Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing choir archive

Wants to store recordings compactly while leaving room for future takes. Compare the capacity and dimensions of the exact HDD model; Western Digital and Toshiba list different thicknesses for different capacities.

Volunteer who transports recordings

Takes the drive along regularly and wants a small device for transferring files between computers. Samsung and Kingston describe compact SSD ranges; also check which connection and cable you need.

Manager of identifiable recordings

For recordings in which people are identifiable, storage is not the only consideration: you also need to manage appropriate access, security and retention periods. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be potential personal data.

What should you consider when choosing?

Portable HDD

A good fit when: the drive is usually stored away and archive capacity is your main priority.

Bear in mind: according to the Consumers’ Association, an HDD is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD; higher-capacity models may also be thicker.

Portable SSD

A good fit when: you regularly take recordings with you or often transfer files between locations.

Bear in mind: check that the capacity suits your files and planned growth; manufacturers’ maximum speeds are no guarantee of performance with your computer or files.

What to consider What should you check? Who should weigh this up more carefully?
Room for future takes Add up your current audio files and planned takes, then compare the capacity and dimensions of the exact model. Western Digital and Toshiba list different thicknesses for different capacities. If I want room for new recordings without needing a bigger space in the cupboard, I look at both capacity and dimensions. Around 36% of consumers say archive space is their top purchasing priority.
Transport and transfers Compare the dimensions of the exact drive and check the computers’ USB ports and required cables. The Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more susceptible to knocks than SSDs. If I regularly take the drive between the rehearsal room and home, its size and ease of connection matter too. Around 27% of consumers prioritise portability and file transfer.
A backup Plan a separate copy, for example in another storage location, and check that you can open files from it. Seagate describes the 3-2-1 approach as backup advice. If a take cannot be recorded again, I don’t want to rely on a single drive. Around 27% of consumers say preserving data is their top purchasing priority.
Computers and file formats Make a note of the systems and USB ports in use. Toshiba specifies NTFS for Canvio Basics and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS; copy your files elsewhere before formatting. If several choir members need to open or save files on different computers, I want to know in advance whether the drive will connect and work with them. Around 10% of consumers prioritise computer compatibility.

What to look out for when buying and using

  • Treating the archive drive as the only copy

    An external drive can be lost or fail. If it holds the only copy, the recording could be lost as a result.

    Plan a second copy before deleting the original from the recording computer. Seagate describes the 3-2-1 approach as backup advice.

  • Assuming all portable drives are equally slim

    Western Digital and Toshiba state that higher-capacity models in their HDD ranges may be thicker.

    Compare both the capacity and dimensions of the exact model with the space you have available for storage.

  • Assuming you need the maximum SSD speed

    Manufacturers quote maximum transfer speeds, but these are not guaranteed speeds for your computer or files. For an archive that is rarely transferred, capacity and a backup may matter more.

    Choose based on how often you transfer files and how much space you need, not just the maximum MB/s shown on the packaging.

  • Forgetting about the computers you use before formatting

    An HDD’s file format may need to be changed for use with macOS. Existing files could be lost in the process if you do not save them elsewhere first.

    Check the systems, ports and file format, and back up your files before formatting.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The My Passport range includes portable HDD models for compact storage. Western Digital lists different thicknesses for different capacities.

  • According to Western Digital, My Passport offers password protection with hardware encryption and a limited three-year manufacturer's warranty.
  • Check the exact model and how it works with Mac; security features are no guarantee that your data will be preserved.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a USB-powered HDD range for straightforward storage. Toshiba lists models with capacities of 1, 2 and 4 TB.

  • According to Toshiba, the drive is ready to use with Windows without installing software and comes with a two-year warranty.
  • Toshiba specifies NTFS and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS; the 4 TB model is thicker than the 2 TB model.

Samsung

The T7 range is a compact SSD option if you regularly take the drive with you and transfer files.

  • Samsung quotes maximum read and write speeds of 1.050 MB/s and 1.000 MB/s for the T7.
  • These are manufacturer figures, not guaranteed speeds for your computer or choir files.

Kingston

The XS1000 is a compact external SSD range available in 1 TB and 2 TB models.

  • Kingston quotes maximum read and write speeds of 1.050 MB/s and 1.000 MB/s.
  • Do not assume the XS1000 has the hardware encryption found in Kingston’s IronKey range.

Seagate

According to its datasheet, the Expansion Portable HDD range is powered via a single USB cable.

  • The connection described does not require a separate power adapter.
  • Seagate states that the Rescue Data Recovery Services mentioned are not available in every country; check the terms for the Netherlands before relying on them.

Joybuy products

These portable HDDs and SSDs are options for storing choir recordings; compare their capacity and size with your archive and the storage space available.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

An option if your archive fits within the stated 1 TB capacity and you’re looking for a portable SSD.

The product information lists read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.

View at Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option if 1 TB suits your archive and the listed connections are compatible with your computers.

The product name lists 2.000 MB/s. The product information mentions USB-C, IP65 protection, drop protection from heights of up to 3 metres and a weight of 46,9 g.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option for a Mac archive where 2 TB is suitable.

The product information lists pre-formatting for Mac, Time Machine support, password protection and a USB-C adapter. The stated weight is 120 g; the dimensions are 75 × 107,2 × 11,15 mm.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD option if your archive needs space for 6 TB and the dimensions fit your available storage space.

The product information lists 256-bit AES hardware encryption and automatic backup software. This 2,5-inch model weighs 210 g and measures 10,7 × 7,5 × 2,06 cm.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option for an archive that needs 2 TB.

The product information lists password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and backup software. According to the information provided, the drive weighs 120 g.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should a choir recording be kept on one drive or in more than one place?

Do not keep an irreplaceable take as the only copy on a single external drive. Seagate describes a separate backup, preferably in another location, as part of the 3-2-1 approach; also check that you can open files from the backup. This is backup advice, not a legal retention requirement for this recording.

Can a Windows drive be used straight away on another choir member’s Mac?

First, check the exact model and configuration. Toshiba specifies NTFS for Canvio Basics and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS. For My Passport, Western Digital lists a downloadable NTFS driver for reading and writing on supported macOS versions; reformatting may be necessary. Copy any existing files before formatting.

How long can recordings of identifiable choir members be kept?

If people are identifiable in an audio recording, it may contain personal data. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR does not set a specific general retention period: decide on a period that is necessary for the purpose, choose an appropriate legal basis before processing and ensure suitable security. The legal basis and retention period for an individual choir will depend on the circumstances.

What can you do if the external drive fails?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller must offer a solution if the product is faulty, according to the Dutch government. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; a manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your statutory rights and does not replace them. A warranty on the drive is not the same as recovering lost recordings.