Choir archive manager
You want to be able to restore recordings after a mistake or drive problem, and decide who manages the archive. The NCSC recommends arranging a separate backup alongside central storage.
For choir recordings, a NAS is best suited to use as a shared archive, provided you also arrange a separate, restorable backup and transfer complete project files from your portable workstation. The NCSC stresses that central storage and RAID are not a backup in themselves. A 2.5GbE port is only worth considering if your computer and the rest of your network can make use of it too.
You want to be able to restore recordings after a mistake or drive problem, and decide who manages the archive. The NCSC recommends arranging a separate backup alongside central storage.
You want designated choir members to be able to find files on their own computers, without giving everyone administrator rights. Synology describes file sharing for the DS223j; check the access options on the model you’re considering.
You also work away from your usual network and want to transfer all the project components to the archive after a session. Apple Support warns that Logic Pro projects may refer to external audio files that aren’t automatically included when you copy them.
Start with a restorable copy and a complete transfer of the recording. Then consider shared access, and only after that look at network speed. This helps ensure an extra-fast port doesn’t seem more important than being able to restore your files.
| Consideration | What to look for | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable recordings | Check whether you can use a separate backup destination and test that you can restore files from it. | If I want to be able to restore recordings after a drive problem, I need a separate copy and a restore test. Around 36% of consumers put restorability first. |
| Shared access | Check user and folder permissions, support for the computers you use, and who manages the accounts. | When several choir members need to find files on their own computers, I want to be able to manage access by user. Around 29% of consumers prioritise shared access without overly broad permissions. |
| Transfer from the workstation | Check how the computer connects and whether your recording software can gather all the project files you need. | After a rehearsal, I want to be able to transfer the entire session, including files referenced by the project. For around 21% of consumers, this transfer is the main priority. |
| Storage and setup | Check whether drives are included, which drives are compatible with the model, and how you’ll store a separate backup. | I want to know in advance what else I’ll need to set up the complete archive. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the overall purchase requirements. |
The NCSC explains that RAID and central storage don’t replace a separate backup. A problem that affects the NAS could therefore affect both the storage and its mirrored copy.
Plan a backup to a different destination and test that you can restore a file from it.
Logic Pro projects may still refer to external audio files if those files haven’t been included in the project. A copied project folder may therefore not contain everything you need.
Use your recording software’s features to gather the necessary project components, then open the copy from its archive location.
A 2.5GbE port won’t automatically make transfers faster if your computer or other network equipment is a bottleneck.
Check the connections on your workstation and all the equipment along the transfer path before choosing a faster port.
Some versions don’t include storage drives. A separate backup also needs a different destination.
Check which drives are included with each model and which are compatible, and plan separately where your backup will be stored.
Synology describes the DS223j as a two-bay model for file sharing and backups. According to Synology, the separate DS225+ has a 2.5GbE port.
The QNAP TS-233 is a two-bay model for central storage and access from computers.
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T combines two drive bays with 2.5GbE.
The NASync DXP2800 is a diskless two-bay option with 2.5GbE.
These NAS models have 2.5GbE. This connection is most relevant if your workstation and network also support the higher speed.
Image unavailable
An option if you’re looking for a central archive with file sharing and can make use of a 2.5GbE network connection.
Five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included.
Image unavailable
An option if you’re looking for network storage with file sharing and backup features, and can make use of the network connection.
Eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports.
Image unavailable
An option if you’re looking for a central archive with file sharing and backup features, and have a suitable 2.5GbE network connection.
Four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included.
No. RAID can help keep a NAS available if a drive fails, but the NCSC says it doesn’t replace a backup. Make a separate copy too, and check that you can restore files from it.
Check that the audio files referenced by the project are included, then open the copy in its new location. Apple Support specifically highlights external files when copying Logic Pro projects. For other recording software, check its project management features.
If you’re only using the NAS for local archiving, it doesn’t need to be accessible from the internet. The NCSC recommends, where possible, not making a NAS directly accessible over the internet, and checking access permissions and default settings too. This is security advice, not a general legal ban.
According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, audio recordings in which someone can be recognised may contain personal data. If the GDPR applies to the choir’s processing of the recording, you’ll need a valid legal basis. Consent is one possible basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one. Decide who should have access and consider how you intend to use the recording before sharing it further.
It depends on the rights to the repertoire and how you intend to use it. The Dutch Government notes that you may need permission from the creator to use copyright-protected music. Check the rights before the choir shares the recording publicly.