Who might need a capture card?

Console reviewer with a streaming PC

Wants to discuss gameplay from a separate console in OBS. OBS Project describes capture cards as video capture sources; also check that the HDMI source and computer connection are compatible with the model you choose.

Reviewer with a high-refresh-rate gaming display

Wants to keep playing on a high-refresh-rate display while discussing the game. Elgato and AVerMedia publish passthrough and recording modes for individual models; compare these with the settings you want to use for your source and display.

Reviewer providing live commentary

Wants to stream clear commentary or group chat alongside gameplay. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio source in two places can cause an echo, so test your microphone and game audio setup beforehand.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, work out where your video is coming from. Then compare recording quality, passthrough to your gaming display and the route for your commentary. These features answer different questions.

What to consider What to check before buying Which consumers prioritise it
Connection and compatibility Check the source’s HDMI output, the USB port or PCIe slot, the operating system and the supported recording software. If I want to connect a standalone console to my streaming PC, the whole setup needs to work before I can record. Around 33% of consumers say compatibility is their top priority.
Recording quality Compare the resolution and frame rate you want to record with the specifications of the exact model and the software you use. If I want to review and discuss clips, I need to know what will actually be recorded, not just what the card can pass through. Around 27% of consumers prioritise how usable the recording is.
Passthrough to your display Compare the resolution, Hz, HDR and VRR of your source and display with the card’s passthrough modes. If I want to keep playing on my usual gaming display during the review, I want to retain my preferred display mode. Around 20% of consumers consider passthrough their main priority.
Commentary and game audio Map out the signal paths for HDMI audio, your headset, microphone and group chat, then check a test recording for missing or duplicated audio. If I’m providing live commentary, I want both my voice and the game audio to come through clearly. Around 20% of consumers put their audio setup first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming you need a capture card to record a game running on the same PC

    OBS can capture compatible games directly from the same Windows PC. An HDMI capture card isn’t necessarily needed if the game and OBS are running on that computer.

    An extra card also means another device and more connections in your setup.

    First, work out whether the video is coming from the same PC or a separate HDMI device. For a compatible Windows game, try OBS Game Capture.

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    Passthrough and recording are separate features. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but can’t record it to the computer in 4K.

    For the exact model, check both the recording and passthrough modes and compare them with the software you use.

  • Assuming an HDMI connection will capture any tournament footage

    Elgato says its capture cards don’t capture HDMI signals protected by HDCP. Also, having a working connection doesn’t automatically give you permission to stream protected material.

    Check where the video is coming from and what rights apply to your planned stream. Don’t plan to bypass copy protection.

  • Assuming an older model is still available

    On its European Dutch-language product page, Elgato says the HD60 X is no longer available.

    Before buying, check that the exact model and variant are actually on sale.

Relevant brands to consider

Elgato

The external HD60 X, 4K S and 4K X, and the internal 4K Pro are models worth comparing for recording, passthrough and connectivity.

  • For the 4K X, Elgato specifies HDMI 2.1 and USB 3.2 Gen 2; for the 4K Pro, it lists HDMI 2.1 and a PCIe 2.0 x4 slot.
  • Elgato’s European Dutch-language product page says the HD60 X is no longer available. A model listing doesn’t necessarily mean it’s currently in stock.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is an external HDMI 2.1 option worth comparing if high refresh rates are important.

  • AVerMedia states that this model can record at up to 4K144 when used with Streaming Center on Windows.
  • For OBS on Mac, AVerMedia specifies 4K60. These maximum figures are from the manufacturer and don’t guarantee that your entire setup will support those modes.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is worth considering if 1080p recording is enough and you’re using a separate HDMI source.

  • NZXT says the card can pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 doesn’t record in 4K and doesn’t support HDR. Also check the USB connection required.

Razer

Razer positions the Ripsaw X as a way to connect a separate HDMI camera to a computer.

  • For this model, Razer specifies recording at up to 4K30 via USB 3.0.
  • This camera-focused use isn’t shown to be a substitute for a card with HDMI passthrough to a separate gaming display.

Joybuy products

This selection focuses on external USB capture cards for a separate HDMI source, used with a PC or laptop. Check the recording and passthrough modes for each model against your equipment.

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card for gaming and streaming

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, 1080p60 recording

For a separate HDMI source when you want to record on a PC or laptop.

The product name specifies HDMI input up to 4K 30Hz and recording at 1080p 60Hz.

The product name specifies compatibility with PC and laptop.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with 4K passthrough

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with 4K passthrough

For a separate HDMI source if you’re looking for 1080p recording and 4K passthrough.

The product name specifies video recording up to 1080p and 4K HDMI passthrough.

The product name specifies UVC and UAC support, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card for a game running on the same PC?

Not necessarily. OBS Project describes Game Capture as a source that captures a compatible game directly, so try that first. For footage from a separate HDMI console or second PC, you’ll need a suitable video capture source.

How do I connect the card and check my commentary?

Add a suitable HDMI source and the capture card to your setup, following the instructions for the exact model, then select the card in OBS as a video capture device. Add your microphone as the appropriate audio source and make a test recording to check that both your voice and the game audio are audible without an echo. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio source in multiple places can cause an echo.

Does 4K passthrough mean my review will be recorded in 4K?

No, that doesn’t automatically follow from the passthrough specification. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but can’t record it to the computer in 4K. For each model, compare the recording and passthrough modes separately.

Can I stream protected tournament footage using a capture card?

Don’t assume that you can. Elgato says its capture cards don’t capture HDMI signals protected by HDCP. In the Netherlands, publishing copyrighted footage generally requires permission, subject to any applicable legal exceptions; also check the rights for the specific material. The Dutch government says copy protection must not be bypassed.

What warranty applies when buying a capture card in the Netherlands?

There’s no set statutory warranty period in the Netherlands that applies to every product. The Dutch government says statutory warranty is based on what you can reasonably expect from the product; check the terms for your specific purchase.