Who is this choice relevant to?

Creator with one recording computer

You demonstrate software on the same computer you use to record and want to know whether you need any extra hardware. OBS Project describes screen and window sources for capturing footage directly.

Creator with a separate demo computer

You want to record the HDMI output from a second computer and need to match the capture mode, any passthrough and the audio routing to your setup.

Creator with a camera or multiple sources

You want to add an HDMI camera or switch between physical video sources during a presentation. Elgato describes a camera as an HDMI source for Cam Link 4K; the number of inputs and features vary between ATEM Mini models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by identifying where the footage is coming from: the same computer, one external HDMI source or multiple sources. This will help you decide whether direct capture, a capture device or a mixer is right for your setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Do you need extra hardware? Work out which computer runs the software and which one you use to record. If they’re the same computer, try screen or window capture first. If I’m demonstrating software on my recording computer, I don’t want to connect an HDMI device unless I need to. Around 36% of consumers prioritise whether extra hardware is necessary.
Video and passthrough Check the HDMI input, capture modes and passthrough modes separately for the exact model. Make a test recording of small interface text. If small text needs to stay legible and I want to see the source footage on a monitor at the same time, I look at both capture and passthrough. Around 29% of consumers prioritise this combination.
Camera and audio Map out how the computer, camera, microphone and capture device are connected. Check video and audio separately in your recording software. If I want to combine my camera footage and demo in one recording, I also need to know which audio source is being captured. Around 21% of consumers start by considering how everything works together.
Host computer and purchase terms Check the operating system, USB connection and source format, as well as the terms for the specific order and any additional warranty. If my recording computer and the terms after purchase are decisive, I check them before choosing a model. Around 14% of consumers prioritise these points.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a capture card for software running on the same computer

    OBS Project offers sources for capturing a screen or window directly. A capture card doesn’t automatically add a necessary HDMI source to this setup.

    Start with a short, direct screen recording. Only choose HDMI hardware if you need footage from another device.

    Extra hardware also means extra connections to set up.

  • Assuming ‘4K’ means the same input, capture and passthrough mode

    Modes can vary by function and model. AVerMedia specifies a maximum of 1080p60 for both capture and passthrough on the Live Gamer MINI GC311; Elgato lists separate capture and passthrough modes for the Game Capture 4K S.

    Check the specifications for the exact model and compare the modes you actually need. Test whether the smallest interface text is still legible in a sample recording.

  • Assuming every HDMI signal can be recorded

    According to Elgato, its capture devices can’t record HDMI signals protected by HDCP. Being able to record something technically is also a separate matter from having the right to publish the footage.

    Check the source and the exact device. Don’t make bypassing copy protection part of your recording plan.

  • Assuming an additional warranty covers all your statutory rights

    The Government of the Netherlands states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. Your right to a product that works as it should is separate from the manufacturer’s warranty or a paid additional warranty.

    Check what an additional warranty actually covers, and contact the retailer if a product is faulty.

Relevant brands to consider

Elgato

Elgato offers several HDMI options: Cam Link 4K for one compatible HDMI source, and Game Capture 4K S for capture with passthrough.

  • According to Elgato, Cam Link 4K supports up to 1080p60, among other formats. Elgato lists capture up to 2160p60 and separate passthrough modes for Game Capture 4K S.
  • Elgato states that HDR capture on Game Capture 4K S is currently only available on Windows. For claims about 2160p60, check the exact Cam Link 4K version and camera compatibility.

AVerMedia

Live Gamer MINI GC311 provides an HDMI-to-USB connection for an external Full HD source, with HDMI passthrough.

  • AVerMedia specifies a maximum of 1080p60 for both capture and passthrough, and lists a built-in H.264 encoder.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals. Also check the system requirements for your specific host computer.

Magewell

USB Capture HDMI Gen 2 is designed to capture one HDMI source via USB.

  • Magewell lists support for Windows, macOS, Linux and Chrome OS, as well as compatibility with OBS.
  • Magewell warns that the actual capture frame rate may be limited by USB bandwidth and internal processing. So compare the specific input and output modes.

Blackmagic Design

The ATEM Mini range offers a mixer option if you want to combine or switch between multiple physical HDMI sources while recording.

  • Blackmagic Design describes HDMI inputs and a USB output that a computer recognises as a webcam.
  • The number of inputs and features such as multiview vary between ATEM Mini models, so check the version you’re considering.

Products at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a second computer for a software demo?

Connect the HDMI output from the demo computer to the input on a compatible capture device, then connect that device to the recording computer. If you also want to see the source footage on a monitor, check that the exact model has HDMI passthrough and supports the input, capture and passthrough modes you need.

What should I check if OBS records video but no usable audio?

Check what audio is coming in over HDMI and which microphone or other audio source is selected in OBS. OBS Project offers separate audio sources and settings for audio output from a video capture device. Make a short test recording before the full demo.

Why is my HDMI capture showing a black screen?

One possible cause is HDCP protection: according to Elgato, Elgato capture devices can’t record a protected HDMI signal. Also check that the exact device supports the source resolution and frame rate. A capture card doesn’t give you permission to distribute protected content or someone else’s copyrighted work.

What return and warranty rights apply to an online purchase in the Netherlands?

For distance purchases from a business, you usually have 14 days to change your mind, although there are exceptions, according to the Government of the Netherlands. There is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; you’re entitled to a product that works as it should and can contact the retailer if there’s a fault. Also check the terms that apply to your specific order.

Can I publish a software demo that shows personal data?

First consider what information is visible, the purpose of publication and the circumstances. The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between strictly personal or household use and wider distribution; where personal data is processed, a GDPR legal basis may be required. Whether a particular recording can be published depends on the circumstances.