Who is this choice relevant to?

Console analyst with a gaming screen

Want to discuss gameplay while keeping the picture on your own screen? Compare recording and HDMI pass-through separately. For example, Elgato specifies 1080p60 recording and 4K60 HDR pass-through for Game Capture Neo.

Commentator using multiple audio sources

If you want to connect and control tournament footage, a microphone and headphones, check which audio connections are available. RØDE’s manual describes these connections for Streamer X.

Creator making detailed replays

If you want to save replays at a higher resolution or frame rate, check that your source, computer and software support the mode you want. Elgato and AVerMedia list different recording and pass-through modes for their individual models.

What to consider when choosing

First decide what you want to record and which screen and audio connections you’ll need during the review. Then check that the capture card and your computer support that combination.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who this matters to
Keeping your gaming screen Check HDMI pass-through and recording mode separately; pass-through doesn’t automatically determine recording quality. If I want to keep playing on my own screen while discussing the footage, I look for pass-through as well as recording. Around 33% of consumers give keeping their gaming screen top priority.
Connecting your commentary setup Check the microphone input, headphone output and how you can manage HDMI audio. If I want to comment and listen at the same time, the right audio connections matter. Around 27% of consumers prioritise audio controls.
Recording detailed replays Compare the recording settings and the requirements for your source, computer and software. If I want to save replays at a higher resolution or frame rate, I check the exact mode supported. Around 20% of consumers prioritise recording detail.
Connecting to your computer Check your computer port, operating system and support in your recording software. For a setup in a spare room, I want to know whether the card connects to my computer; an internal PCIe card needs a compatible desktop. Around 20% of consumers prioritise computer connectivity.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K pass-through with 4K recording

    For Game Capture Neo, Elgato specifies 4K60 HDR pass-through but 1080p60 recording. So the picture mode on your screen doesn’t automatically tell you what your recording files will be like.

    Compare the recording mode with the files you want to keep for your review, separately from your gaming screen’s mode.

  • Assuming a maximum frame rate without checking the software requirements

    AVerMedia’s stated 4K144 recording for GC553G2 requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; this mode isn’t automatically available with other software combinations.

    Check the requirements for your operating system and recording software before relying on a maximum frame rate.

  • Assuming a working HDMI recording setup gives you broadcasting rights

    A capture card records footage, but it doesn’t determine whether you can share that material publicly. The Dutch government explains that permission from the creator may be needed to use copyright-protected material; privacy rules may also apply to recognisable people.

    Before streaming, check the rights that apply to the tournament footage. If people are recognisable, also consider the relevant privacy rules.

Brands to compare

Elgato

For Game Capture Neo, Elgato specifies 1080p60 recording with 4K60 HDR pass-through. The brand lists 4K60 recording for Game Capture 4K S.

  • The separate recording and pass-through modes make it easier to compare these two functions for each model.
  • Game Capture Neo’s pass-through isn’t 4K recording; check which recording files you need.

AVerMedia

AVerMedia describes Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1, model GC553G2, as an external HDMI 2.1 capture card and lists features including 4K120 pass-through.

  • The stated pass-through mode gives you a useful point of comparison if you’re looking at higher pass-through modes.
  • The stated 4K144 recording requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; check whether these requirements suit your setup.

RØDE

RØDE Streamer X combines HDMI capture with audio connections, including an XLR/TRS combo input and a headphone output, according to the manual.

  • This combination may suit a review setup where you manage a microphone, headphones and HDMI source together.
  • The extra audio controls may be unnecessary if you already use a suitable microphone interface.

Blackmagic Design

Blackmagic Design describes DeckLink Mini Recorder 4K as an internal PCIe card with HDMI and SDI inputs.

  • This internal card may suit a permanent setup in a desktop with a compatible PCIe connection.
  • Blackmagic Design lists recording up to 2160p30; check that this frame rate and the desktop connection suit your source.

Razer

Razer describes Ripsaw X as a capture card for an HDMI camera and lists 4K30 capture and OBS compatibility.

  • Its stated use is well suited to capturing an HDMI camera as a video source.
  • If you also want to send the picture to a separate gaming screen, check explicitly that the connection you choose supports this.

Joybuy products for recording gameplay

This product selection focuses on external HDMI capture cards for recording gameplay and, if needed, sending the picture to a gaming screen. Check the recording and pass-through modes separately.

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, 1080p60 recording, black and red

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, 1080p60 recording, black and red

The described HDMI loop-out may be useful if you also want to monitor the picture on a second screen while recording.

The product name lists 1080p60 recording and an HDMI input of up to 4K 30Hz; this input mode is not the recording mode. The description also mentions a microphone input, headphone output and use with OBS.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

The listed 4K HDMI pass-through and capture up to 1080p may be relevant if you want to pass through and record footage; check that both modes suit your setup.

The product name lists UVC and UAC support, driver-free installation, a microphone input and a headphone output. Capture is specified up to 1080p; 4K refers to pass-through, not the recording mode.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you add a capture card to a review in OBS?

Connect a compatible HDMI source to the capture card, connect the card to your computer, then add a video capture source in OBS. OBS Project explains how to add video devices as sources; also check the connection and driver requirements for your chosen model.

Why does a capture card sometimes fail to show video from a streaming service?

Elgato says its capture devices can’t record HDMI signals with HDCP protection enabled. This technical limitation doesn’t in itself give you permission to broadcast protected footage; check the rights for third-party material separately.

Can you livestream tournament footage or recognisable people in the Netherlands without permission?

Don’t assume that you can. According to the Dutch government, permission from the creator may be needed to use copyright-protected material publicly. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that filming and publishing recognisable people may require a lawful basis. Before broadcasting, establish which rights and privacy rules apply to your footage.

What are your rights if the capture card isn’t suitable for your setup?

For an online purchase in the Netherlands, ACM ConsuWijzer says you generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, with some exceptions. This is separate from your rights against the seller if a product is faulty; check the terms that apply to your purchase.