Who is a capture card suitable for?

Students recording slides on a single laptop

If your presentation and recording are running on the same computer, you can select the screen or a window as a source in OBS. OBS Project explains both options, so try screen recording before buying any extra hardware.

Students using a separate HDMI camera

If you want to record yourself alongside your presentation, check that the camera provides a compatible, unencrypted HDMI signal with a clean output. Elgato outlines these requirements for Cam Link 4K.

Students who want to show the picture on a separate display at the same time

If you also need to keep a separate HDMI source visible on an external display, look for HDMI pass-through. AVerMedia lists this feature for the Live Gamer MINI GC311.

What should you look for when choosing one?

Start by looking at where the picture is coming from: your own screen needs a different solution from a separate HDMI source. Then decide whether the signal also needs to go to a second display, and how you’ll record your voice.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Presentation picture Check whether the slides are on the computer you’re recording on or come from a second HDMI device. If I only want to record my own screen, I first want to know whether screen recording is enough. Around 33% of consumers prioritise capturing slides without unnecessary hardware.
Separate camera Check the HDMI output, clean output, cable and whether the camera stays switched on during recording. If you want to record yourself alongside the presentation, you need a camera that outputs a compatible HDMI signal. Around 25% of consumers prioritise capturing camera footage.
Spoken voice Check which microphone is active in your recording software and listen to a short test recording. If my explanation needs to be easy to hear, I check the microphone separately from the picture. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recording spoken audio.
Display output Check whether the model has an HDMI output for pass-through, and compare the pass-through and recording specifications separately. If you also want to show the HDMI source on an external display while recording, a suitable pass-through feature is useful. Around 17% of consumers make displaying the picture on a screen at the same time their top buying priority.

Common mistakes

  • Buying a capture card just to record your own screen

    OBS can use your own screen or a window directly as a source. A capture card is designed to capture video from a separate source.

    Before buying, check whether your picture is coming from a second device with an HDMI output.

  • Assuming HDMI pass-through and recording resolution are the same specification

    The maximum pass-through resolution may differ from the maximum recording resolution. One figure doesn’t automatically tell you what the device can record.

    For the exact model, compare the input, recording and pass-through specifications separately, and check whether it has an HDMI output.

  • Testing only the picture

    Seeing your presentation doesn’t mean that your chosen microphone or other audio will be included in the recording. OBS treats video and audio sources separately.

    Make a short test recording and check both the picture and your voice. Don’t accidentally select the same audio source twice, as this can cause an echo.

Brands to compare

Elgato

Cam Link 4K converts HDMI to USB 3.0, allowing you to use a compatible camera as a video source on a computer.

  • Elgato lists support for formats including 1080p60. The stated support for 2160p60 applies only to compatible cameras and the latest Cam Link 4K model.
  • Check that the camera provides unencrypted, preferably clean, HDMI output, and that the exact camera and product version are compatible.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for a single HDMI source when you also want to pass the signal through to a display.

  • AVerMedia specifies HDMI input and HDMI pass-through, with up to 1080p60 for both recording and pass-through.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals. Also check the recording computer’s system requirements.

Magewell

USB Capture HDMI Gen 2 is an HDMI-to-USB capture solution with embedded audio.

  • Magewell lists USB 3.0 and support for Windows, Linux, Mac and Chrome OS.
  • Magewell warns that the actual recording frame rate may be limited by USB bandwidth and internal processing. HDMI pass-through isn’t specified for Gen 2.

Joybuy products for a separate HDMI source

This selection of Joybuy products focuses on recording a separate HDMI source, including a model listed with pass-through to a display.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0, 4K pass-through and microphone and headphone sockets

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0, 4K Pass-through

Suitable if you want to record a separate HDMI source and also pass the signal through to a display.

USB 3.0; video recording up to 1080p; 4K pass-through; driver-free installation; microphone input and headphone output.

Recording is listed as supporting up to 1080p; 4K applies to pass-through.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a separate HDMI source in OBS?

Connect the source’s HDMI output to the capture card’s HDMI input, then connect the card to the computer you’re recording on. In OBS, add a video capture device, select the device and a supported resolution and frame rate, then make a short test recording.

How can I stop my voice from being missing or sounding doubled?

Select the microphone you want to use as the audio input and listen to a test recording. OBS warns that selecting the same audio source in both the general audio settings and separately in a scene can cause an echo.

Which recording file format is practical for a long presentation?

OBS recommends MKV because an unexpected interruption won’t necessarily corrupt the whole file. If you need MP4 afterwards, OBS has a remuxing feature to convert the recording.

What can I do if the capture card isn’t working properly?

If the product is faulty, you can contact the seller to ask for a solution. The Government of the Netherlands states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. Any manufacturer’s warranty is also separate from your statutory rights.

Can I record fellow students who can be identified and share the presentation?

That depends on who makes the recording, its purpose and how you share it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that an organisation needs a legal basis to create and publish footage in which people can be identified; consent is often the most appropriate basis. If you’re making a recording of a student event, check with the people involved and your educational institution what has been agreed before filming or sharing it.