Who is this buying guide for?

Console player with a laptop

You want to display a separate console in OBS via HDMI and need to check that your source, capture card and laptop will work together. OBS Studio describes a capture device as a way to bring console footage into OBS.

Co-op host with party chat

You want to bring game audio, your teammates’ voices and your own commentary together in the stream. For a PS5 setup, Elgato explains that connected headphones can affect game audio over HDMI.

Player with a high-refresh-rate screen

You want to keep your preferred picture mode on a separate screen while streaming. Compare HDMI pass-through and recording separately, as Elgato and AVerMedia list different modes for different models.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether OBS runs on the same device as the game. Then compare the HDMI pass-through, recording settings and separate audio setup you need.

What to consider What to look for Who should prioritise it
Source and computer Is the game running on the same Windows PC as OBS? If not, check the HDMI output and the exact model’s USB or PCIe connection requirements. If I want to connect a separate console to my laptop, I first need to know whether the source, card and computer will work together. Around 33% of consumers say compatibility is their top buying priority.
Game audio and voices Work out where the game audio, party chat and microphone audio are coming from; test the recording and listen back. When I play with others, I want viewers to hear both the game audio and the voices clearly. Around 27% of consumers give a complete co-op audio mix top priority.
Gaming screen and recording Compare HDMI pass-through and recording separately, including resolution, refresh rate, HDR and any VRR support. When I play on a separate screen, I want to keep my preferred picture mode without assuming the recording will support the same mode. Around 20% of consumers put their gaming screen first.
Connections and accessories Check the available ports, required cables and whether your setup needs an HDMI output to a separate screen. In a small room, I want to keep my setup simple and know in advance which connections and cables I’ll need. Around 20% of consumers say a straightforward setup matters most.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K’ means 4K recording

    Pass-through and recording can have different limits. For example, Elgato lists up to 4K60 pass-through and 1080p60 recording for Game Capture Neo. NZXT says Signal HD60 can pass through 4K, but can’t record or stream in 4K to a computer.

    Compare HDMI input, monitor pass-through and recording as separate specifications for the exact model.

  • Assuming HDMI carries all your co-op voices

    The audio route depends on your console, headset and OBS settings. In the PS5 setup described by Elgato, connecting headphones can stop game audio from coming through HDMI.

    Check where each sound is coming from and make a test recording before your stream so you can listen back.

    Depending on the audio setup, you may need additional compatible connections or cables.

  • Choosing a capture device without HDMI pass-through when you play on a separate screen

    Sandberg 134-19 is listed with HDMI-in and USB-A-out; the manufacturer doesn’t list an HDMI output for monitor pass-through.

    Before buying, check whether you need to pass the signal through the same card to a separate gaming screen.

  • Checking only the card, not the cables and ports

    Elgato doesn’t list an HDMI cable as included with Game Capture Neo. For connecting to a USB-C port, the manufacturer recommends a suitable USB 3.0 cable or adapter.

    Compare the included accessories with the connections on your console, laptop and monitor.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Elgato offers external models with different combinations of HDMI pass-through and recording. These specifications come from the manufacturer and aren’t an independent performance test.

  • Game Capture Neo lists up to 4K60 pass-through and 1080p60 recording.
  • HD60 X and 4K X offer different pass-through and recording modes; 4K X requires you to pay attention to the USB connection.
  • Game Capture Neo doesn’t include an HDMI cable and has no listed analogue audio input.

AVerMedia

The range includes external capture cards and an internal PCIe card; connection types and features vary by model.

  • Live Gamer MINI GC311 lists up to 1080p60 for both pass-through and recording.
  • Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is designed for higher HDMI modes; the manufacturer says certain modes require specific software and system configurations.
  • According to AVerMedia, GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals. Live Gamer 4K GC573 is an internal PCIe Gen 2 x4 card.

Sandberg

HDMI Capture Link to USB-A 134-19 is an HDMI-to-USB capture device for setups that don’t need HDMI pass-through to a separate screen.

  • The manufacturer lists HDMI audio and recording up to 1080p30.
  • The listed connections are HDMI-in and USB-A-out; don’t expect this capture device to pass HDMI through to a monitor.

NZXT

Signal HD60 is an external option for an HDMI source, provided its connections and recording capabilities suit your setup.

  • According to NZXT, the card can receive and pass through a 4K signal.
  • NZXT says Signal HD60 can’t record or stream in 4K to a computer and doesn’t support HDR.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These product picks are external HDMI capture cards for connecting a separate source to a computer. If you use a separate gaming screen, check the exact model’s HDMI pass-through and recording settings.

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card with 1080p60 recording

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, 1080p60 recording

For a separate HDMI source; the product description mentions HDMI loop-out for a second screen, so check that it supports your preferred picture mode.

The title lists HDMI input up to 4K 30Hz and recording up to 1080p60. The 4K figure doesn’t refer to recording.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0, 4K pass-through and UVC/UAC

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0, 1080p capture, 4K pass-through, UVC/UAC

For anyone who wants to capture an HDMI source and use a separate screen; check that the pass-through supports your preferred picture mode.

The title lists capture up to 1080p, 4K HDMI pass-through, UVC/UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output. Here, 4K refers to pass-through, not recording.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0, 4K pass-through and driver-free setup

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0, 1080p capture, 4K pass-through, driver-free setup

For a separate HDMI source; if you use a second screen while gaming, check the pass-through required for your setup.

The title lists capture up to 1080p, 4K pass-through, a microphone input and a headphone output. The 4K figure isn’t a recording specification.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if the game is running on my streaming PC?

Not necessarily: if the game and OBS are running on the same Windows PC, OBS Studio recommends trying Game Capture first. For console footage in OBS, OBS Studio describes using a capture device or an alternative method that depends on your network.

Will a capture card also record my teammates’ voices?

Not necessarily; game audio, party chat and microphone audio can come from different sources. For a PS5 setup with Game Capture Neo, Elgato says that connecting headphones to the console or controller can stop game audio from coming through HDMI. Test each audio source before going live.

How do I add a capture card to OBS?

In OBS, add a Video Capture Device source and select the device. Choose a resolution and frame rate supported by the capture card, then set up audio and monitoring separately.

Can I capture gameplay from a Nintendo Switch Lite via HDMI?

Not using the usual dock and HDMI setup: Nintendo Netherlands says the Switch Lite doesn’t support TV mode. So check the capabilities of your exact console before choosing a capture card for your setup.

Does 4K pass-through mean the capture card also records in 4K?

No, pass-through and recording are separate features. For the exact model, compare the HDMI pass-through to your screen with the listed recording settings. For example, Elgato lists up to 4K60 pass-through and 1080p60 recording for Game Capture Neo.