Who is this setup for?

Streamer in a shared bedroom

You want to listen and speak quietly, while keeping commentary and game audio easy to control separately. OBS Project explains how to set up audio sources and monitoring; check these settings alongside your choice of capture card.

Console commentator with a separate monitor

You connect a console to a computer, but also want to keep a suitable picture on your monitor while discussing the action. Compare the HDMI input, passthrough and recording modes separately; Elgato, for example, lists different maximum specifications for the Game Capture Neo.

Replay and detail analyst

You want to revisit specific moments in a game and need to decide whether 1080p60 is enough or whether you need higher recording quality. Compare the model’s recording mode with the software and settings you plan to use.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check your audio and source connections. Then decide which monitor and recording settings you need, and finally check which cables and connections you’re missing.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Commentary and game audio Check where your headset connects and whether OBS is capturing the same audio source twice. If I stream from a shared bedroom, I want my commentary to be clear without echo or unnecessarily loud audio. Around 29% of this group are likely to put sound quality first.
Monitor picture Compare your preferred monitor resolution and refresh rate with both the passthrough and recording modes. I want to keep my own monitor picture while discussing the action, rather than assume passthrough also indicates recording quality. Around 23% of this group are likely to make preserving their monitor picture their main priority.
Source and computer Make a note of your source, HDMI output, computer port and intended recording software; also check your console’s audio output. When I connect a console, I want to know in advance whether the source, computer and software will work together. Around 18% of this group are likely to prioritise compatibility.
Recording detail Compare the recording setting you actually need with the mode available on the exact model and its software requirements. For replays and detailed analysis, I want to capture enough picture information without choosing higher specifications I don’t need. Around 18% of this group are likely to prioritise recording detail.
Cables and accessories Check what’s included in the box, which HDMI cables you have available and which USB port your computer has. I want to connect the whole setup without discovering after purchase that I’m missing a cable. Around 12% of this group are likely to prioritise having all the necessary connections and accessories.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    A passthrough signal to your monitor doesn’t automatically tell you what resolution the card can send to your recording software. Elgato lists a maximum of 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 recording for the Game Capture Neo.

    Before buying, compare your preferred monitor settings with the model’s separately listed recording modes.

  • Expecting a capture card to fix echo or excessive noise

    A card won’t automatically control how your microphone, headset and game audio are captured in OBS. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio device twice can cause echo.

    Make a short test recording, listen back through your headset and check both your global and scene-specific audio sources.

  • Leaving cables and headset connections until after you buy

    According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo doesn’t come with an HDMI cable. The PS5 setup described with the Neo needs two HDMI cables; using a headset with the console or controller may also affect game audio over HDMI.

    Map out the connections between your source, card, monitor and computer, then compare them with what’s in the box and the cables you already own.

  • Assuming you can broadcast tournament footage freely

    The Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or making protected material available to the public. Being able to record footage doesn’t automatically mean you’re allowed to publish the broadcast.

    For the footage in question, check what permission or applicable exception applies, and don’t broadcast more material than you have a valid legal basis to use.

Brands to consider

Elgato

According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo, HD60 X and 4K S offer different combinations of recording, passthrough and audio connections.

  • Elgato lists a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 for the Game Capture Neo. The HD60 X has a 3.5mm line-in and several passthrough modes, according to the manufacturer.
  • The Neo doesn’t come with an HDMI cable. Treat passthrough and recording modes as separate specifications.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia, the Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for Full HD, while the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 has more extensive listed HDMI and recording modes.

  • AVerMedia describes the GC311 as offering Full HD passthrough and a built-in H.264 encoder.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC553G2’s stated 4K144 recording applies when using Streaming Center on Windows in MJPEG. The manufacturer lists 4K60 for OBS on Mac; don’t take this to mean that’s a general OBS specification.

NZXT

According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 is an external option for connecting a compatible HDMI source to a streaming computer.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, the model can’t record or stream that signal to a computer in 4K and doesn’t support HDR.

Joybuy products for capture card setups

A Joybuy product option for an HDMI capture setup where 1080p recording and microphone and headphone connections are useful.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0, 4K passthrough, and microphone and headphone connections

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

The listed connections may be useful if you want to use a microphone and headphones in your setup; check they’re compatible with your source and preferred audio setup.

The product title lists video recording up to 1080p and 4K passthrough: the stated 4K refers to passthrough, not recording.

The title also mentions driver-free installation, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I simply discuss someone else’s tournament footage live?

Not just because you can technically capture the footage. The Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or making protected material available to the public. For the tournament in question, check who owns the rights and what permission or applicable exception applies; a short, relevant discussion isn’t the same as rebroadcasting an entire match.

What if my housemate is recognisable in a public stream?

Consider this before publishing and, where possible, keep housemates out of shot. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use doesn’t apply when footage is shared more widely, for example in public. Consent may be a possible legal basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one.

How do I add a capture card in OBS without getting duplicate audio?

Add the card as a video capture device, then check your audio sources and monitoring. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio device both globally and in a scene can cause echo. Start with a short test recording and listen back through your headset.

Why is my PS5 setup showing a black screen or no game audio?

For the PS5 setup described with the Game Capture Neo, Elgato says HDCP must be disabled to capture the console signal. Elgato also notes that connecting a headset to the PS5 or controller may mean game audio isn’t output over HDMI. These technical steps don’t in themselves give you permission to rebroadcast protected broadcasts.

What can I do if my capture card stops working too soon under normal use?

Contact the retailer to discuss a suitable solution. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that, in addition to any manufacturer’s warranty, you have a legal guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use. There isn’t one fixed warranty period that automatically applies to every capture card.