If you play and record on the same PC, try capturing the game directly in OBS first; a capture card usually won’t add anything. If you use a console or a second gaming PC, first check that the HDMI passthrough is right for your gaming display, then compare the recording quality, computer compatibility and audio connections separately. Before an important run, make a test recording and check that the gameplay, commentary and timer all line up.
Who might need a capture card?
Console speedrunner with a separate display
Wants to play on a separate display while a computer records the run, timer and presentation. So check the passthrough and HDMI audio. Elgato’s Game Capture Neo manual explains how to connect it to a console and a separate display.
Runner with a high-refresh-rate monitor
Wants to keep the gaming display’s refresh rate. Compare the passthrough with the recording capabilities: manufacturers such as AVerMedia describe these as separate features for each model.
PC runner with one computer
Wants to present a speedrun with a timer and may be able to record directly in OBS. Elgato describes direct game capture as an option when the same PC runs and records the game.
What should you look for when buying?
First, decide whether you need to record a separate HDMI source. If you do choose a card, compare its passthrough for your gaming display and its recording capabilities as two separate things.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Gameplay and passthrough |
Check that the HDMI passthrough supports the resolution and refresh rate of your source and display. Don’t mistake passthrough for recording quality: according to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo passes through 4K60 HDR but records in 1080p60. |
If I play on a separate display, I want to know which picture settings the card passes through to it. Around 36% of consumers say gameplay and passthrough are their main buying concern. |
| Recording, audio and timer |
Compare the supported recording formats and check the video source and audio settings in OBS. Watch a test recording to make sure it includes the gameplay, commentary and timer. |
If I want to keep the full run, the recording must also include my commentary and timer. Around 29% of consumers give a complete recording with audio and a timer their highest priority. |
| Compatibility |
Check the connections, operating system and support for the exact model in your software. Elgato says its capture cards do not record HDMI signals protected by HDCP. |
If I want to use a console, computer and microphone in one studio setup, I want to know in advance whether the connections and software will work together. Around 21% of consumers put compatibility first. |
| Do you need a card? |
Work out where your gameplay is coming from. If you play and record on the same PC, try capturing the game directly in OBS first; for a console or second PC, a card can add an HDMI source to OBS. |
If my game and recording run on the same PC, I want to check first whether extra hardware will add anything. Around 14% of consumers make avoiding an unnecessary purchase their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Mistaking 4K passthrough for 4K recording
Passthrough and recording specifications can differ. Elgato specifies 4K60 HDR passthrough and recording up to 1080p60 for the Game Capture Neo.
For the exact model, compare passthrough and recording separately, using the resolution and frame rate you actually need.
If a card can’t deliver the recording quality you need, you may need another solution.
-
Buying a card to capture gameplay on the same PC
If the game and OBS are running on the same PC, OBS can capture the game directly. Elgato says a capture card doesn’t take over the encoding task.
If you don’t need to connect a separate HDMI source, make a short recording without a card first.
-
Judging by the live preview alone
A working preview in OBS doesn’t automatically mean the saved file will include the gameplay, commentary and timer.
Record a short test before a long run and watch it back. Check the audio and selected recording format too.
Brands to consider
Elgato
The Game Capture Neo and HD60 X have different recording and passthrough specifications. Compare them based on the recording you want and the display you use.
- Elgato lists 1080p60 recording and 4K60 HDR passthrough for the Game Capture Neo.
- The HD60 X’s passthrough specification isn’t the same as its recording capabilities; check the combination you need for the specific model.
ASUS
The TUF Gaming Capture Box FHD120 is worth considering if you want to combine 1080p recording at a high frame rate with a separate gaming display.
- ASUS specifies 1080p120 capture and 4K60 passthrough for this model. OBS lists the TUF Gaming Capture Box FHD120 among its certified devices.
- The OBS listing applies to this specific model and doesn’t tell you anything about other ASUS models.
AVerMedia
The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is designed for HDMI 2.1 setups with higher passthrough requirements.
- AVerMedia lists 4K144 passthrough among this model’s features.
- The manufacturer’s 4K144 capture claim applies to Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG. Check that your chosen software and computer combination supports this mode.
Magewell
The USB Capture HDMI 4K Plus may be worth considering if support for multiple operating systems and HDMI loop-through are part of your requirements.
- Magewell specifies support for Windows, Linux, Mac and Chrome OS, with recording up to 3840×2160p30 or 1920×1080p90.
- These are the stated capabilities of the USB Capture HDMI 4K Plus; check that the formats suit your own recording settings.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a capture card for a speedrun on one PC?
Usually not if the same PC runs the game and records it in OBS: try direct game capture first. For a separate console or gaming PC, an HDMI capture card can add the gameplay to your OBS scene.
How do I add the card and timer to my presentation?
Add the card to OBS as a video capture source and check the active resolution, frame rate and audio settings. LiveSplit offers a timer for speedruns; then record your complete scene and watch it back.
Why can’t I see PlayStation 5 footage through an Elgato card?
According to Elgato, its capture cards don’t record HDMI signals protected by HDCP, and HDCP is enabled by default on the PlayStation 5. Elgato explains how to disable HDCP for gameplay capture; protected films and streaming services can’t automatically be recorded this way.
What return and warranty rights apply to online purchases in the Netherlands?
According to the Government of the Netherlands, online purchases from a business usually come with a 14-day cooling-off period; check the applicable terms and exceptions. You’re also entitled to a product that works properly. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period, and the seller is your point of contact if a product is faulty.