Who is this buying guide for?

Console player with limited desk space

You want to get console footage on your existing screen or into the PC preview, without setting up a second full gaming station. Choosing between HDMI passthrough and the preview affects both your cabling and how you play. OBS Project, Elgato and NZXT describe the relevant capture and setup options.

Co-op host who wants to mix voices

You want viewers to hear the game, your voice and, where relevant, party chat. So check in advance how your console outputs audio and how to set up separate audio sources in OBS. Elgato and OBS Project describe relevant connection and audio checks.

Player with specific screen requirements

You want to keep a particular resolution or refresh rate while playing, even if your recording uses a lower resolution. Compare the input, HDMI passthrough and USB capture separately; Elgato, AVerMedia and NZXT list model-specific limits.

What should you look for?

First decide whether you want to play on a connected screen or use the PC preview. Then check the video format, audio routing and connections required for your equipment.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Gaming setup and cables Check that you have room for the screen and HDMI and USB cables, or see whether playing via the preview suits your setup. On a small desk, I want to show gameplay without setting up a second gaming station; around 33% of consumers therefore prioritise gaming space and cabling.
Game audio and voices Check where console and chat audio come from, which audio inputs the card has and how OBS handles microphone and capture audio. As a co-op host, I want viewers to hear the game, my voice and, if needed, party chat; for around 27% of consumers, this audio setup comes first.
Gameplay and recording For the exact card, compare the supported HDMI passthrough and capture resolution with your screen, source and preferred stream quality. I want to keep my preferred screen settings while playing, even if the stream is recorded at a lower resolution; around 20% of consumers prioritise retaining their gameplay settings.
Source, computer and ports Check the video output on your console or second PC, the available port on your computer and the card’s system requirements. Before connecting anything, I want to know whether my gaming source and computer are compatible; around 20% of consumers start by checking compatibility.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    Passthrough to a screen and recording on a computer are two different features. Elgato lists up to 2160p60 passthrough and capture up to 1080p60 for Game Capture Neo. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but can’t record or stream it to a PC in 4K.

    For the exact card, compare the passthrough and capture specifications separately with the screen settings you want to use.

  • Assuming HDMI carries all co-op voices too

    Game, microphone and party chat audio can depend on your console and headset settings. Elgato explains that, in a PS5 setup, a connected headset can remove game audio from HDMI. OBS Project warns that setting up the same audio source twice can cause an echo.

    Before buying, work out where your game audio, microphone and any party chat will come from. Then check the connections and set up each source separately in OBS.

    Depending on your console, headset and card, you may need a different cable or audio route to mix the sound.

  • Mixing up models with almost identical names

    The AVerMedia Live Gamer MINI GC311 and StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 are different models with different stated maximum HDMI passthrough resolutions.

    Compare the full model number on the product page with the specifications for that exact version.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Game Capture Neo is an external option for connecting a console to a screen and computer.

  • Elgato lists HDMI input and output, USB 3.0, up to 2160p60 passthrough and 1080p60 capture for Neo.
  • Elgato says an HDMI cable is not included. Check that you have enough cables for your preferred passthrough setup; these specifications apply to Neo, not all Elgato cards.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 and StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 are two models for different screen setups.

  • AVerMedia lists up to 1080p60 passthrough and recording for the GC311, and up to 4K60 passthrough with 1080p60 capture for the GC311G2.
  • Don’t mix up the model numbers: the stated maximum passthrough resolution differs between the GC311 and GC311G2.

NZXT

Signal cards are worth considering if you want to use a console with a computer. NZXT also describes playing via a PC without a separate console screen.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal.
  • The Signal HD60 can’t record or stream that signal to a PC in 4K. This alone doesn’t tell you how much preview lag to expect on your computer.

Razer

The Ripsaw HD is an external HDMI/USB card to consider if you need analogue audio connections.

  • Razer lists 3.5 mm microphone and aux inputs, 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 as a supported capture mode for the Ripsaw HD.
  • Having these connections doesn’t prove that party chat from a specific console will be captured without adjustments.

Joybuy products

This Joybuy product selection focuses on an external HDMI capture card with passthrough for a console or screen setup.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with 4K passthrough and microphone and headphone connections

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card, 4K passthrough, capture up to 1080p

The listed HDMI passthrough and audio connections suit a setup with a connected screen and separate audio sources.

The product title lists 4K passthrough, capture up to 1080p, USB 3.0, a microphone input and a headphone output. 4K passthrough doesn’t mean that recordings are made in 4K.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if I play and stream the co-op game on the same PC?

Generally not: NZXT says you don’t need a capture card if you play and record or stream on the same PC. A console or second PC is a separate video source, so a capture setup may be useful.

How do I connect a console with HDMI passthrough and add the video source in OBS?

With a card that supports HDMI passthrough, connect an HDMI cable from the console to HDMI-in, a second HDMI cable from HDMI-out to the gaming screen, and USB to the computer. Add the card in OBS as a Video Capture Device. Check the manual for your exact card, as this connection setup doesn’t automatically apply to models without an HDMI output.

Why can’t viewers hear the voices or game, or why does the audio sound doubled?

First check whether the console is outputting the desired audio via HDMI. Elgato explains that, in a PS5 setup, a headset connected to the console can remove game audio from HDMI. Then check the audio meters and monitoring in OBS; OBS Project warns that setting up the same audio source both globally and in a scene can cause an echo.

Might I need an extra HDMI cable, and what about the warranty?

That depends on the card and your setup. Elgato says that an HDMI cable isn’t included with Game Capture Neo, while a passthrough setup uses two HDMI cables. Consumer purchases in the Netherlands are covered by a statutory guarantee. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period, and the seller must resolve issues with a faulty product. If an extended warranty is offered, check what extra rights it provides.

Can I use music or other copyrighted material in a Dutch co-op stream without permission?

Not necessarily. The Dutch government says you may only use copyrighted music, photos and films with the creator’s permission. Consider the rights to any material in your specific stream separately from buying the capture card.