Who is this choice relevant to?

Presenter using one laptop

You want to record your presentation screen and voice without unnecessarily connecting a second video device. OBS Project explains how to use screen and window sources in OBS Studio.

Presenter using an HDMI camera

You want to record footage from a separate HDMI source, so you’ll need to check that the camera output and USB connection are compatible with your chosen card. Elgato and AVerMedia describe models designed for this type of camera setup.

Presenter using a second video source

You want to record the HDMI signal from a second computer and perhaps view it on your own monitor at the same time. In a shared room, remember to consider your audio and privacy settings too.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
The video source Work out whether the video is coming from the same computer, a second HDMI device or a camera. For an external source, check its HDMI output, the USB connection it requires and whether the signal is unencrypted. If I only want to capture a window on my recording computer, I don’t want to connect an extra device. Around 31% of consumers are mainly concerned with checking whether their video source is compatible.
Voice and audio Select the microphone you want to use in your recording software and listen back to a short test recording. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio source twice can cause an echo. When I’m presenting in a shared room, I want to record my voice clearly without selecting the wrong audio source or recording it twice. Around 31% of consumers prioritise voice recording.
Privacy in the room Check the camera frame and active microphone, and discuss the recording and how it will be shared with anyone involved beforehand. The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between strictly personal use and wider distribution of video footage. If I share a bedroom, I want to avoid accidentally recording my housemates or their conversations. Around 23% of consumers prioritise privacy in the room.
Monitoring and viewing slides Check whether the model has HDMI passthrough, and compare the specified recording and passthrough resolutions separately. Make a test recording to see whether small text on your slides remains legible. When I’m presenting from a second computer, I want to be able to view the feed on a monitor and check my slides. Around 15% of consumers consider this more important than the other factors.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a capture card for a window on the same computer

    If your presentation is running on the computer you’re recording on, software such as OBS Studio can use the window or screen directly as a source. You may not need a capture card.

    First, make a short screen or window recording and check that the video and audio are set up correctly.

    An unnecessary device also means extra connections, cables and setup.

  • Confusing HDMI input with recording resolution

    A specified input resolution doesn’t automatically tell you what resolution the card can record at. AVerMedia lists the BU113 as supporting up to 2160p60 HDR video input and recording at up to 2160p30.

    Check the product information for the exact model and compare its HDMI input, recording and any passthrough specifications separately.

  • Testing the video only

    Your recording may use the wrong microphone or have an echo if the same audio source is selected twice. Housemates could also be captured on video or audio without your intending to record them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority sets out different privacy conditions for footage kept strictly private and footage shared more widely.

    Make a short test recording and listen back to it. Check the camera frame, and discuss in advance who might be recorded and how you plan to share the recording.

    If your recording includes unwanted footage, it takes extra time to remove it or make the recording again.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Elgato offers both an HDMI-to-USB solution designed for cameras and capture cards with HDMI passthrough.

  • According to Elgato, Cam Link 4K supports unencrypted HDMI input and recording at up to 1080p60. Elgato says its specified 2160p60 capability applies to compatible cameras and the latest model.
  • Elgato specifies HDMI passthrough and recording at up to 2160p60 for Game Capture 4K S.
  • Elgato says HDR recording for Game Capture 4K S is currently only available on Windows. For Cam Link 4K, check which hardware revision you need.

StarTech.com

StarTech.com UVCHDCAP is an HDMI-to-USB solution with passthrough, designed in part for presentations and training sessions.

  • StarTech.com specifies unencrypted HDMI recording at up to 1080p60, HDMI passthrough and a 3.5mm stereo line input.
  • The specified recording limit is 1080p60. The line input isn’t automatically suitable for a microphone, so check that your audio source is compatible.

AVerMedia

AVerMedia describes the Live Streamer CAP 4K BU113 as a USB camera input for a camera or camcorder.

  • AVerMedia specifies USB 3.1 Gen 1 Type-C and UVC. The maximum HDMI input is 2160p60 HDR; the maximum recording resolution is 2160p30.
  • USB 2.0 is not supported. The input specification is not the same as the recording resolution.

Razer

Razer Ripsaw X is a compact capture card for use with an HDMI camera.

  • Razer lists recording at up to 4K30 and support for OBS.

Products related to this topic

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if my slides are on my recording laptop?

Not if you only want to record that laptop’s screen or a window: OBS Studio provides video sources for this. Set up your chosen microphone or application audio separately, then check the result with a test recording.

How do I connect a second presentation computer if I also want to use my own monitor?

Choose a model that explicitly specifies HDMI passthrough. Connect the source to the HDMI input, the monitor to the HDMI output and the recording computer via USB. Beforehand, check that the recording resolution suits your needs, as recording and passthrough may support different resolutions.

Why is my screen black, or why can’t I hear my voice?

Check that the source and capture card support your chosen resolution and frame rate, and that the signal is unencrypted for the card. Elgato says its capture devices can’t record HDMI signals with HDCP protection enabled. If your voice is missing, also check which microphone is selected and make sure the same audio source isn’t selected twice.

Can I record a housemate or publish the presentation?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, footage kept strictly private or shared only with a very limited group is generally exempt from the GDPR. That exemption doesn’t apply to wider publication or business use; in those cases, you need a legal basis under the GDPR to include identifiable people, often their consent. The specific requirements depend on who is recording, why and how the recording will be shared, so discuss this with your housemate beforehand.

What can I do if a capture card breaks too soon during normal use?

If you bought the product as a consumer in the Netherlands, you can contact the seller if it doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect during normal use. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets says that, depending on the circumstances, you may be entitled to a free repair, replacement or refund; there isn’t one fixed warranty period for every product.