Who is this choice relevant to?

Gamer with a high-refresh-rate monitor

Wants to record video from a second PC without the monitor display unexpectedly dropping to an unsupported resolution or refresh rate. Elgato and AVerMedia’s model specifications make passthrough an important point to check.

Recording or streaming creator

Needs recording quality that suits their use, as well as a working route for PC audio and microphone input. NZXT highlights audio routing as a separate challenge in a two-PC setup.

Builder of a dedicated two-PC setup

Is weighing up an external USB card against an internal card and needs to connect the HDMI link between the computers appropriately. Elgato specifies a USB requirement for the 4K X and a PCIe interface for the 4K Pro.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide what you want to record, then check the monitor display and work out the connection and audio routes.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Monitor display and HDMI passthrough Compare the resolution, Hz, HDR and VRR of the source, card and monitor; assess passthrough separately from recording. Elgato lists passthrough up to 2160p60 for the 4K S and up to 2160p144 for the 4K X. If I want to keep my preferred display mode on the monitor while recording on the second PC, passthrough is an important factor in my choice. Around 31% of consumers say monitor display is their main concern when buying.
Actual recording quality Check the maximum capture resolution and frame rate for the exact model and software. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through 4K, but cannot record in 4K. If you need a recording file at a particular resolution and frame rate, check these separately from the passthrough specifications. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recording quality.
Audio from both computers Decide which PC audio, voice and microphone input you want in the recording; check the connections and test the routing in your recording software. NZXT describes audio as a separate challenge in a two-PC setup. If I want PC audio and microphone input to come through correctly in my recording, I’ll plan the audio routes in advance. Around 25% of consumers say audio recording is their main concern when buying.
Connection and placement Check whether your recording PC has a suitable USB port or spare PCIe slot, and whether the HDMI cable route will work. If you have signal problems, Elgato recommends using a shorter cable or lowering the resolution or frame rate. If you’re looking for a card that suits the PC you have and the distance between the computers, you’ll need to consider the connection and cable route together. Around 19% of consumers prioritise placement and connectivity.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K’ guarantees 4K recording

    A card can pass through a 4K signal without recording in 4K itself. NZXT notes this distinction for the Signal HD60.

    For the exact model, check the maximum recording and passthrough resolutions separately, including the frame rate.

  • Assuming every USB-C port offers the same capabilities

    The shape of the connector doesn’t tell you what USB speed is available. Elgato lists a lower recording resolution for the 4K X when used with USB 3.2 Gen 1 than with the required USB 3.2 Gen 2 connection.

    Check the USB specification of your recording PC and the requirements of the exact card model.

  • Leaving the HDMI cable route and audio setup until after you buy

    An unsuitable or longer HDMI cable can contribute to signal problems. And getting a picture on screen won’t automatically sort out the routing for PC audio and microphone input.

    Plan the video and audio routes in advance, then test the display mode you intend to use with the necessary connections. Depending on your setup, you may need extra HDMI or audio cables; a mixer is only relevant for certain audio setups.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Elgato offers external models such as the 4K S and 4K X, as well as the internal 4K Pro. Connections, recording specifications and passthrough capabilities vary by model; the details below are based on Elgato’s own specifications.

  • The 4K S lists recording up to 2160p60 via USB 3.0; the 4K Pro uses PCIe 2.0 x4.
  • The 4K X requires USB 3.2 Gen 2 for the full specifications listed; Elgato states that recording resolution is lower via USB 3.2 Gen 1.
  • According to Elgato, the 4K Pro does not support signals with Display Stream Compression.

AVerMedia

The external Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 and internal Live Gamer 4K 2.1 GC575 offer different installation options for a setup with a high-refresh-rate monitor.

  • AVerMedia lists 4K144 passthrough for both models.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC553G2’s 4K144 recording claim requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; don’t treat this as a general performance level for every application.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is designed for setups where 1080p recording is enough; according to NZXT, the Signal 4K30 also supports 4K30 recording and HDR display.

  • According to NZXT, the HD60 can receive and pass through a 4K signal if 1080p recording is sufficient.
  • NZXT states that the HD60 cannot record in 4K and does not support HDR. So the 4K label alone doesn’t make this card suitable for those requirements.

ACT

The AC7600 is a USB-C option for a single HDMI source. An extra HDMI input isn’t automatically necessary in a setup with one second computer.

  • ACT lists 4K60 passthrough and 4K30 recording for the AC7600.
  • These are ACT’s specifications, not the result of an independent performance test; treat passthrough and recording as separate features.

Joybuy product selection

This Joybuy selection is aimed at an external USB setup where 1080p recording is sufficient and 4K passthrough is desirable.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

Suited to an external USB setup where recording up to 1080p is sufficient and 4K passthrough is desirable.

The product title lists recording up to 1080p and 4K passthrough; it doesn’t mention 4K recording.

The title mentions driver-free installation, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I add the second computer’s video in OBS?

Connect the second computer’s HDMI output to HDMI IN on the capture card, then add a Video Capture Device source in OBS on the recording PC. Select the card and choose a supported resolution and frame rate; OBS Project explains how to select the card in this source’s properties.

What can I check if the picture is black or flickering?

First check that the source computer is switched on, the cable is connected to HDMI IN and the card supports the signal. If you have signal problems, Elgato recommends using a shorter cable or lowering the resolution or frame rate. According to Elgato, its capture cards cannot record HDMI signals with HDCP protection enabled.

Will I need extra audio equipment for two PCs?

Not necessarily. First decide which audio sources you want to record and test where they come through. NZXT recommends a mixer and extra audio cables for its own two-PC example, but these aren’t a general requirement for every capture card.

What rights apply to an online purchase in the Netherlands?

For an online consumer purchase, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions; ACM ConsuWijzer explains this right. You’re also entitled to a product that works as it should. The Dutch government states that there’s no fixed statutory warranty period for all products in the Netherlands; if there’s a fault, contact the seller.

Can I record and publish everything that appears on the second computer?

No. Being able to record something doesn’t automatically mean you’re allowed to publish it. The Dutch government states that you generally need permission to use other people’s copyright-protected music, films and photos; a private copy for personal use can’t simply be made public. Before sharing your recording, also check whether the screen shows other people’s personal data.