Who is a capture card for a second PC for?

Home worker with a second PC

Wants to record a desktop, demonstration or everyday video from another computer and is mainly looking for a suitable, straightforward connection.

4K recording creator

Wants to capture more detail than 1080p, so needs to distinguish recording output from the signal that is only passed through to a display.

High-refresh-rate display user

Wants to record the picture from a second PC, which may be used for gaming, while checking whether the display can keep its desired high refresh rate.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the resolution and frame rate you want to record. Then check whether the card can pass through the display signal you need and is compatible with your recording computer.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Basic 1080p recording Check the maximum recording output and whether the second PC provides an unencrypted HDMI signal. If I mainly need a straightforward 1080p recording from my second PC, I don’t want recording requirements beyond what I need. Around 33% of consumers make basic 1080p recording their top priority.
True 4K recording Look up the maximum recording resolution and frame rate; don’t assume these from the HDMI input or passthrough alone. If I want to record in 4K, the recording output must genuinely support that resolution. Around 25% of consumers prioritise true 4K recording.
Keeping a high refresh rate Compare the resolution, Hz, HDR and VRR you want for both passthrough and recording. If I want to keep using my high-refresh-rate display through the capture card, I’ll check the passthrough and, if needed, accept a different recording setting. Around 25% of consumers make keeping their display’s refresh rate their top priority.
Connection and audio Check the required USB speed or available PCIe slot, then test whether audio is recorded in your recording software. If the ports on my recording PC or the audio route are key factors, I want to know in advance how the card connects and how it captures audio. Around 17% of consumers base their choice mainly on connection and audio.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K’ means 4K60 recording

    Recording and passthrough may have different maximum specifications. For example, the European j5create JVA14-N is specified for 4K30 recording and 4K60 passthrough.

    For the card you choose, compare recording output and passthrough separately, including the frame rate.

  • Comparing only the highest frame rate

    Supported frame rates can differ between display passthrough and recording, and may also depend on HDR, software and operating system. AVerMedia links the stated 4K144 recording for the GC575 to Streaming Center.

    Check the combination of resolution, frame rate, HDR, recording software and operating system you plan to use.

  • Assuming every card will work with every recording PC

    An external card may need a specific USB connection; an internal card needs a suitable, available PCIe slot. Elgato says that USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbps is required for the full specified USB performance of the 4K X. According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo does not come with an HDMI cable.

    Before buying, check the available connections, your preferred audio route and what’s included in the box.

    If you don’t have the required connection or cable, you may need extra accessories before you can use the setup.

Brands and model differences

Elgato

Among the models reviewed, Elgato offers external USB cards and an internal PCIe option, with different recording and passthrough settings.

  • According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo records up to 1080p60, while the stated maximum recording resolution for the Game Capture 4K S is 2160p60. These are model specifications, not the results of independent performance tests.
  • Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbps for the full USB performance of the 4K X. The Game Capture 4K Pro is a PCIe 2.0 x4 card, and its maximum recording output is lower than its stated passthrough capability.

AVerMedia

The models reviewed offer an internal PCIe option and an external USB option.

  • AVerMedia specifies 4K144 passthrough for the GC575. The manufacturer also states that it can record up to 4K144 with Streaming Center.
  • The stated recording setting requires Streaming Center. So check the software, operating system and specific signal combination you plan to use.

j5create

The European JVA14-N is an external capture card with HDMI input and output, as well as analogue audio connections.

  • j5create specifies 4K30 recording and 4K60 passthrough for this model.
  • The stated 4K60 passthrough doesn’t mean the card records in 4K60; its stated maximum recording resolution is 4K30.

Blackmagic Design

The DeckLink Mini Recorder HD is an internal card with HDMI and SDI inputs, for a recording PC with a suitable PCIe slot.

  • Blackmagic Design specifies recording up to 1080p60 and 2Kp60 DCI.
  • Its stated recording formats make it unsuitable as a direct choice for 4K recording. Also check the installation requirements and how you want to connect your display.

Joybuy product pick for 1080p recording

This Joybuy selection focuses on an external USB capture card for recording from a second PC at up to 1080p; the stated 4K passthrough does not mean 4K recording.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0 and 4K passthrough

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card

Worth considering if you want to record from a second PC via HDMI and recording at up to 1080p suits your needs.

The product name specifies USB 3.0 and capture at up to 1080p; the stated 4K passthrough does not mean 4K recording.

The product name also mentions driver-free installation, a microphone input and a headphone output.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect the second computer for recording?

Connect a suitable, unencrypted HDMI output from the source PC to HDMI IN on the capture card, then connect the card to the recording PC using the required connection. In OBS, add the card as a video capture source. If you’re using HDMI OUT for your display, check that the card can pass through the display setting you want.

Why is there a picture but no sound in the recording?

First, check that the source PC is sending audio through the HDMI output you’ve chosen. Then check the audio source, output mode and meters in OBS. According to OBS, the ‘Capture Only’ setting won’t automatically let you hear audio through monitoring. Make a short test recording to check that the sound is audible and included in the recording.

Can I record protected video from the second computer?

Don’t assume that an HDCP-protected signal can be captured. The Elgato models reviewed specify unencrypted HDMI input, so check the source and the specifications of the model you’re considering.

What cancellation period and warranty apply when buying from a Dutch online shop?

When you buy remotely from a business, you’ll usually have 14 days to change your mind, but exceptions and the seller’s circumstances may be relevant. You’re also entitled to receive a product that works as it should in the Netherlands, and the seller is your point of contact if it’s faulty. There is no fixed two-year statutory warranty period for all products.

What should I check for product safety in the Netherlands?

Electrical and electronic equipment sold in the Netherlands must meet the applicable European product requirements, including the required CE marking. Check the information about the specific capture card and the seller, especially if it’s imported from outside the EU.