Who is a capture card for a second PC for?

Creator with a second recording PC

You want to use the HDMI video from one computer in recording or streaming software on another. Megekko describes this setup as a way to send video and audio to a computer via a capture card for recording or livestreaming.

Streamer with a high-refresh-rate gaming monitor

You want to keep your monitor running at the refresh rate you prefer while recording. To do that, compare the passthrough capabilities with the model’s separate capture mode.

Creator who wants to capture PC audio

You want to record audio from the source PC as well as video, and decide in advance how that audio will reach your recording PC.

What should you look for in a capture card?

External USB capture

Best for: a laptop setup or a card you want to be able to move between systems.

Check: the USB connection, operating system and the model’s separate input, passthrough and capture modes.

Internal PCIe capture

Best for: a fixed recording PC with a suitable free PCIe slot.

Check: the available slot and bandwidth in advance; this type of card is not designed to be fitted in a laptop.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recording quality For the exact model, compare the HDMI input, capture resolution, frame rate and software used. Input, passthrough and recording are separate specifications. If I want to record from my second PC at a particular resolution and frame rate, I check that this combination is actually available. Recording quality is the top buying priority for around 33% of consumers.
Monitor passthrough Compare the resolution and refresh rate you want for your monitor with the passthrough specifications; also check for VRR and any reliance on DSC. I want to keep my chosen display mode on my monitor while recording. For around 25% of consumers, retaining that display mode is the top priority.
Connection to the recording PC Check whether you need USB or an available PCIe slot, and look at the system requirements and operating system for the exact model. Whether I have a laptop or desktop, I first check which connection I can actually use. Connection and computer compatibility are the top buying priority for around 25% of consumers.
Audio routing Work out which audio is carried over HDMI and which sources may need to be set up separately in OBS. If I also want to capture audio from the source PC, I want to know in advance how it will be included in my recording. Around 17% of consumers put audio routing first.

Common capture card buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K input’ means ‘4K60 recording’

    A card may accept a particular input signal without offering the same resolution and frame rate for recording. For example, Magewell lists a capture limit of 3840×2160p30 for the USB Capture HDMI 4K Plus, even though it can accept 4Kp60 input.

    Check the input, passthrough and capture specifications separately for the exact model.

  • Comparing only the maximum refresh rate

    A high passthrough mode does not automatically tell you which capture mode is available. Elgato says the 4K X cannot capture signals with Display Stream Compression (DSC).

    Check the input-to-capture matrix for the display setting you want to use.

  • Assuming that seeing the video means your audio setup is complete

    Seeing a picture does not automatically mean the PC audio you want will be included in the recording. OBS warns that adding the same audio source both as a separate source and in the general audio settings can cause an echo.

    Decide in advance how HDMI audio and any separate microphone sources will be routed, then test with a short recording.

Brands worth considering

Elgato

The 4K S and 4K X are external models, while the 4K Pro is an internal option for desktop PCs.

  • Elgato lists USB 3.0 and capture up to 2160p60 for the 4K S. For the 4K Pro, the brand specifies PCIe 2.0 x4 and capture up to 2160p60.
  • According to Elgato, HDR capture with the 4K S is currently available only on Windows and is limited to 1080p60. The brand says the 4K X cannot capture DSC signals.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is an external option to compare if high HDMI passthrough or an ultrawide source matters to you.

  • AVerMedia lists 4K144 passthrough and support for 3440×1440 among this model’s features.
  • AVerMedia’s stated 4K144 recording capability requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG. This requirement does not automatically apply to other software or models.

Magewell

The USB Capture HDMI 4K Plus is an external option to consider if you want to compare HDMI loop-through and separate audio options.

  • Magewell lists HDMI loop-through, USB 3.0, embedded HDMI audio and a microphone/headphone socket.
  • For this model, Magewell specifies capture up to 3840×2160p30 or 1920×1080p90. So a 4Kp60 input does not mean the model records at 4K60.

Capture cards at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I add video from my second computer in OBS?

Connect the HDMI output from the source PC to the capture card’s input, then connect the card to the recording PC. In OBS, add a video source for the capture device. According to OBS, a device on Windows requires a driver that supports DirectShow output.

Does the capture card’s HDMI output always need to connect to my monitor?

No. Elgato also describes a dual-PC setup that uses only the HDMI input, leaving the HDMI output unused. If you do connect the output to a monitor, check that the passthrough mode supports your preferred display setting.

Why can I hear the audio twice in OBS?

Check whether the same audio device is selected both as a separate source and in the general audio settings. OBS warns that selecting it twice can cause an echo.

What are my rights when I buy a capture card online?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy online you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery; check whether any exception applies. ACM also says you are entitled to a product that meets what you could reasonably expect. Dutch statutory guarantees do not have a fixed term of exactly two years.

Can I livestream music from my source PC without checking anything else?

Do not assume that a working capture card also takes care of music rights. BumaStemra says you do not need a separate BumaStemra licence for its members’ music on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram or Twitch, but warns that other rights holders may still have a stream blocked. For broadcasts on your own website, BumaStemra describes separate permission requirements; check the rights for your specific broadcast.