Compare the HDMI passthrough and recording quality separately against your source PC’s output and the display you want to keep using. An external USB card suits a portable setup if your recording computer has the required USB port; an internal PCIe card needs a desktop with a compatible free slot. Set up audio separately, and check whether housemates or private information could be seen or heard.
Who is this buying guide for?
Gamer with a high-refresh-rate display
You want to record your second PC while keeping the resolution and refresh rate you want on your own display. To do this, compare HDMI passthrough and recording separately. For example, Elgato lists the HD60 X as supporting passthrough up to 2160p60 and recording up to 2160p30.
Streamer sharing a bedroom
You want to manage game audio and your microphone properly, and avoid accidentally showing or broadcasting a housemate or private information. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people in images published online are personal data.
Content creator with a portable setup
You want to use your capture card with different computers or workstations, so you check the USB connection, required cables and capabilities of the recording computer. Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbps for the 4K X to deliver full performance.
What should you look for?
Start with the source PC’s signal and the picture you want to record. Then check the connections, audio and space the setup requires.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Passthrough and recording |
Compare HDMI passthrough, recording resolution and frame rate separately against the source PC’s output and your display’s capabilities. |
If I want to keep the picture I prefer on screen while gaming and also need a particular recording format, I’ll prioritise a combination that does both. Around 40% of consumers prioritise picture quality and passthrough. |
| Audio and privacy |
Check how game audio and your microphone are added and tested in the recording software. Also check which notifications or people could appear on screen. |
When I share a room, I want to be able to check what my stream lets people hear and see. Around 30% of consumers prioritise audio and privacy. |
| Connection and portability |
Check the required USB port and speed, or, for an internal card, the type and availability of a PCIe slot. |
If I move between computers or workstations, the card needs to be compatible with the recording computer I actually use. For around 20% of consumers, connection and portability are the main priorities. |
| Extra cables and equipment |
Map out the HDMI, USB and audio connections in advance, then compare them with the cables and accessories included in the package you choose. |
If I want to keep the amount of equipment in a shared bedroom to a minimum, I want to know which connections I can already use. Around 10% of consumers prioritise a simple setup. |
Common pitfalls
-
Confusing passthrough with recording
A card may support a higher picture specification for passthrough than for recording. Elgato lists the HD60 X as supporting passthrough up to 2160p60, compared with recording up to 2160p30.
For each model, compare the input, passthrough and recording specifications with your source PC, display and preferred recording format.
-
Only accounting for the card in your setup
A passthrough setup may need an extra HDMI cable. In a two-PC setup, audio also needs its own route and checks.
Map out the connections in advance and check the contents of the exact package you’re considering.
Depending on your setup, you may need extra HDMI or audio cables and additional audio equipment. NZXT includes a mixer in its more advanced two-PC example, but that doesn’t make one essential for every setup.
-
Assuming any source signal can be recorded and published
Elgato says its capture devices cannot capture an HDMI signal with HDCP protection enabled. Being able to record something technically and having permission to publish it are also two different things.
Before recording, check that the signal you want to capture is compatible. Before publishing, check your rights to the content and consider what other people might be seen or heard in.
Brands to consider
Elgato
The models mentioned have different specifications for external capture cards. Compare them individually rather than treating these as general features of the brand.
- Elgato lists the HD60 X as supporting passthrough up to 2160p60 and recording up to 2160p30. For the 4K S, the manufacturer lists recording up to 2160p60.
- Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbps for the 4K X to deliver full performance. Passthrough and recording specifications are not interchangeable.
AVerMedia
The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is an external model to consider if HDMI passthrough and your source computer are key factors.
- AVerMedia lists passthrough up to 4K144 and 1080p360 for this model.
- The manufacturer links 4K144 capture to Streaming Center software on Windows and specifies MJPEG as the recording format. Don’t assume the same performance applies in OBS or on a Mac.
NZXT
The Signal HD60 and Signal 4K30 are models to compare for a two-PC setup, depending on your preferred recording format and passthrough requirements.
- NZXT also describes free solutions for transferring picture and sound in a two-PC setup.
- NZXT highlights audio as an important consideration and recommends a mixer in an advanced example, but one isn’t essential for every buyer.
UGREEN
The HDMI 2.1 capture card with manufacturer SKU 35871 is a specific model to compare if its stated HDMI and USB features suit your setup.
- UGREEN lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbps, VRR and HDR for this model.
- Check the specifications for the exact version and make sure they’re compatible with your source PC, display and recording computer.
Joybuy products
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
How do I connect an external capture card to a second PC?
Connect the HDMI output on the source PC to HDMI IN on the capture card. If you’re using passthrough, connect HDMI OUT to your display. Connect the card to the recording computer via USB, then add a video capture device in OBS. Check the available format and frame rate, and list the cables you’ll need in advance.
Why can’t I hear any sound, or why does the audio play twice?
First, check whether your selected audio source is sending sound to OBS and how audio monitoring is set up. OBS warns that selecting the same audio source in multiple places can cause an echo, so test your complete two-PC setup with a short recording.
Can I record an HDMI signal with HDCP protection?
Elgato says its capture devices cannot capture an HDMI signal with HDCP protection enabled. So check whether the signal you want to record is compatible. This doesn’t, in itself, mean you have permission to publish the material.
What should I consider if my housemate might appear on camera?
Recording only the PC signal is different from filming with a camera in the bedroom. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people in images published online are personal data. Take care not to include housemates or private information by accident, and check the applicable privacy rules before publishing.
Can I livestream music or films from my second PC?
Don’t assume that you can. The Government of the Netherlands distinguishes between making a private copy for personal use and distributing or making material available to the public. You generally need permission to use copyright-protected films and music. Check the rights to the specific content before publishing it.