Who is a capture card for?

First-time dual-PC user

Primarily wants straightforward 1080p recording and to know in advance which HDMI and USB connections and cables the setup requires. Elgato and AVerMedia specify different recording and passthrough limits for their entry-level models.

Gamer with a high-refresh-rate monitor

Wants to keep the desired resolution and refresh rate while playing. Elgato’s specifications for the 4K S and 4K X show why you should compare monitor passthrough and recording separately.

Streamer with a custom audio mix

Wants to route game audio, microphone and headset so the recording PC receives the intended sources. NZXT identifies audio as a key setup challenge in a dual-PC setup; OBS offers separate audio and monitoring settings.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide what recording quality you need and what you want your monitor to display. Then check the connections and audio setup across your entire system.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Simple 1080p setup Check the HDMI input and any HDMI output, the USB connection and which cables are included. If I mainly want to record from my second PC in 1080p without fuss, I want to know how the card and monitor connect. Shoppers who prioritise a simple connection make up around 33% of consumers in this decision-making context.
Monitor resolution and refresh rate Compare the stated passthrough with the recording settings; check that the combination works with your source, card, monitor and software. If I want to keep my preferred monitor settings while playing, I compare passthrough separately from recording quality. Shoppers who prioritise monitor performance make up around 27% of consumers in this decision-making context.
Game, microphone and headset audio Decide which PC sends the audio and which sources your recording software receives; make a short test recording. If I want both game audio and my voice in the recording, I want to know in advance where I’ll listen and which PC receives the sources. Shoppers who prioritise audio mixing make up around 20% of consumers in this decision-making context.
Recording PC compatibility Check the model’s required USB port and system requirements; test your chosen resolution and frame rate in your recording software. If I want to use my recording PC with my chosen card and settings, I first check that the connections and software are compatible. Shoppers who prioritise compatibility make up around 20% of consumers in this decision-making context.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    A card can pass a 4K signal through to a monitor without the recording PC capturing the footage in 4K. Elgato makes this clear for Game Capture Neo, as does NZXT for Signal HD60.

    Check the stated passthrough and recording resolutions for the exact model.

  • Testing the picture only

    A working HDMI connection doesn’t tell you whether game audio, microphone audio and your own monitoring are also routed as intended.

    Before you start longer recordings, make a short test with all your audio sources. NZXT lists a mixer as a possible recommendation for a dual-PC setup, not as a standard requirement.

    Depending on your chosen audio setup, you may need extra audio cables or equipment.

  • Assuming all the cables are included

    Elgato states that Game Capture Neo does not come with an HDMI cable.

    Map out the connections between your source PC, capture card, recording PC and any monitor, then compare them with what’s in the box.

    For Game Capture Neo, you’ll need to use an HDMI cable from your existing setup or arrange one separately.

Brands to consider

Elgato

The Game Capture models mentioned offer different combinations of recording and monitor passthrough.

  • According to Elgato, Game Capture Neo records at up to 1080p60 and supports passthrough at up to 4K60.
  • Elgato lists passthrough of up to 1440p120 and 4K60 recording for the 4K S. For the 4K X, it lists features including 4K144 passthrough and recording via USB 3.2 Gen 2.
  • The stated maximums won’t necessarily apply to every combination of signal, software and recording PC. The 4K X requires the specified USB 3.2 Gen 2 connection.

AVerMedia

Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for a simpler 1080p60 setup, while Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 offers different stated capabilities.

  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 supports up to 1080p60 for both passthrough and recording.
  • AVerMedia specifies recording at up to 4K144 on the GC553G2 with Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; for OBS on Mac, it lists 4K60.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 does not support 4K, HDR or high refresh rates. The stated GC553G2 combinations depend on the software and platform.

NZXT

Signal HD60 is worth considering for a dual-PC setup where you don’t need to record in 4K.

  • NZXT states that Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, this model cannot record that signal in 4K and does not support HDR.
  • NZXT highlights audio setup as something to consider in a dual-PC setup. A mixer is the manufacturer’s recommendation, not a general requirement.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a second computer to OBS?

Connect a suitable HDMI output on the source PC to the HDMI input on the capture card, then connect the card to the recording PC. In OBS, add a video capture device and select the card; then check the resolution, frame rate and audio. Whether you also need an HDMI output to a monitor depends on your display setup.

Why do I have a picture but no sound in my recording?

Check that the source PC is sending audio to the intended HDMI output and that OBS is receiving or monitoring audio from the recording source. Also test the microphone and headset on the PC you want to use them with; NZXT identifies audio as a key setup challenge in a dual-PC setup.

Can a capture card with 4K passthrough also record in 4K?

Not always: passthrough and recording are separate specifications. For example, Elgato states that Game Capture Neo can pass through 4K60 but records at up to 1080p60. Check both figures for the exact model and the signal combination you plan to use.

Can I record any footage from the other PC?

No, not every model supports every signal. Elgato specifies unencrypted HDMI sources for the models mentioned; AVerMedia states that the GC311 cannot record an HDCP-protected signal. Check the specifications for your exact card and source.

What cooling-off period and warranty apply to online purchases in the Netherlands?

For many online purchases from a business, the Dutch government states that you have a 14-day cooling-off period, subject to exceptions; these rules do not necessarily apply to purchases from a private individual. If a product is faulty, contact the seller about your statutory warranty rights. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; the assessment depends, among other things, on what you could reasonably expect from the product.