Who is a capture card for?

Console commentator with a laptop

You want to show a separate HDMI source in OBS and first check that your laptop and the card work together.

Player using a separate screen

You want to keep playing on your own screen while you commentate. That’s why it’s important to compare HDMI passthrough separately from the footage the card records.

Commentator providing live analysis

You want the game audio and your voice in the broadcast, so check in advance which audio sources are available.

What should you look for?

Direct Game Capture

Choose this when: the game runs on the same Windows PC as OBS and you don’t need a separate HDMI source.

Trade-off: you won’t need an extra capture card or cables, but this option isn’t designed to bring a console’s HDMI picture into your computer.

External card for Full HD recording

Choose this when: you want to record a console or another separate HDMI source in OBS and check the options available for your screen.

Trade-off: maximum recording and passthrough capabilities vary by model. Check the USB connection and system requirements too.

Card with enhanced passthrough or audio connections

Choose this when: your separate screen needs specific passthrough capabilities, or you want to manage audio through separate connections.

Trade-off: a higher passthrough resolution doesn’t automatically mean equally high recording quality. The USB connection you use can also make a difference.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Video source and laptop Work out where the game is running, then check the card’s HDMI output, USB port and system requirements. If I want to commentate on a console game using my laptop, I first want to know whether the source, computer and card will work together. Around 30% of consumers give source and laptop compatibility top priority.
Setting up on a small desk Check which HDMI cables and free USB ports you’ll need, and whether a cable is included with the card. For a small student room, I want to know whether the card and the cables I need will fit on my desk. Around 30% of consumers focus on having a practical setup and the necessary accessories.
Playing on a separate screen Compare the HDMI passthrough you want with the recording output for the exact model and USB connection you’ll use. If I want to keep playing on a separate screen while commentating, I check the signal that screen receives. Around 20% of consumers prioritise screen passthrough.
Commentary and game audio Check the audio connections, select the card as a source in OBS and make a short test recording. If I want to broadcast my voice and the game audio together, I check in advance that the right audio sources can be heard. Around 20% of consumers give commentary and game audio top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a card when direct Game Capture will do

    If the game runs on the same Windows PC as OBS, you can try direct Game Capture. An external card would add an extra device and more cables.

    First check whether the picture needs to come from a separate HDMI device.

    An unnecessary card also means extra equipment and cables taking up space on your desk.

  • Confusing passthrough with recording quality

    The maximum resolution for a separate screen may differ from the resolution the card records. With the ASUS TUF Gaming Capture Box-CU4K30, the stated maximum recording resolution also depends on the USB connection.

    For your exact card, compare both the screen passthrough and the recording output, and check which USB port you’re using.

  • Assuming picture, cables and commentary will all work automatically

    Having a video source in OBS doesn’t automatically mean the game audio and your voice will be heard as you want them to be. Elgato says that an HDMI cable isn’t included with the Elgato Game Capture Neo.

    Check which cables you need and make a short test recording with picture, game audio and commentary before you start.

    You’ll need to provide your own HDMI cable for the Elgato Game Capture Neo if you don’t already have one.

Brands to compare

Elgato

According to Elgato’s specifications, the Game Capture Neo offers an external option for 1080p60 recording and screen passthrough up to 4K60.

  • Elgato distinguishes between the Game Capture Neo’s recording output and HDMI passthrough.
  • An HDMI cable isn’t included. According to Elgato, HDR recording is currently only available on Windows.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia, the Live Gamer MINI GC311 is a compact external Full HD option with HDMI passthrough and a micro-USB connection.

  • AVerMedia lists up to 1080p60 for both recording and passthrough, as well as built-in H.264 encoding.
  • AVerMedia doesn’t list 4K, HDR or high refresh rate support for this model. Check your computer’s system requirements too.

ASUS

According to ASUS, the TUF Gaming Capture Box-CU4K30 is an external option with HDMI passthrough and separate audio connections.

  • ASUS lists features including 4K60 passthrough and 3.5mm connections.
  • The maximum stated recording resolution varies by USB connection: ASUS lists up to 2160p30 via USB 3.2 Gen 1x1 and 720p30 via USB 2.0.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are HDMI capture cards for a separate video source, such as a console, and their listings mention OBS and use with a separate screen.

HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

HDMI capture card USB 3.0 (4K30 input, 1080p60 recording)

Suitable for a setup with a separate HDMI source that you want to use with OBS.

The product listing specifies HDMI input up to 4K30, recording up to 1080p60 and HDMI passthrough.

Also listed: USB 3.0, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card (4K passthrough, recording up to 1080p)

Suitable for a console setup where you want to record an HDMI source and use the card with OBS.

The product listing specifies video recording up to 1080p and 4K HDMI passthrough.

Also listed: USB 3.0, UVC and UAC support, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if the game is running on my streaming PC?

Not necessarily. The OBS Project recommends trying Game Capture first if the game is running on the same Windows PC. For a separate HDMI source, add a video source in OBS for the connected capture card.

How do I connect an external card and check the audio?

Connect the HDMI source to the HDMI input and connect the card to your computer. Use the HDMI output if you also want to connect a separate screen, then select the card as a video source in OBS. Check the audio output mode and make a test recording before going live.

What should I check before buying, and what if the card doesn’t meet my expectations?

Check which cables are included and whether your computer has the required connection. The Government of the Netherlands says that, in principle, online purchases from a business come with a 14-day cooling-off period. Check the terms and conditions of the specific seller.

Can I stream footage from an existing tournament broadcast as part of my analysis?

Not automatically. According to the Government of the Netherlands, permission is generally needed to make copyrighted material available to the public. Under certain conditions, the right to quote may apply to a necessary extract from published work, provided you credit the source and author. Whether that applies to your tournament footage and intended use depends on the specific circumstances.

Can a capture card record protected footage from a streaming service?

Don’t assume it can: AVerMedia says the Live Gamer MINI GC311 doesn’t support HDCP-protected signals. The Government of the Netherlands also says that you must not circumvent copy protection.