Who might need a capture card?

Mod maker using one PC

You’re showcasing a PC mod and want to check whether direct recording will do the job. OBS Project recommends trying Game Capture first for DirectX or OpenGL games; NZXT Support Center notes that you don’t need a capture card to play and record on the same PC.

Console or two-PC presenter

You’re capturing gameplay from a separate console or PC on your recording PC. OBS Project describes a capture device as a way to send console gameplay to OBS Studio.

Detail-focused showcase creator

You want to capture small graphical changes clearly or maintain a particular refresh rate while playing. Compare the recording specifications with the HDMI pass-through; Elgato and AVerMedia list these features separately.

What should you look for?

First decide whether your footage is coming from the same PC or a separate device. Then compare the recording quality, the pass-through to your gaming screen and the audio settings.

What to consider What to check before buying Why it matters
Do you need a card? Check whether your gameplay is coming from the same PC, a console or a second PC. If you’re playing on the same Windows PC, try OBS Game Capture first. If I’m playing and recording on one PC, I don’t want to use an extra HDMI device if software recording will do the job. Around 33% of consumers prioritise choosing the right signal route, including the option of not buying a card.
Mod details in the recording Compare the maximum recording quality at your preferred frame rate and HDR setting. Elgato specifies recording up to 2160p60 for the 4K S; HDR recording is limited to 1080p60 on Windows. AVerMedia specifies a maximum recording resolution of 2160p30 for the GC551G2. If I’m showing fine graphical changes, I want them to be clearly visible in the recorded file. Around 27% of consumers give clear mod details top priority.
Playing on your own screen Check pass-through support for your screen’s exact resolution and refresh rate, separately from the recording specifications. For the GC551G2, AVerMedia lists 1440p120 VRR pass-through and recording up to 1440p60, among other specifications. If I’m playing on my own screen during the showcase, I want to know which signal route will work for me. Around 20% of consumers prioritise responsive gameplay and screen use.
Game audio and commentary Check HDMI audio, any analogue connections and the audio monitoring settings. AVerMedia lists 3.5mm line-in and line-out for the GC551G2; in OBS, Capture Only means you won’t hear the audio locally by default. If I’m talking through the gameplay, I want the audio to go where it should and to know what’s in the recording. Around 20% of consumers prioritise control over game audio and commentary.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a capture card to record on the same PC

    If a game is running on the same PC, try recording directly first. OBS Project recommends Game Capture as the first option, while NZXT says you don’t need a card if you’re playing and recording on the same PC.

    Try a suitable capture source in OBS first, and only consider extra hardware if you want to capture footage from a separate device.

  • Confusing pass-through with recording quality

    A card may pass a signal to your screen at a higher quality than it can record at the same time. AVerMedia specifies a maximum recording resolution of 2160p30 for the GC551G2, despite listing 2160p60 HDR pass-through. Razer also distinguishes between 1080p60 recording and 4K60 pass-through on the Ripsaw HD.

    Check the official recording and pass-through specifications for the resolution, frame rate and HDR setting you actually want to use.

  • Assuming picture and sound will automatically come through together

    In OBS, recording and listening locally are separate settings. NZXT also explains that audio in a two-PC setup may need extra configuration.

    Make a short test recording first and check what you can hear and what’s captured in the file. A separate audio setup may need extra cables or configuration time.

  • Expecting a card to record every HDMI signal

    Elgato says that devices with HDCP protection can’t record protected HDMI signals. A capture card also doesn’t give you permission to use other people’s copyrighted material.

    Check that your gameplay source provides a recordable signal. If you want to use other people’s music, images or text publicly, arrange permission separately.

Brands to compare

Elgato

The 4K S and 4K X are external capture cards for different recording and high-refresh-rate setups.

  • Elgato specifies recording up to 2160p60 for the 4K S.
  • According to Elgato, HDR recording on the 4K S is limited to 1080p60 on Windows. Supported combinations for the 4K X depend on the input signal, codec and USB connection.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer EXTREME 3 GC551G2 is an external card with HDMI pass-through and separate analogue audio connections.

  • AVerMedia lists recording up to 2160p30, 2160p60 HDR pass-through, and 3.5mm line-in and line-out.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC551G2 doesn’t support USB 2.0 or recording HDCP-protected signals.

NZXT

NZXT positions the Signal HD60 as an option for recording or streaming when 4K recording and high refresh rates aren’t required.

  • The manufacturer lists the card as an option for console and two-PC setups.
  • NZXT Support Center notes that a two-PC setup may need extra audio configuration.

Razer

The Ripsaw HD is an external capture card with HDMI pass-through and separate audio connections.

  • Razer lists 1080p60 recording, 4K60 pass-through, a USB 3.0 connection and 3.5mm connections.
  • Razer’s specification table lists up to 2160p30 for 4K recording, so 4K60 pass-through doesn’t mean it records in 4K60.

Products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I showcase a mod on my only gaming PC without a capture card?

Yes. If you’re playing on the same Windows PC, try OBS Game Capture first. OBS Project says this source doesn’t work with every game, so try another suitable capture source if it doesn’t work. A card is mainly useful for footage from a separate device.

How do I connect a card, and why can’t I hear any sound?

Connect the external HDMI source to HDMI-in. If you want to pass the signal through the card to a gaming screen, connect HDMI-out to that screen. Add the card in OBS as a video capture device and check the audio settings separately. In OBS, Capture Only means you won’t hear the audio locally by default.

Why is my PlayStation screen still black?

The capture devices mentioned here can’t record an HDMI signal protected by HDCP. Elgato explains how to turn off HDCP in the console settings for PS5 gameplay; this doesn’t make protected films or streaming services recordable.

What are my rights if a capture card I bought online isn’t suitable or is faulty?

For eligible distance purchases from a business in the Netherlands, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms and exceptions that apply to your purchase. The cooling-off period is separate from your statutory guarantee: if there’s a fault, contact the seller. According to the Dutch government, there’s no single fixed statutory guarantee period for all products in the Netherlands.

Can I use music or other third-party work in my public mod showcase?

Not automatically. The Dutch government says that, in principle, you may only use copyrighted music, images and text with the creator’s permission. Check what rights and permissions apply to the specific game, mod, music and platform.