Who is this buying guide for?

Slides from one computer

If you’re presenting and recording on the same computer, first check whether you can capture the slides in OBS using a display or window source. OBS Studio describes both capture sources.

Presenter with an HDMI camera

If you want to add camera footage, check that the camera outputs a suitable HDMI signal and that you can turn off any on-screen menus. Elgato lists this as a check for cameras used with Cam Link 4K.

Presenter with a separate screen

If you’re using a separate HDMI source and want to record the picture while also displaying it on a screen, look for HDMI pass-through. AVerMedia and Elgato describe pass-through on their respective capture models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Display or window capture

Choose this option: if the slides are on the same computer as the recording software.

The trade-off: you don’t need a capture card for this, but this option won’t automatically capture a separate HDMI camera or second laptop.

HDMI to USB without pass-through

Choose this option: if you need to connect a single separate camera to the computer as a source, and won’t be connecting an HDMI screen through the capture device.

The trade-off: Elgato says the Cam Link 4K has no HDMI output. Also check that the camera provides a clean, unprotected signal.

HDMI capture with pass-through

Choose this option: if a separate HDMI source needs to connect to both the recording computer and a screen.

The trade-off: check the capture and pass-through limits separately for the exact model; Elgato and AVerMedia provide model-specific figures.

HDMI switcher with USB output

Choose this option: if you want to switch between several HDMI cameras or computers during the same presentation.

The trade-off: a switcher is a more complex set-up than a single capture input; features vary between ATEM Mini models.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recording slides Are the slides on the recording computer or a second device? Test your chosen display or window source. If my slides are already on the recording computer, I first want to know whether I can capture them without an extra device. Around 31% of consumers prioritise recording slides without unnecessary hardware.
Connecting an HDMI camera Check that the camera provides a clean HDMI signal, that you have the right cable and that it’s suitable for use throughout the recording. If I want to use a separate camera, it needs to provide a suitable HDMI signal throughout the presentation. Around 25% of consumers say camera footage is their main buying concern.
Audio to accompany the picture Check the selected audio source and level meters in your recording software, then listen back to the test recording. If I’m recording commentary for my slides, I want to be able to hear that the microphone has actually been captured. Around 25% of consumers prioritise clear speech.
Displaying on a screen at the same time Look for HDMI output or pass-through, and compare the capture and pass-through specifications for the same model. If my external source also needs to be visible on a separate screen while I’m recording, I need a signal path for both. Around 19% of consumers cite displaying on a screen at the same time as their main buying concern.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a capture card for slides on the same computer

    If the presentation is already running on the recording computer, OBS can use a display or window as a source. A capture card would add equipment and connections that aren’t needed for that source.

    Try display or window capture first, and only add hardware if you want to connect a separate HDMI source.

  • Confusing pass-through resolution with capture resolution

    For the Elgato HD60 X, Elgato lists separate limits for pass-through and capture. So a higher pass-through figure doesn’t automatically mean that the recording will be made at the same resolution.

    Compare the capture and pass-through specifications for the exact model and the signal you want to use.

  • Assuming that a visible picture means the sound is working too

    OBS treats video and audio sources separately. Seeing a picture in the recording doesn’t confirm that the microphone or another audio source you want has been selected.

    Check the audio meters and listen back to a short test recording before the presentation.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Elgato offers both a single-camera-to-USB option and capture models with HDMI pass-through.

  • According to Elgato, Cam Link 4K processes supported, unprotected HDMI signals via USB 3.0.
  • According to Elgato, Cam Link 4K has no HDMI output. The stated capture and pass-through limits for HD60 X don’t automatically apply to Cam Link 4K.

AVerMedia

Live Gamer MINI GC311 is an HDMI-to-USB option with pass-through to a separate screen.

  • AVerMedia lists up to 1080p60 for both capture and pass-through on the GC311.
  • AVerMedia says the GC311 doesn’t process HDCP-protected signals, so check what signal your source provides.

Magewell

According to Magewell, USB Capture HDMI Gen 2 is an HDMI input to USB for use with Windows, Mac, Linux and Chrome OS, among other systems.

  • Magewell lists HDMI audio and a USB 3.0 interface.
  • Magewell warns that the actual capture frame rate may be limited by USB bandwidth and the internal operating frequency.

Blackmagic Design

ATEM Mini models are designed for set-ups where you can switch between several HDMI sources.

  • Blackmagic Design lists four HDMI inputs, a USB webcam output and recording to USB drives for the ATEM Mini Pro.
  • Features vary between ATEM models; you don’t necessarily need a switcher for one camera.

Joybuy products for HDMI capture

This selection of Joybuy products is suited to recording a separate HDMI source via USB, with HDMI pass-through to a screen.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0 and HDMI pass-through

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0, 4K pass-through, capture up to 1080p

An option for recording a separate HDMI source via USB when you also want to connect a screen through HDMI pass-through.

The product title lists capture up to 1080p and 4K pass-through, so pass-through isn’t the same as the stated capture resolution.

The title also lists a microphone input and headphone output. Check that the connections and signal are compatible with your equipment.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I record slides without a capture card?

Yes, if the presentation is running on the recording computer: OBS offers display and window sources. Check separately that the audio you want is being recorded too.

What should I test before a long recording?

Check whether you can turn off on-screen menus on an HDMI camera, whether it keeps working throughout the recording and whether it has enough power. Then make a test recording and listen back to it; also check which audio source is selected in OBS.

Should I buy an extended warranty?

No, you don’t need an extended warranty to exercise your statutory rights when buying as a consumer in the Netherlands. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the seller is responsible if a product used normally doesn’t do what you could reasonably expect; an additional warranty has its own terms.

Can I film other people clearly and share the recording?

That depends on who is recording and what happens to the footage. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an exception may apply to strictly personal use within a very limited circle. For business use or filming on behalf of an organisation, you need a legal basis under the GDPR when filming identifiable people; consent is one possible legal basis. Work out which situation applies to you, and inform the people involved before recording or publishing.