Who is a capture card for?

Game comparison creator

Wants to record different games in a consistent video format. Elgato and AVerMedia distinguish between recording and HDMI pass-through in their product specifications, so check both for your chosen display mode.

Recording in a shared room

Wants to monitor commentary and game audio without assuming that a capture card will remove room noise. OBS Project explains how to assign audio to separate tracks.

Console gamer with a demanding display

Wants to use a display mode that suits their monitor while recording. Elgato’s product specifications show why you should check the stated pass-through separately from the recording resolution.

What should you look for when choosing one?

If you’re playing and recording on the same PC without capturing a second HDMI source, you generally don’t need a capture card. If you’re recording a console or a second PC, first choose a suitable recording format, then check that the card passes your preferred gaming mode through to your monitor.

Priority What to look for Who this matters to
Comparable video recordings Check the recording resolution and frame rate for both games; compare these values separately from HDMI pass-through. When comparing two games side by side, I want to record them in the same format so I can judge the differences fairly. Around 33% of consumers prioritise comparable video recordings.
Game audio and commentary Check how game audio is captured, whether you’re using a separate microphone and whether your test recording includes the audio tracks you need. When recording in a shared bedroom, I want to be able to check commentary and game audio without accidentally capturing room noise. Audio monitoring is a priority for around 27% of consumers.
Gameplay on your monitor Compare the exact pass-through mode, including resolution and frame rate, with your source and monitor. While recording, I want to keep the display mode my monitor can handle, not just get a suitable recording file. Around 20% of consumers prioritise gameplay display and HDMI pass-through.
Computer and connections Check the required USB port, operating system and recording software for the exact card you’re considering. Before buying, I want to know that the card, USB connection and software will work with my recording computer. Computer compatibility is the main concern for around 20% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K pass-through with 4K recording

    According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo passes through up to 4K60, but records at a maximum of 1080p60. The AVerMedia Live Gamer MINI GC311 also has a pass-through limit of 1080p60.

    For the display mode you want to use, check the specifications for input, pass-through and recording separately.

  • Assuming all the necessary cables and ports are included

    Elgato doesn’t list an HDMI cable as included with the Game Capture Neo. For the 4K X, Elgato says that using a USB 3.2 Gen 1 port may reduce the available recording resolution.

    Check what’s in the box, then compare your cables and USB port with the card’s requirements.

  • Thinking a capture card will solve room noise

    Separate audio tracks in OBS can help with editing, but you need to check the settings; they won’t make a shared room quiet.

    Before a long session, record a short clip with your microphone and game audio, then check the tracks in your editing workflow.

    If commentary and game audio have already been combined on one track, separating them afterwards may mean extra editing work.

Brands and relevant models

Elgato

The Game Capture Neo, 4K S and 4K X have different recording and pass-through modes. The details below apply to these models, not the entire product range.

  • According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo records at up to 1080p60 and passes through up to 4K60. The 4K S has a stereo line input and passes through up to 4K60.
  • Elgato specifies a USB 3.2 Gen 2 port for the 4K X; using Gen 1 may result in a lower recording resolution. According to Elgato, an HDMI cable isn’t included with the Game Capture Neo.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for a Full HD setup, while the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is intended for setups with higher HDMI modes.

  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 supports recording and pass-through at up to 1080p60.
  • AVerMedia’s claim of 4K144 recording on the GC553G2 is specific to Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; for OBS on Mac, the manufacturer specifies 4K60. Check which mode suits your software.

Razer

The Razer Ripsaw HD RZ20-02850 is a model with HDMI pass-through and analogue audio connections.

  • Razer lists 4K60 pass-through, 3.5mm connections and 1080p60 as key features.
  • Razer’s technical table lists 2160p30 as the maximum recording resolution. So check the recording figure separately from the pass-through figure.

Joybuy product selection

This selection focuses on HDMI recording up to 1080p, with 4K pass-through and connections for a microphone and headphones. Check the recording and pass-through modes separately for your own setup.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card

Could suit a setup where recording at up to 1080p is enough and you want to connect a microphone and headphones.

The product title lists USB 3.0, driver-free installation, recording up to 1080p, 4K pass-through, a microphone input and a headphone output. The pass-through specification doesn’t mean it records in 4K.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if I play and record on the same PC?

Generally not, unless you need to capture an external HDMI source. According to NZXT Support Center, a capture card may be useful if you’re recording a console or a second gaming PC.

How can I keep commentary and game audio separate for editing?

In OBS, assign different audio sources to separate recording tracks and make a test recording first. OBS Project notes that standard video players often play only one track at a time, so check the result in your editing workflow too.

Can I record video that’s protected by HDCP?

Don’t assume that you can. Elgato specifies unprotected HDMI input for the models mentioned; AVerMedia says the GC311 can’t record an HDCP-protected signal. Check the settings and terms for your own source, and don’t try to bypass protections.

What are my rights when shopping online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cooling-off period from the date of delivery, subject to legal exceptions. Your statutory guarantee is separate from any manufacturer’s or seller’s guarantee.

Can my roommate be recognisable in a recording I publish?

If you share footage of an identifiable person more widely than for personal or household use, don’t assume the household exemption applies. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains this distinction; check which privacy rules apply to your recording and publication before sharing the footage.