Who is this guide for?

Creator with a single recording PC

You’re showing a game mod on the same computer that runs your recording software and want to check whether extra hardware would add anything. OBS Project describes Game Capture and other sources for content available on that computer.

Creator with a separate gaming source

You’re capturing footage from a console or second computer and want to record it, possibly while viewing it on a separate screen. Manufacturers such as Elgato and NZXT describe models with HDMI pass-through and different recording limits.

Creator with an HDMI camera

You’re filming a physical modification with a separate camera and want to check whether its output suits your recording setup. Elgato and Magewell describe HDMI input solutions; check the camera’s supported output mode and the exact device.

What should you look for?

Record directly on the same PC

Choose this if: the game mod runs on the computer with OBS installed and you can capture the content there.

Trade-off: you don’t need an extra HDMI input for this, but this setup won’t automatically capture footage from a separate console, computer or camera.

HDMI input without separate pass-through

Choose this if: you want to record from a separate HDMI camera or another source and don’t need the capture card to send the signal to a second screen.

Trade-off: an HDMI input doesn’t automatically mean the device also has an HDMI output.

HDMI capture card with pass-through

Choose this if: you’re recording from a separate console or computer and want to view the same signal on a separate screen at the same time.

Trade-off: recording and pass-through may have different maximums; compare both for your chosen resolution and frame rate.

What to consider What should you check? Which shoppers is this for?
Whether you need hardware First, work out where the mod runs and make a test recording using a suitable OBS source. If the mod already runs on my recording PC, I want to test whether OBS can capture the footage directly first. Around 36% of shoppers say whether they need extra hardware is their main buying consideration.
Screen pass-through Check for an HDMI output and compare the pass-through mode with the recording limit. When I’m gaming on a separate console, I also want to keep the footage on a separate screen. Around 29% of shoppers give screen pass-through top priority.
Camera input Check that the camera outputs an unprotected HDMI signal at a supported resolution and frame rate. If I’m filming a physical modification, my camera’s HDMI output needs to be compatible with the capture card. Around 21% of shoppers prioritise camera input.
Audio recording Work out whether sound comes in via HDMI, a separate microphone or both, then listen back to a test recording. When I’m adding commentary to the source footage, I want to make sure my voice and the source audio are both clear in the file. Around 14% of shoppers make audio quality their main buying consideration.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying a capture card when the mod already runs on your recording computer

    If the game or display source you need is already available directly in OBS, a capture card may be unnecessary. OBS Project describes sources for games, windows and displays.

    Try the relevant software source first and make a short test recording.

    This could help you avoid unnecessary hardware and extra connections in your setup.

  • Confusing 4K pass-through with 4K recording

    A card’s pass-through resolution and the footage captured by the recording computer may have different limits. NZXT states that, with Signal HD60, 4K pass-through doesn’t mean the card records to the computer in 4K.

    For the exact model, compare HDMI pass-through and recording over USB separately.

  • Assuming an HDMI input is an output for a second screen

    A device designed for input and a capture card with HDMI pass-through don’t necessarily do the same job. The Magewell USB Capture HDMI Gen 2 specifications describe one HDMI input.

    Map out the route from source to card, computer and, if needed, screen, then check the ports on the exact model.

    If you want to connect a separate screen, you may need a different signal route or a device with an HDMI output.

  • Testing only the live preview

    Seeing a picture doesn’t tell you whether the right microphone and other audio sources are included in the saved recording. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio source in multiple places can cause echo.

    Record the footage and commentary together, then listen back to the saved test file.

Brands to consider

Elgato

Offers solutions for both camera input and gaming with HDMI pass-through; the right choice depends on the signal route you need.

  • According to Elgato, Game Capture 4K S supports HDMI pass-through and recording up to 2160p60.
  • With Cam Link 4K, the compatible camera mode depends on the source; 2160p60 mode may vary by model version.

NZXT

Signal HD60 is designed for a setup where 4K pass-through is useful but 4K recording isn’t needed.

  • According to NZXT, Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal.
  • NZXT states that the model can’t record in 4K to the recording computer and doesn’t support HDR.

Magewell

USB Capture HDMI Gen 2 is an input-focused option for a separate HDMI camera or another HDMI source.

  • Magewell specifies one HDMI input with embedded audio, USB 3.0 and OBS support.
  • The model specifications don’t describe an HDMI output, so don’t assume it has a pass-through function.

AVerMedia

Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is aimed at setups with a separate gaming source where high refresh rates matter.

  • AVerMedia lists pass-through up to 4K144.
  • According to AVerMedia, recording up to 4K144 requires Streaming Center on Windows in MJPEG; this limit doesn’t automatically apply to every app or computer.

Razer

Ripsaw HD combines 1080p60 recording with 4K60 pass-through for a separate gaming source.

  • Razer lists these separate maximums for the specific Ripsaw HD model.
  • The recording limit is 1080p60; 4K60 refers to pass-through, not 4K recording.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These Joybuy product picks are HDMI capture cards with pass-through, for anyone who wants to record from a separate HDMI source and also send the signal to a second screen.

4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, black and red

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0, black and red

For a separate HDMI source when you need to record to a PC or laptop and send the signal to a second screen at the same time.

The product name lists HDMI input up to 4K 30Hz and recording up to 1080p 60Hz. The product description mentions HDMI pass-through to a second screen; the 4K specification is not a 4K recording limit.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0, microphone and headphone ports

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

For a separate HDMI source when you want to record the footage and pass it through HDMI to a second screen.

The product name lists video recording up to 1080p, 4K HDMI pass-through, UVC and UAC support, and a microphone and headphone port. The 4K specification refers to pass-through, not the recording limit.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you connect a separate HDMI source for your showcase?

Connect the source’s HDMI output to the HDMI input on a compatible capture card, then connect the card to your recording computer. If the exact model has an HDMI output and you want to use a separate screen, connect the screen to that output. Add the card in OBS as a video source and make a test recording.

How can you avoid missing commentary or duplicated audio?

Choose your microphone and other audio sources deliberately in OBS, then listen back to a saved test recording. OBS Project warns that selecting the same audio source both globally and in a scene can cause echo.

What should you check if the HDMI source shows a black screen?

First, check the cables, input mode and supported resolution. Elgato states that its capture devices can’t receive HDMI signals protected by HDCP; don’t try to bypass copy protection.

What are your rights when buying online or if a product is faulty?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy a product online you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. You’re also covered by the statutory guarantee if, under normal use, a product doesn’t do what you could reasonably expect; this isn’t automatically limited to the commercial warranty period.

Can you include visitors and game or mod content in a public showcase?

Recording for private use and sharing publicly aren’t the same thing. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the personal or household use exemption doesn’t apply when footage is shared more widely. The Dutch government also distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing protected material. So check the relevant rights and permissions; using a capture card doesn’t in itself give you the right to publish.