Who is this relevant to?

Console player

You record gameplay from a console via HDMI and want to keep the game screen usable while you play. Manufacturers such as Elgato and AVerMedia describe cards with HDMI passthrough.

Two-PC setup builder

You use a separate recording PC and need to route both game audio and commentary between the two computers. NZXT highlights audio as an important consideration in a two-PC setup.

PC player without an HDMI source

You’re comparing games running on the same Windows PC, so you can first try recording directly with software. OBS Project describes Game Capture for DirectX and OpenGL games.

What should you look for?

First, work out where the games are running and what details you need in the finished recording. Then check that the display passthrough, audio connections and computer connection suit your setup.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Recording quality Compare the recording with your source signal, software and USB port. Elgato lists a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 for Game Capture Neo, even though passthrough supports up to 4K60. I want to be able to assess small differences between games in the saved recording. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recording quality.
Display passthrough Check HDMI passthrough separately from recording. AVerMedia lists passthrough up to 1080p60 for the GC311; Elgato lists passthrough up to 2160p144 for the 4K X. I want to keep playing in my preferred screen mode while recording. Around 29% of consumers prioritise display passthrough.
Audio and commentary Map out your HDMI audio, headset and microphone separately. Elgato describes the 3.5mm connection on the 4K X as line-in, not a microphone input; NZXT highlights the audio connection when using two PCs. If I want to comment on gameplay or capture party chat, I need to be able to control the different audio sources. Around 21% of consumers prioritise audio.
Connection and setup First work out where the games are running, then check which USB port and cables you’ll need. OBS Project describes Game Capture as a direct option for games running on a single Windows PC. If both games are already running on my Windows PC, I want to know whether I can record without an extra card. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a simple setup.

Common pitfalls

  • Reading ‘4K passthrough’ as ‘4K recording’

    Passthrough to your screen and recording on your computer are separate features. Elgato lists 4K60 passthrough for Game Capture Neo, but recording is limited to 1080p60.

    Check the stated recording mode and HDMI passthrough separately before choosing a card.

    If you ultimately need 4K detail in your file, a card that only records at 1080p may not meet your needs.

  • Comparing the highest recording mode without checking the conditions

    AVerMedia’s stated 4K144 recording for the GC553G2 requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG. Elgato lists a lower recording resolution for the 4K X when using USB 3.2 Gen 1.

    Compare the modes using the software and USB port you plan to use.

  • Assuming a line-in is a microphone input

    Elgato describes the 3.5mm connection on the 4K X as line-in, not a microphone input.

    Plan for game audio and commentary as separate sources, and make a short test recording with your own headset and microphone.

    For commentary, you may need a different audio cable or a separate way to record your microphone.

Brands to compare

Elgato

The models mentioned range from 1080p60 recording to 4K recording options and higher display passthrough. The information below refers to specific models, not every capture card from the brand.

  • Elgato lists a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 with passthrough up to 4K60 for Game Capture Neo; for the 4K S, the brand lists 4K60 recording.
  • Elgato lists passthrough up to 2160p144 for the 4K X. Check recording settings and USB requirements separately: passthrough does not guarantee the same recording quality.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is an option for 1080p60; the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 offers higher HDMI modes and additional audio features.

  • AVerMedia lists a maximum of 1080p60 for both passthrough and recording on the GC311.
  • The manufacturer’s stated 4K144 recording for the GC553G2 requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG. Check that this combination works with the software you use.

NZXT

NZXT discusses the Signal HD60 and Signal 4K30 for two-PC setups.

  • In its own setup advice, NZXT recommends the Signal 4K30 for uses including 4K30 recording or high refresh rates.
  • In the same advice, NZXT highlights audio as something to consider with two PCs; this is not a comparative performance test.

Razer

The Ripsaw HD is an HDMI option if you want to record at 1080p60 and use 4K60 passthrough.

  • Razer lists 1080p60 recording alongside 4K60 passthrough for the Ripsaw HD.
  • The stated passthrough resolution doesn’t mean the card records in 4K; check whether 1080p60 is enough for your finished file.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These products are external HDMI capture cards for recording a game source; the recording options mentioned go up to 1080p.

HDMI capture card USB 3.0, 1080p60, Black + Red

HDMI capture card USB 3.0, 1080p60, Black + Red

Suitable for an external HDMI game source if recording up to 1080p60 is enough and you want to use HDMI loop-out for a second screen.

The product name lists HDMI input up to 4K 30Hz and recording up to 1080p60. The description mentions USB 3.0, HDMI loop-out and a microphone input.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0

An external HDMI option for a game comparison if recording up to 1080p meets your needs for the finished file.

The product name lists recording up to 1080p, 4K HDMI passthrough and USB 3.0. It also mentions UVC/UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to compare two games on the same Windows PC?

Not necessarily. First, try OBS Game Capture for games running directly on that PC; OBS Project describes this source for DirectX and OpenGL games. It isn’t an HDMI recording option for footage from a console or a second PC.

Does 4K passthrough mean the capture card also records in 4K?

No, they’re separate specifications. For example, Elgato lists a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 alongside 4K60 passthrough for Game Capture Neo. Check the recording and passthrough modes separately.

Why is game audio or party chat missing from my recording?

Audio sources may follow different routes. Check HDMI audio, your headset, microphone and software separately; NZXT specifically highlights the audio connection as something to consider when using two PCs. Start with a short test recording.

What can I do if a card I bought online isn’t suitable?

In many cases, when you buy from a business remotely, you have 14 days to change your mind, subject to exceptions explained by the Netherlands government. Your statutory guarantee is separate: ACM ConsuWijzer says you can contact the seller if a product doesn’t do what you could reasonably expect when used normally.

Can I publish my recorded game comparison without restrictions?

No. The ability to record does not in itself give you the right to publish. The Netherlands government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or making it available to the public. Check the rights to the footage and music too; according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for purely personal use may not apply if recognisable images are shared more widely with the public.