Who is this choice relevant to?

Console player comparing games with limited desk space

Wants to record games one after another and keep the connection between the console, recording computer and, if needed, gaming display neat. AVerMedia lists the Live Gamer MINI GC311 as measuring 100 × 57 × 18,8 mm.

Creator making side-by-side comparisons

Wants to decide in advance whether two game sources need to be recorded at the same time; one HDMI input on a card won’t be enough for this by itself. Elgato and AVerMedia each list one HDMI input for the cards mentioned.

Comparing picture quality and smoothness

Wants to weigh up recording resolution, frame rate and display output separately. Elgato and NZXT describe recording and HDMI passthrough as separate features.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, decide whether you’re recording directly from a gaming PC or using a separate HDMI source. Then consider whether separate recordings will do, and what recording quality and audio setup you need.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Compact setup and connections Map out the complete HDMI and USB signal path, and check how many ports and cables it requires. If desk space is limited, I want to know where the source, computer and, if needed, gaming display will go. Around 33% of consumers prioritise a compact, practical connection setup.
Recording one after another or simultaneously Decide whether separate recordings will do; for simultaneous recording, check the number of inputs and available USB ports. Anyone who wants to compare two games at the same time needs to record both sources simultaneously. Around 25% of consumers prioritise this capability.
Recorded picture and display output Compare each model’s recording and passthrough specifications separately, using the same target resolution and frame rate. If I want to compare picture quality fairly, the recordings need to be made using the same settings. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the quality of the recorded picture.
Audio and required connections Make a test recording with your intended console, headset and software, then check the audio in the saved file. Anyone who wants to record game audio or commentary will want to know in advance whether the headset changes the audio setup. Around 17% of consumers prioritise a working audio connection.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but it doesn’t record in 4K. Elgato lists different maximums for recording and passthrough on the HD60 X.

    Check the exact model’s product page for its recording resolution, passthrough and corresponding frame rate.

    If the recording resolution is lower than you intended, you may need to choose a different model.

  • Using one HDMI input for two simultaneous sources

    AVerMedia and Elgato each list one HDMI input for the GC311 and 4K S models mentioned. One input receives one selected HDMI source.

    Decide whether recording one source after another will do before setting up your equipment. For simultaneous recordings, check how many inputs and computer connections you’ll need.

    Two simultaneous feeds may require additional recording hardware and computer connections.

  • Assuming both headset and game audio will be recorded

    Elgato warns that some consoles don’t send audio to a capture card and headphones at the same time.

    Make a test recording with the headset you plan to use, then listen back to the saved file.

    Depending on your setup, you may need an additional audio cable or a different audio connection.

Brands to compare

AVerMedia

AVerMedia offers models for compact 1080p60 recording and for higher stated recording frame rates.

  • According to AVerMedia, the Live Gamer MINI GC311 measures 100 × 57 × 18,8 mm and supports 1080p60 recording and passthrough.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or high refresh rates. The stated 4K144 recording on the GC553G2 requires Streaming Center on Windows and uses MJPEG.

Elgato

The HD60 X and 4K S are external HDMI-to-USB capture cards. The recording mode you want determines which specifications matter.

  • Elgato lists a maximum of 4K30 recording for the HD60 X and 4K60 recording for the 4K S.
  • According to Elgato, HDR recording on the 4K S is limited to 1080p60 on Windows. The available modes may depend on the USB port you use.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is designed for anyone who wants to combine 1080p recording with 4K signal passthrough to their gaming display.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can read and pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 doesn’t record the signal in 4K, and this model doesn’t support HDR.

Joybuy products for recording games

These Joybuy products are external HDMI capture cards for recording a game source on a computer, with stated recording limits of up to 1080p.

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, recording up to 1080p60, black

USB 3.0 HDMI capture card, recording up to 1080p60, black

For an HDMI game source when 1080p60 recording is enough.

USB 3.0; HDMI input up to 4K at 30 Hz; recording up to 1080p at 60 Hz.

Joybuy
VIELLAN USB 3.0 HDMI video capture card with recording up to 1080p and 4K passthrough

VIELLAN USB 3.0 HDMI video capture card, recording up to 1080p, 4K passthrough

Suitable for an HDMI game source when 1080p recording is enough and you want to pass through a 4K signal.

USB 3.0; video recording up to 1080p; 4K HDMI passthrough.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if both games are running on my recording PC?

Usually not: try recording directly with recording software first. According to the OBS Project, you need a suitable capture source to record a separate console signal in OBS.

How do I connect one console while continuing to play on my usual display?

With a card that has HDMI passthrough, connect the console to HDMI IN, HDMI OUT to the gaming display, and USB to the recording computer. Check that the source, display and computer support the selected signal mode, then add the card as a video capture source in OBS.

Why is the PS5 picture black in the capture software?

In an Elgato setup, this can happen if HDCP is enabled. Elgato recommends turning off HDCP on the console for gameplay recording; this doesn’t make protected films or streaming services freely recordable.

How can I check whether my game comparison is usable?

Make a short test recording of both games using the same target resolution, frame rate and audio settings. Check the saved file and its audio separately from what you saw or heard on the gaming display.

Can I publish recordings featuring game footage or identifiable people?

A recording for personal use doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish protected material. The Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing material, so check the rights to game footage and music before publishing. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR may apply as soon as people are identifiable in the footage.