Which capture card is right for you?

Console tutorial creator

You want to show how controller inputs affect the game while playing on a separate screen. Compare the HDMI pass-through with the recording quality you need. OBS Project describes a game capture card as a way to capture console footage in OBS.

Button demonstrator

You want to film your grip and finger movements up close. Check that your camera has suitable, clean HDMI output and can stay powered on while recording. Elgato Support explains these checks for recording from a camera via HDMI.

Combined-view creator

You want to combine your hands, gameplay and commentary. OBS Project lets you use webcams and capture cards as video sources, so plan how to connect the sources and audio to your computer.

What should you look for in a capture card?

First decide whether you mainly want to capture gameplay, a close-up from a camera or both. Then match the connections, video modes and audio to your setup.

Gameplay on a separate screen

Choose this if: you want to record the console signal while also sending it to a screen.

Check: both the HDMI pass-through and recording quality, as these can vary by model.

Close-up of hands and controller

Choose this if: the buttons and finger movements are the focus and you have a suitable HDMI camera.

Check: a camera capture card won’t automatically pass the picture through to a gaming screen.

Combine gameplay and a view of your hands

Choose this if: you want to show both the controls and the in-game response in one tutorial.

Check: your computer needs to be able to capture the sources, and you’ll need to manage the audio too.

Try your existing recording sources first

Choose this if: a webcam you already own works directly as a video source in OBS, or your console’s recording feature is enough.

Check: this won’t automatically give you both a camera close-up and console footage as OBS sources.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Console footage and screen Compare the HDMI input and pass-through with your preferred display settings, and check the recording settings separately. I want to record gameplay while playing on a separate screen. Around 33% of consumers prioritise capturing console footage.
Close-up of controls Check that the camera has clean, unprotected HDMI output and can stay powered on while recording. I want a close-up that clearly shows grips and button presses. Around 25% of consumers give the highest priority to a view of their hands.
Combining footage and commentary Count the camera, console, USB and audio connections you’ll need, and make a short test recording. I want to record the controls, the in-game response and my commentary at the same time. Around 25% of consumers focus mainly on combining footage and commentary.
Equipment you already own Test whether your webcam works directly in OBS, and check the USB connection and included cables if you’re using a capture card. I want to check first whether my camera and computer are enough. Around 17% of consumers prioritise easy connections with equipment they already own.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K pass-through with 4K recording

    A capture card may pass a higher resolution to a screen than it can record. Elgato specifies up to 2160p60 pass-through and 1080p60 recording for Game Capture Neo. AVerMedia lists up to 1080p60 for both on the Live Gamer MINI GC311.

    For the exact model, compare the supported recording and pass-through modes with the video quality and gaming screen you want.

  • Choosing a camera capture card for a console and separate gaming screen

    An HDMI-to-USB camera solution is designed to bring a suitable camera signal into your computer. That doesn’t mean it can also pass console footage through to a gaming screen.

    Plan the signal path in advance: camera or console to the capture card and computer, and, for gameplay, to your gaming screen if needed.

  • Not checking the HDMI output in advance

    Recording from a camera may require clean HDMI output. Also check that the camera can stay on for the whole tutorial. An HDCP-protected signal may prevent recording.

    Test the camera output and make a trial recording. For console gameplay, check the official guidance for your console and signal.

    You may need a suitable cable or a solution for powering your camera for extended periods.

Brands and product ranges to consider

Elgato

Game Capture Neo and Game Capture 4K S are game capture cards with HDMI pass-through. Cam Link 4K is a separate option for a suitable HDMI camera.

  • According to Elgato, Game Capture Neo records up to 1080p60 with pass-through up to 2160p60; Game Capture 4K S can record up to 2160p60.
  • These models have different features. For Cam Link 4K, check that your camera has suitable, clean HDMI output.

AVerMedia

Live Gamer MINI GC311 is a Full HD option for recording console gameplay with HDMI pass-through.

  • AVerMedia specifies up to 1080p60 for both recording and pass-through, with a micro-USB 2.0 interface.
  • According to AVerMedia, this model doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals.

Razer

Ripsaw X is an HDMI-to-USB option for use with a camera, for example to get a close-up of your controller.

  • Razer lists recording up to 4K30 and support for OBS.
  • This is a camera-focused solution, not automatically a replacement for a game capture card with HDMI pass-through.

NZXT

In a 2022 overview, NZXT described the Signal range for uses including consoles, a second computer and cameras.

  • That overview linked HD60 with Full HD recording and another option with 4K30.
  • NZXT also noted that you need to plan your audio setup when using a headset.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These product picks are HDMI capture cards for recording console footage. For each model, check that the listed recording and pass-through modes and connections suit your setup.

4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

An option for recording gameplay in Full HD. Compare the input mode with the recording quality you need.

The product name lists HDMI input up to 4K 30 Hz, recording at 1080p at 60 Hz and USB 3.0.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card

An option for recording gameplay with HDMI pass-through. Check that the listed modes are compatible with your computer and gaming screen.

The product name lists recording up to 1080p, 4K HDMI pass-through, USB 3.0, UVC/UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if I’m only filming my hands and controller?

Not necessarily: a compatible webcam can work directly as a video source in OBS. You only need a suitable capture solution for a separate HDMI camera if you want to record that source on your computer. Check the HDMI output and preferred video mode first.

How do I connect console footage and a view of my hands for recording?

Add the available video capture devices as separate sources in OBS. Use a suitable game capture card for console footage and a camera capture card that’s compatible with your HDMI camera. Make a test recording with the picture and commentary before filming the whole tutorial.

Why is the PS5 picture black on a capture card?

An HDCP-protected HDMI signal may prevent recording. Sony Interactive Entertainment explains that, to record PS5 gameplay with an external HDMI capture card, you need to turn off HDCP in the settings. This doesn’t give you permission to record protected films or streaming services.

Which cables and aftercare should I check?

Check which cables are included and whether you already have a suitable camera, power supply and computer port. For example, Elgato states that Game Capture Neo doesn’t come with an HDMI cable. If a product is faulty, Dutch law gives you a legal guarantee from the seller, in addition to any manufacturer’s warranty. ACM ConsuWijzer explains this consumer right.

Can I return a capture card bought online in the Netherlands?

For an online consumer purchase from a business, you generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. The Dutch government and ACM ConsuWijzer explain this cooling-off period. Check who the seller is and how to notify them of a return.