Who is a capture card for?

Console streamer with limited space

You want to record console gameplay on your computer while continuing to play on your own screen. Elgato distinguishes between the footage you record and the signal sent to your screen via passthrough.

Creator who wants to keep commentary separate

You share a bedroom and want to be able to control or edit game audio, your voice and, potentially, a camera feed of your hands separately. OBS explains how to assign audio sources to separate recording tracks; the capture card is just one source in the setup.

PC gamer weighing up the alternatives first

You play and record on the same PC and want to know whether an extra device will add anything. Elgato says a capture card isn’t necessary to play and stream on the same machine in a single-PC setup; you can try capturing the game in OBS first.

What should you look for when choosing one?

Direct recording on one PC

Choose this if: your game and recording software run on the same PC; try adding a game source in OBS first.

Bear in mind: this option doesn’t replace HDMI input for a separate console, and it won’t capture your hands automatically.

External HDMI capture card

Choose this if: you want to record console gameplay on a computer and your setup needs an HDMI input.

Bear in mind: check recording and passthrough separately; a high passthrough setting doesn’t determine the quality of the recorded video file.

What to consider What should you check? Who should consider this?
Commentary and room noise Check whether you can connect your microphone to the computer or to a suitable input. A stereo line-in isn’t automatically a microphone input. If I want to edit my commentary separately afterwards and make sure it can be heard clearly, I look at the audio connections and where the recording is made. Around 33% of consumers prioritise clear commentary that can be edited separately.
Signal to your screen Check for HDMI-out and whether the passthrough setting on the exact model suits your screen and console signal. If I want to keep playing on my own screen while recording, I look for passthrough rather than relying only on the software preview. Around 27% of consumers prioritise playing directly on their own screen.
Source and computer Make a note of your game source, computer, available ports and recording software, then compare them with the specifications for the exact model. If I’m not sure whether my console, computer and connections will work together, I check that combination before buying. Around 20% of consumers prioritise connectivity and system compatibility.
Recording quality Compare the maximum recording resolution and frame rate with what you want to edit or publish. If the gameplay needs to be easy to see in my tutorial, I check the recording specifications, not just passthrough. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the final picture quality.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K60’ means 4K60 recording

    For the Elgato Game Capture Neo, 4K60 is the stated passthrough setting; the maximum recording resolution is 1080p60.

    For the exact model, compare HDMI input, passthrough and recording separately.

  • Assuming every audio connection is a microphone input

    According to the manufacturer, the Elgato HD60 X has a stereo line-in; Streamplify lists a mic-in for the CAPTURE 4K. The function varies by model.

    Check what type of connection your audio source requires. If necessary, connect your microphone separately to the computer.

  • Expecting the capture card to record room audio or your hands too

    A capture card records the connected video source. A microphone, camera footage of your hands and the setup of audio sources are separate parts of the recording.

    Make a short test recording with gameplay, commentary and the camera source before filming the tutorial.

    You may also need a separate camera source to show your hands.

Brands and models to consider

Elgato

The official specifications for Game Capture Neo and HD60 X show that their recording and passthrough capabilities differ.

  • Game Capture Neo lists recording up to 1080p60 and passthrough up to 4K60. Elgato says the model doesn’t come with an HDMI cable.
  • The HD60 X has a stereo line-in, which isn’t automatically a microphone input. Check the connections and settings on the exact model.

AVerMedia

The specifications for Live Gamer MINI GC311 and StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 differ, so check the model number carefully.

  • AVerMedia lists 1080p60 recording and 4K60 passthrough for the StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2.
  • Don’t confuse the GC311 with the GC311G2: their stated passthrough capabilities differ. AVerMedia’s claims about ease of use or latency are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements.

Razer

Razer lists HDMI in and out, 1080p60 recording, 4K60 passthrough and analogue audio connections for Ripsaw HD.

  • You can compare the stated recording and passthrough settings separately with the tutorial quality you’re aiming for.
  • The published system requirements list Windows and USB 3.0. Check these if you’re using a different computer; the specifications don’t say how quiet the complete setup is.

Streamplify

For CAPTURE 4K, Streamplify lists a mic-in, recording up to 4K30 and passthrough up to 4K60.

  • The manufacturer lists both a microphone input and separate recording and passthrough settings.
  • The stated latency figure isn’t an independent measurement. Check that the specified video setting works with your own source and computer.

Joybuy products for this setup

This selection of Joybuy products is aimed at capturing an HDMI video source with separate audio connections.

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0, 4K passthrough and microphone input

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card

May suit a setup where you record an HDMI video source via USB and want to use audio connections on the capture card.

The product name lists USB 3.0, recording up to 1080p, 4K passthrough, a microphone input and a headphone output.

Check that the listed connections and video settings suit your source, computer and desired recording.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I show the controller itself using a capture card?

An HDMI capture card records the connected video source, but it won’t automatically capture your hands or controller. Add a separate camera source for this, then check how the gameplay and camera footage appear together in the recording before publishing.

How can I keep my voice and game audio separate when editing?

In OBS, you can assign audio sources to separate recording tracks and make a test recording first. OBS notes that standard video players generally play only one track at a time; bear this in mind if you won’t be editing the footage first.

Will noise suppression help if someone I live with is talking in the room?

Don’t expect noise suppression to remove much sound from a busy room. OBS describes the feature as useful for light background noise; listen back to your test recording and, if necessary, change where or when you record.

Why might I get a black screen from a PlayStation 5?

Elgato says its capture cards can’t capture an HDMI signal when HDCP protection is enabled, and that HDCP is switched on by default on PlayStation 5. For permitted gameplay, follow the setup instructions for your console and capture card; this doesn’t give you permission to record protected films or services.

Can someone I live with appear recognisably in an online controller tutorial?

Don’t assume you have general permission. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers recognisable people in footage to be personal data and says the exception for personal or household use doesn’t apply when sharing outside a limited private circle. Assess the publication of identifiable footage separately, and position your camera and microphone so that people you live with aren’t recorded unintentionally.