Who would benefit from a capture card for console gaming?

Streamer who plays quietly through a headset

Wants to hear game audio in a shared bedroom without using speakers, and needs to check how that audio will also reach the broadcast. Elgato explains that, with certain consoles, connecting a headset can stop audio from being sent over HDMI.

Console gamer with a dedicated gaming monitor

Wants to keep playing on their monitor, so needs to distinguish HDMI passthrough to the screen from recording to the computer. Elgato, AVerMedia and NZXT describe these features for each model.

Beginner with a laptop or PC

Wants to add their console to streaming software and needs to check which computer port, software and audio settings are suitable. OBS Project explains how to add a capture card as a video capture device.

What should you look for in a capture card for a shared bedroom?

First, check how you’ll hear the audio and how it will get into your stream. Then compare the passthrough to your monitor with the separate recording function.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this most relevant to?
Headset audio for you and your stream Check your console, headset, any line-in connection, and the separate audio routes for listening and streaming. If I want to play quietly, I want to hear my game without speakers and check that the stream also gets the audio it needs. Around 36% of consumers prioritise headset audio for both the player and the stream.
Picture on your gaming monitor For the exact model, compare the console output, HDMI passthrough to the monitor and recording resolution. If I play on my own monitor, I want to keep the picture I want and know whether the card passes that signal through. Around 29% of consumers prioritise preserving the monitor signal.
Setup with a laptop or PC Check the computer port and software you need; add the card to OBS as a video capture device, then test the picture and sound. If I’m starting with a laptop or PC, I want to be able to connect the card and set up my video and audio sources correctly. Around 21% of consumers prioritise an easy setup.
4K recording Look up the recording capabilities of the exact model and check separately for any HDR recording limitations. If I really want to record my gameplay in 4K, I want to distinguish recording from 4K passthrough alone. Around 14% of consumers prioritise 4K recording.

Common mistakes when buying a capture card

  • Assuming ‘4K’ guarantees 4K recording

    For the NZXT Signal HD60, NZXT distinguishes between passing through a 4K signal and recording or streaming to a PC in 4K.

    For the exact model, compare the HDMI input, passthrough to your monitor and recording resolution separately.

  • Assuming headset audio will automatically be included in the stream

    Elgato warns that, with PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2, connecting a headset can stop audio from being sent over HDMI.

    Before buying, map out the audio route from the console to your headset and to the recording. Check whether your equipment supports a suitable analogue connection.

    A suitable analogue audio route may require an extra cable and a compatible line-in connection.

Brands to consider

Elgato

The Elgato Game Capture 4K S is an external option if you’re looking for 4K60 recording, HDMI passthrough and an analogue line-in connection.

  • According to Elgato, this model supports 4K60 recording and passthrough.
  • Elgato states that HDR recording is limited to 1080p60 and is currently available on Windows only. An analogue line-in connection is not a headphone output, so check the complete audio setup.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia, the StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 is designed for 1080p60 recording with 4K60 passthrough to your screen.

  • The stated recording and passthrough resolutions differ, so you can play at 4K60 while recording at 1080p60.
  • Check separately whether the card is suitable for your headset, audio setup and computer; the stated picture specifications don’t answer those questions.

NZXT

The NZXT Signal HD60 is worth comparing if 1080p recording is enough and HDR isn’t essential.

  • According to NZXT, this model can read and pass through a 4K signal.
  • NZXT states that the Signal HD60 can’t record or stream to a computer in 4K and doesn’t support HDR.

Capture cards at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions about capture cards for console gaming

Can I play with a headset while the stream gets game audio?

It depends on your console and audio setup. Elgato warns that, with PlayStation 4 and 5 and Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, connecting a headset can stop audio from being sent over HDMI. Check whether your headset and recording device support a suitable analogue connection, or try another supported audio setting.

How do I connect a capture card to OBS?

Connect the console to the card’s HDMI input and, if you’re playing on a monitor, connect the HDMI output to a monitor that supports the passthrough you want. Add the card to OBS as a video capture device, then check the recording and audio settings separately.

What can I do if the capture card is faulty or I change my mind about an online purchase?

According to the Authority for Consumers & Markets, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee if a product is faulty. For online purchases, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery; check the applicable exceptions and returns policy.

Can my flatmate be recognisable in a public livestream?

Don’t assume that recognisable footage of your flatmate can automatically be included in the stream. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR generally doesn’t apply to recordings made purely for personal or household use, but may become relevant when camera footage is made available online to an unrestricted audience; the authority also mentions the consent of people being filmed. Discuss the recording in advance and, if necessary, keep others out of shot and out of the audio.

Can I stream game footage and music publicly without permission?

A capture card doesn’t in itself give you the rights to publish protected material. According to Auteursrecht.nl, you generally need permission from the rights holder to make copyright-protected material available online, unless an applicable exception applies. Check the terms for the game and any music separately.