Who is this guide for?

New streamer aiming for 1080p

You want to record console gameplay in OBS and play on a separate screen, without paying for 4K recording you don't need. OBS Project explains how to use capture devices for console footage in OBS; Elgato and AVerMedia specify models that record at 1080p60.

Gamer with a high-refresh-rate monitor

You want to maintain the passthrough quality and refresh rate you need on your own screen while streaming, perhaps with VRR. Elgato specifies models with different passthrough options, including VRR on the 4K S.

Creator with an existing streaming PC

Your choice depends on the USB connection, operating system, OBS and how you add game audio. Elgato notes that a slower USB connection can limit the available recording resolution on the 4K X; OBS supports capture cards as a video source.

What should you look for?

First, compare the HDMI passthrough to your gaming screen with the recording output for your stream. Then check that your computer, software and audio setup are compatible with the card.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Picture on your gaming screen Compare your desired resolution, Hz, HDR and VRR with the card's passthrough capabilities and those of your console and monitor. Elgato specifies passthrough of up to 4K60 for the Game Capture Neo. If I mainly want to keep playing smoothly on my own screen while streaming, I check the entire video signal chain; around 33% of consumers prioritise their gaming screen.
Recording output Check the maximum recording resolution, frame rate and HDR requirements separately. Elgato and AVerMedia specify 1080p60 recording for the Neo and StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2; Elgato specifies recording up to 4K60 for the 4K S. When I want to record footage in OBS or another streaming application, I focus on the actual recording output, not just a 4K label; around 25% of consumers give recording quality top priority.
Connection and software Check the USB speed, cable, operating system and software requirements for the exact model. Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 for the 4K X; according to Elgato, USB 3.2 Gen 1 works at a lower recording resolution. OBS can add a compatible card as a video source. If I want to use my existing streaming PC, I first check that its ports and software are compatible with the card; around 25% of consumers rank compatibility above other purchasing priorities.
Audio and HDMI setup Decide where to connect the game audio and any microphone audio, and check which HDMI ports you need. Razer lists separate audio inputs for the Ripsaw HD; Elgato describes an HDMI In, HDMI Out and USB setup for PS5. When I want to combine game audio and microphone audio in my streaming setup, I check the signal path and connections; around 17% of consumers give audio and setup top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘4K’ means 4K recording

    For the Elgato Game Capture Neo and AVerMedia StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2, 4K60 passthrough refers to the picture sent to your gaming screen. According to their manufacturers, both models are designed to record at up to 1080p60.

    For each model, compare the HDMI passthrough and recording output for your stream separately.

  • Focusing only on the capture card when you need a high refresh rate

    Your desired resolution and Hz must also be supported by your console, monitor, cables and computer. Elgato says the 4K X needs a suitable USB connection to deliver its full capabilities; AVerMedia requires a compatible display for the 4K144, VRR and HDR passthrough mentioned.

    Check the connections and supported picture formats throughout your setup before choosing a card.

  • Assuming a black PS5 picture means the card is faulty

    According to Elgato, its capture devices cannot display or record HDMI signals while HDCP protection is active.

    For supported gameplay, follow the manufacturer's setup instructions for your specific model. Do not try to capture protected films or streaming services.

Brands to consider

Elgato

According to Elgato, the Game Capture Neo, 4K S and 4K X are designed for different recording and passthrough needs.

  • The Neo is specified for recording at up to 1080p60, while the 4K S records at up to 4K60. The 4K X has HDMI 2.1 and passthrough of up to 4K144.
  • The USB connection can limit the 4K X's available capabilities. Also check the HDR recording requirements for each model and operating system.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia, the StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 is designed for 1080p60 recording with 4K60 passthrough, while the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is aimed at higher passthrough rates and 4K recording.

  • AVerMedia specifies 4K144 passthrough and 4K60 recording for the GC553G2.
  • For the GC553G2's stated 4K144, VRR and HDR capabilities, AVerMedia requires a compatible HDMI 2.1 display. The GC311G2 is not a 4K recording card.

Razer

The Ripsaw HD may be worth considering if separate audio connections are part of your console and PC setup.

  • Razer lists 1080p60 as the main recording feature, alongside 4K60 passthrough and microphone and aux inputs.
  • Razer's support information also lists 2160p30 recording in its specifications table. Check that the recording format you want is supported by the exact model version.

Joybuy capture card products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a capture card for OBS?

No, not always. OBS Project describes both using a capture device and connecting via PS Remote Play or the Xbox app for supported consoles; the network option depends on a sufficiently fast connection between your console and computer. If you want to use the console's HDMI signal as a video source in OBS, choose a suitable capture solution.

How do I connect a PS5 if the picture stays black through my capture card?

In its PS5 setup instructions for the Elgato 4K X, Elgato says to turn off HDCP in the HDMI system settings before connecting the card. Then connect the console to HDMI In, HDMI Out to the display, and the card to the computer via USB. This is a model-specific instruction for supported gameplay, not permission to capture protected films or streaming services.

Will every capture card work with my Nintendo Switch?

Not every model or setup will. OBS Project explains how to capture footage from a docked Nintendo Switch and notes that the Switch Lite cannot be docked. Also check the inputs and supported picture formats for the exact capture card.

What if a capture card I bought online isn't suitable or breaks too soon?

For a standard online consumer purchase, ACM ConsuWijzer says you generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period from delivery; check the applicable terms and exceptions. In addition, ACM ConsuWijzer says the seller must provide an appropriate solution at no cost if a product breaks too soon under normal use, such as a repair, replacement or refund.

Can I use music or other protected material in my gameplay stream?

A capture card does not give you the rights to broadcast protected material. The Dutch government says you need the creator's permission to use copyright-protected music, films and photos, and that a private copy for personal use must not be made public. Check the rights and terms that apply to the game and music in your stream.