Who is a capture card for co-op streaming for?

Hosts who want teammates to be heard

You play on a console or a second PC and want to bring game audio, your own voice and your teammates’ voices together in the stream. OBS’s audio mixer provides separate sources and monitoring so you can check the sound.

Console streamers with a separate streaming PC

You want to capture your console’s HDMI output while playing on a separate screen. Compare the recording and passthrough specifications for the exact model.

Hosts showing two gameplay feeds at once

You want to show two separate HDMI sources at the same time. If so, count the video and audio inputs your streaming setup needs.

What should you consider when choosing one?

First, decide whether you need to capture a separate HDMI source and how many sources need to be on screen at once. Then compare recording, passthrough and audio features with your equipment and streaming software.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Game audio and voices Check the HDMI audio route, any analogue chat connections and the audio sources in OBS. Make a test recording and listen back to it. If I want game audio, my voice and my teammates’ voices to be heard together, I need to be able to check the audio route. Around 31% of consumers prioritise clear co-op conversations.
HDMI source and recording quality Note the source, your preferred recording resolution and frame rate, and your PC’s USB or PCIe connection. Compare the recording features with passthrough on the exact model. When I connect a console or a second PC, I want the source and the recording quality I’m after to suit my setup. Around 31% of consumers prioritise compatible video capture.
Gameplay picture while streaming Check the resolution, refresh rate, HDR and VRR you want for the specific combination of source, card and screen. Consider recording and passthrough separately. If I play on my own screen while streaming, I want to know which signal mode is passed through and what the software records. Around 23% of consumers prioritise their own gameplay picture.
Two pictures at once Count the HDMI sources that need to be on screen at the same time. Check whether your recording setup sends them separately to the streaming PC. If viewers need to see two separate gameplay feeds, I need more than one source being passed through. Around 15% of consumers prioritise two simultaneous feeds.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing passthrough with recording

    A card may pass through a 4K signal without recording it to your PC in 4K. NZXT notes this limitation for the Signal HD60.

    Check the recording and passthrough specifications separately for the exact model.

  • Ignoring the software requirements behind a recording claim

    AVerMedia’s claim of recording at up to 4K144 on the GC553G2 requires Streaming Center and the MJPEG format.

    Check which resolution, frame rate and format you need with your own streaming software.

  • Expecting one HDMI input to capture two feeds

    The Elgato 4K X has one HDMI input for one video signal; it cannot independently record two separate sources at the same time.

    Decide in advance whether co-op means one shared picture or two separate feeds, then check how many inputs you need.

  • Going live without testing the audio

    Seeing a video picture doesn’t automatically mean game audio, your microphone and chat are coming through properly in the stream. OBS handles audio sources and monitoring separately.

    Make a short test recording with all the audio sources you want, then listen back to it before going live.

Brands and models to consider

Elgato

The models mentioned include external USB cards with HDMI 2.0 or HDMI 2.1, as well as an internal PCIe card with HDMI 2.1.

  • According to Elgato, the Game Capture 4K S supports recording at up to 2160p60. The 4K X has HDMI 2.1 and a USB 3.2 Gen 2 interface.
  • The internal 4K Pro requires PCIe. Elgato specifies recording at up to 2160p60 and no support for DSC signals. These are manufacturer specifications, not independent practical tests.

AVerMedia

The external Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is worth considering if HDMI 2.1 and the party chat setup are important to you.

  • AVerMedia describes this model as having a built-in party chat feature.
  • According to AVerMedia, recording at up to 4K144 requires Streaming Center and MJPEG. The manufacturer specifies 5.1 audio recording for Windows only. These are model and usage requirements, not independent measurements.

Razer

The Ripsaw HD is an external HDMI 2.0 and USB 3.0 option to consider for 1080p60 streaming and audio connections.

  • Razer specifies 1080p60 recording, 4K60 passthrough, and microphone and headphone connections.
  • 4K60 passthrough doesn’t mean 4K60 recording. Check that the connections and audio configuration suit your setup.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is an example of an external capture card; NZXT also discusses audio configuration for a two-PC setup.

  • According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 can receive and pass through a 4K signal.
  • NZXT states that this model doesn’t record or stream the signal to the PC in 4K and doesn’t support HDR. This information applies to the Signal HD60, not all products from the brand.

Capture cards on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do you connect a console for a stream?

In the Elgato 4K X setup, the console connects to HDMI IN, HDMI OUT connects to the gaming screen, and USB connects to the streaming PC. Add the card as a video source in OBS. For other models, check their connections and manual.

Why does a PS5 capture card show a black screen?

With the 4K X, Elgato says that enabling HDCP can cause a black screen. For PS5 gameplay, Elgato recommends turning off the setting Settings > System > HDMI > Enable HDCP. This doesn’t make copy-protected films or apps available to record.

How can you check that your friends and game audio sound right?

Use OBS’s level meters and monitoring, adjust the individual sources, and listen back to a test recording. Don’t assume the audio is set up properly just because you can see the video.

Can you show identifiable teammates in a public co-op stream?

First, consider whether you have a valid legal basis for sharing the footage. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use doesn’t apply when identifiable footage is shared more widely; in many cases, you’ll need consent. Talk to everyone involved in advance about what will be shown.

Can you stream music from a game or in the background without permission?

A capture card doesn’t give you music rights. BumaStemra says that you don’t need a separate BumaStemra live-streaming licence for music by its members on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram or Twitch, but warns that other rights holders may still have a stream blocked. Commercial posts and broadcasts on your own website may require different permissions.