Who is this choice relevant to?

Console player with a streaming PC

If you want to show HDMI gameplay from a separate console in OBS while playing on your own screen, a capture device is one way to bring in the video. OBS Project explains how to use a game capture device for console footage.

Streamer with commentary or party chat

If clear conversations matter, check how game audio, your microphone and any party chat will come through on the stream. Elgato describes a limitation with HDMI game audio when a headset is connected to the console or controller for a PlayStation 5 with Game Capture Neo.

PC gamer with a temporary setup

If the game and OBS are running on the same PC, OBS Game Capture can capture the game directly. OBS Project describes this source for games that use DirectX or OpenGL.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether your video is coming from a console or the same PC as OBS. Then check the audio separately, along with the display mode you want to keep on your gaming screen.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Game source and computer Note whether your source is a separate HDMI console or the same PC, and check which USB port or PCIe connection is required. If I’m connecting a console to a separate streaming PC, I want to know in advance whether the card and computer are compatible. Around 31% of consumers are mainly concerned with this source and compatibility question.
Game audio, microphone and party chat Work out the audio setup and test your headset with a sample recording. If conversations are part of the broadcast, I want to check that game audio, my microphone and party chat can all be heard. Around 25% of consumers put this audio setup first.
Picture on your gaming screen Compare the source and screen resolution and refresh rate with the passthrough supported by the exact model; check recording separately. If I want to keep my preferred display mode while playing, I check the passthrough rather than just the recording quality. Around 19% of consumers prioritise these display settings.
A separate camera For an HDMI camera, check its output, any menu overlays, power supply and operating time. If I want to show a separate camera alongside gameplay, I need to check whether it can be connected as a separate video source. This is the main buying priority for around 13% of consumers.
Avoiding extra equipment For PC gaming, try OBS Game Capture first, then check which ports and cables you actually need. For a one-off stream, I don’t want to connect more hardware than my setup requires. Around 12% of consumers mainly want to avoid unnecessary extra equipment.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming 4K passthrough means 4K recording

    Passthrough describes the signal sent to your gaming screen; recording describes what the card captures. The Elgato Game Capture Neo lists passthrough up to 4K60 and recording up to 1080p60. The AVerMedia GC311 lists up to 1080p60 for both.

    Compare the passthrough and recording specifications separately for the exact model.

  • Choosing a card without checking your computer’s port

    Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 for the 4K X and PCIe 2.0 x4 for the internal 4K60 Pro MK.2. Without the right connection, your planned setup won’t work.

    Check the exact port type and which cables are included with your chosen model.

    A missing compatible connection or HDMI cable could prevent your planned setup from working. Check what you already have and what you still need beforehand.

  • Assuming HDMI video will include all conversations

    Elgato explains that, on a PS5 with Game Capture Neo, a headset connected to the console or controller can affect the HDMI game audio output.

    Test game audio, your microphone and party chat separately with the equipment you’ll use during the session.

    You may need extra equipment or settings to use a different audio setup; what’s required depends on your existing headset and connections.

  • Assuming a charity stream gives you permission to use images or music

    A fundraiser doesn’t automatically remove privacy or copyright requirements. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains the conditions for filming and publishing recognisable people at events; for copyright-protected music, the Dutch government says you need permission from the creator.

    Before you go live, check who will be recognisable on camera and which protected music or other content will be heard. Where necessary, make sure you have an appropriate legal basis or permission.

Brands to compare

Elgato

The models mentioned range from external cards for 1080p60 recording to an internal card for desktops with PCIe. These are manufacturer specifications, not results from independent performance tests.

  • Elgato lists 1080p60 recording and passthrough up to 4K60 for Game Capture Neo; the 4K X supports higher passthrough modes.
  • According to Elgato, Game Capture Neo doesn’t include an HDMI cable and has no analogue audio input. The 4K X requires USB 3.2 Gen 2 for the specified connection, while the 4K60 Pro MK.2 requires a compatible PCIe setup.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for Full HD input and passthrough, while the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 supports higher HDMI modes.

  • AVerMedia lists passthrough and recording up to 1080p60 for the GC311.
  • AVerMedia requires Streaming Center on Windows for 4K144 recording on the GC553G2 and specifies MJPEG. For OBS on Mac, the manufacturer lists 4K60 recording.

EVGA

The XR1 Lite and XR1 Pro are separate external USB models for HDMI game capture.

  • EVGA lists recording up to 1080p60 with 4K60 passthrough for the XR1 Lite. For the XR1 Pro, the manufacturer specifies recording up to 4K30 and additional audio mix controls.
  • These differences apply to each individual model; on their own, they don’t tell you which card is best for your computer, screen or audio setup.

Razer

Ripsaw HD is an external option for a separate console and streaming computer.

  • Razer lists 1080p60 recording and 4K60 passthrough for this model.
  • The product page referenced is for a different sales region. Before buying, check the specifications and connections of the product version you’re considering.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These products are external HDMI-to-USB capture cards for a separate HDMI source and a streaming computer. Check that the recording, passthrough and connections listed for each model suit your setup.

HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, Black + Red

4K HDMI Capture Card, USB 3.0, Black + Red

For connecting a separate HDMI source to a streaming computer; the product name specifies USB 3.0.

HDMI input up to 4K 30Hz; recording up to 1080P 60Hz. These are separate modes.

The product name specifies compatibility with PCs and laptops.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0

For connecting a separate HDMI source to a streaming computer; the product name specifies USB 3.0.

The product name specifies capture up to 1080p and 4K HDMI passthrough.

Also listed: UVC and UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you connect a console to OBS?

With a compatible capture card, connect the console’s HDMI output to HDMI-in, HDMI-out to your gaming screen, and USB to the streaming computer. Add a video capture device in OBS and make a test recording to check the resolution and frame rate; the exact connections vary by model.

Why can I see the picture but can’t hear PlayStation 5 audio?

Elgato explains that, with Game Capture Neo, the PS5 doesn’t send game audio over HDMI when a headset is connected to the console or controller. Check the audio output and test the headset and chat routes separately.

What can you check if your console screen is black?

Check the signal mode, connections and HDCP setting. Elgato states that its capture devices can’t capture HDMI signals protected by HDCP. Don’t use a capture card to record protected films or other protected content.

Which cables and warranty details should you check beforehand?

Check which HDMI cables are included with your chosen model; Elgato states that Game Capture Neo doesn’t include an HDMI cable. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands.

Can you broadcast participants and background music during a charity stream?

If a company or organisation films and publishes recognisable people at an event, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says the GDPR applies and a legal basis is required. Consent is often an appropriate legal basis, but it isn’t the only one. For copyright-protected music, the Dutch government says you need permission from the creator. Check the requirements for your specific stream and the content you plan to use.