Who are these options for?

The sociable camper

You’re listening back to a memo and want to stay in touch with the people and sounds around your pitch. Compare an open-ear design with in-ear earbuds that have an ambient sound mode.

Listener of quiet recordings

You want to make out the words in a quiet memo when background noise is distracting. Pay attention to the fit and keep the volume at a sensible level.

Camper without a regular charging spot

You listen at different times throughout the day and want to know how long the earbuds themselves last before they need charging. Compare listening time per charge with the total including the case, and consider moisture and dirt too.

What should you look for when choosing?

Open-ear

When: if you want to remain approachable while listening and keep the sounds around you accessible.

Trade-off: an open design doesn’t physically block out distracting background noise, and doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear everything around you.

Sealing in-ear

When: if you want to follow a quiet recording more easily and switch between listening modes when needed.

Trade-off: fit varies from person to person, and an ambient sound mode doesn’t guarantee that you’ll be aware of everything around you.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Awareness of your surroundings Compare open-ear earbuds with in-ear models that have an ambient sound mode. Check whether you can still follow what’s happening around you at a sensible volume. If I want to listen to a memo by the tent without losing touch with the people around me, awareness of my surroundings comes first. Around 31% of consumers prioritise this.
Clarity Consider the fit, the available listening modes and whether you can follow the recording at a sensible volume. If I mainly want to make out quiet speech when background noise is distracting, I look for a suitable listening mode and a good seal. Around 31% of consumers say clarity is their top priority.
Listening time without a charging spot Compare listening time per charge with the total including the case, and check which listening mode the manufacturer used to quote the battery life. If I listen back at different times throughout the day and don’t want to keep looking for somewhere to charge, I check the listening time per charge. Around 23% of consumers say this is their main consideration.
Fit, moisture and dirt Check the style, the protection rating for the earbuds and case separately, and the care instructions for the exact model. If I’m looking for a comfortable pair to use carefully at the campsite, I also check how to protect them from moisture and dirt. Around 15% of consumers prioritise fit and protection.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking total battery life, including the case, for continuous listening time

    Consumentenbond points out that the quoted total battery life may include charges from the case. You can’t wear the earbuds while they’re charging in the case. JBL states that the Wave Buds 2 offer up to 40 hours in total with ANC off.

    Compare listening time per charge with the total including the case, and check which listening mode the manufacturer used to calculate battery life.

  • Assuming the earbuds’ protection rating also applies to the case

    The stated protection can vary between components. JBL specifies IP54 for the Wave Buds 2 and IPX2 for the case, so the ratings aren’t the same. Sony advises wiping moisture from the charging contacts and letting the port dry at room temperature.

    Check the protection rating for each component separately, store the case somewhere dry and follow the care instructions for the exact model.

  • Turning the volume up repeatedly to hear a quiet memo

    The World Health Organization points out that sound level, listening time and repeated exposure to loud noise are all linked to hearing risks.

    First try improving the fit, switching to another listening mode or moving somewhere quieter, and keep the volume at a sensible level.

Brands to consider

Shokz

The OpenFit 2 is an example of an open-ear design for staying connected to your surroundings at the campsite while listening.

  • Shokz lists an open design and physical buttons for the OpenFit 2. The manufacturer quotes up to 48 hours including the case.
  • An open design doesn’t physically block out a noisy environment, nor does it guarantee that a quiet voice memo will be clear.

Sony

The WF-C510 is a sealing in-ear model with an ambient sound mode.

  • Sony specifies up to 8 hours of playback with ambient sound mode on and 11 hours with it off.
  • Sony lists an IPX4 rating, which doesn’t include a dust rating. You’ll need to judge the fit for yourself.

JBL

According to JBL, the Wave Buds 2 combine Smart Ambient with active noise cancelling for those who want to switch between listening modes.

  • JBL specifies IP54 for the earbuds and IPX2 for the case. The manufacturer quotes up to 40 hours including the case with ANC off.
  • These specifications don’t tell you how clearly you’ll hear a quiet memo or how long playback lasts with ANC on.

Earbuds for different listening preferences

This selection of Joybuy products includes open-ear models for keeping the sounds around you accessible, plus an in-ear model that lets you switch between greater isolation and ambient sound.

Bose Ultra Open Earbuds 2nd Gen - Cherry Chocolate

Bose Ultra Open Earbuds 2nd Gen - Cherry Chocolate

Suited to anyone who wants to keep the sounds around them accessible while listening back; an open design doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear every sound.

View at Joybuy
Bose Sport Open Earbuds - Black

Bose Sport Open Earbuds - Black

An open-ear option for anyone who wants to keep the sounds around the campsite accessible while listening; check that the style suits you.

View at Joybuy
Bose Ultra Open Earbuds Black

Bose Ultra Open Earbuds Black

Suited to anyone who wants to keep their ear canal clear while listening back; bear in mind that open-ear doesn’t mean physically blocking out background noise.

View at Joybuy
Sony LinkBuds Clip – Wireless Open-Ear Earbuds-Black

Sony LinkBuds Clip – Wireless Open-Ear Earbuds-Black

An open-ear option for keeping the sounds around you accessible; check that the available listening modes suit your memo and situation.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

An in-ear option for switching between greater isolation and ambient sound; check that the fit is comfortable and the listening modes suit your recording.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are open-ear earbuds always the right choice for a voice memo?

No. They leave your ear canal clear if you want to remain approachable, but a well-fitting, sealing in-ear pair may be more practical when background noise is distracting. In either case, keep the volume at a sensible level.

What should you check if your earbuds won’t charge after a damp night?

For the WF-C510, check that the earbuds are properly seated in the case and that the contacts are clean. Sony advises wiping moisture from the charging contacts and letting them dry at room temperature. For another model, refer to its own manual.

Does your statutory guarantee end when the manufacturer’s warranty expires?

No. When a consumer buys a product in the Netherlands, the statutory guarantee is separate from any additional manufacturer’s warranty. The appropriate remedy depends on the circumstances of the fault.

Can you wear earbuds when cycling away from the campsite?

The Dutch government allows hands-free listening, but you mustn’t hold a mobile device while cycling. That’s a different situation from relaxing at the campsite and listening back to a memo.

Should you mainly look at the microphone when choosing earbuds for listening back?

Not if you’re only listening to an existing memo. In that case, consider the fit, listening modes, controls and listening time. Microphone information relates to recording or transmitting your voice, not directly to playing back a memo.