Which type of scanner is right for you?

Preserving fragile books

If you’re scanning older, bound books, the condition of the original determines how far you can safely open it. The National Archives of the Netherlands emphasises that the physical condition of an item is an important consideration when digitising it.

Creating a searchable school archive

If you want to find passages again later, look at both the OCR and the quality of the page image. I.R.I.S. lists searchable PDF as an output option; check the text recognition on pages from your own books.

Working with a mix of source materials

If you’re combining books, loose documents and photos, match the scanning area to the materials. Epson describes its Perfection V39II as an A4 flatbed for photos and documents; CZUR positions the Shine 800 A3 Pro primarily for flat materials.

What should you look for when choosing?

Overhead scanner for bound books

Choose this option: if a fragile or thick binding can’t be safely pressed flat, or if you’re scanning lots of bound pages. CZUR positions its ET series for books, with curve correction; I.R.I.S. lists A3 capture and searchable PDF for the Desk 6 Pro.

Consider: use a test scan to check whether curved lines, shadows and text near the spine are clearly visible. Manufacturer features aren’t an independent assessment of the complete scanning workflow.

Book-edge scanner

Choose this option: if a book within the A4 scanning area can rest safely on the glass. Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge for the OpticBook 4800.

Consider: each page needs to be placed on the glass. Don’t force the binding, and check that the software works with the school’s computer.

Standard flatbed scanner

Choose this option: if sturdy books fit within the scanning area and you also want to scan loose photos or documents. Epson lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm for the Perfection V39II.

Consider: a flatbed isn’t specifically designed for fragile book bindings. Use a test scan to check that text near the spine remains legible.

Document camera for flat materials

Choose this option: if you’re mainly scanning loose, flat pages or A3 materials. CZUR positions the Shine 800 A3 Pro for flat materials and specifies 8 MP and 205 dpi for A3.

Consider: don’t confuse this model with the ET series for bound books. Check small print on a test scan; the stated resolution alone doesn’t prove that book pages will be easy to read.

What to consider What to check Who is this important to?
Protecting the book binding Check the condition of the binding and make a test scan of the inner margin. Compare overhead scanning with a book-edge scanner. When I scan a fragile, bound book, I don’t want to press the binding flat. Around 40% of consumers put protecting the binding at the top of their list when buying.
Making lots of pages searchable Check whether the software can create searchable PDFs, and test names, dates and text close to the spine on pages from your own materials. When there are lots of pages, I want to be able to find passages again later without overlooking OCR errors. Around 30% of consumers prioritise searchability when dealing with lots of pages.
Scanning a mix of materials Compare the scanning area with your books and loose materials; also check whether a book can rest safely on the glass. If our project also includes loose photos and documents, I want to know whether one device can handle them without forcing a fragile binding. Around 20% of consumers prioritise versatility.
Materials larger than A4 Measure the largest page or open spread, and check small print in a test scan at the intended size. If a book or document is larger than A4, I want to know whether the whole page will fit in a single scan. Around 10% of consumers prioritise a larger scanning size.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a document camera is the same as a book scanner

    CZUR positions the Shine 800 A3 Pro primarily for flat materials and the ET series for book scanning with curve correction. So the model name alone doesn’t tell you whether a scanner is suitable for thick books.

    Check the full model name and make a test scan of a curved book page, not just a loose sheet.

    If the text near the spine isn’t legible, rescanning or correcting the image afterwards could take extra time.

  • Treating a dpi or megapixel figure as a guarantee of quality

    A specification doesn’t prove that the inner margin will be legible, that OCR will work correctly or that all the original information will be visible.

    Check a test scan for small text, images and missing parts of the page. Keep a checked page image as well as a searchable version.

    Checking and editing scans can take extra time, particularly if recognition errors need correcting.

  • Sharing a scan made for personal use without checking first

    Making a copy for personal use doesn’t automatically give you permission to distribute a book or publish it online. Different conditions may apply when using extracts for education.

    Decide in advance what you want to share and with whom, and check the rights or relevant educational arrangements before making the scan available.

Brands to consider

CZUR

CZUR positions different models for different scanning materials: the ET series for bound books and the Shine 800 A3 Pro primarily for flat pages.

  • According to CZUR, the ET series doesn’t put pressure on the book spine; the manufacturer lists curve correction for this series.
  • For the Shine 800 A3 Pro, CZUR specifies 8 MP and 205 dpi for A3 and recommends the model for flat materials. This doesn’t make it technically equivalent to the ET series.

I.R.I.S.

I.R.I.S. positions the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro as an overhead scanner for A3 documents and books, among other materials, with searchable output options.

  • I.R.I.S. lists searchable PDF as an output option.
  • The stated speed isn’t an independent assessment of a complete book-scanning workflow. Test OCR and image quality on your own materials.

Plustek

Plustek positions the OpticBook 4800 as an A4 book-edge scanner for books that can rest safely on the glass.

  • Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and OCR software for Windows and Mac.
  • The scanning area is A4, and pages need to be placed on the glass. This limits its use with larger or fragile books.

Epson

Epson positions the Perfection V39II as a compact A4 flatbed for photos, loose documents and books that fit on the glass without being damaged.

  • Epson lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and USB power.
  • The model isn’t specifically designed for contactless scanning or scanning along a narrow book edge.

Joybuy product for A4 flatbed scanning

This Joybuy product is an A4 flatbed scanner for projects involving books and loose documents that can rest safely on the glass.

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner, 1200 × 1200 dpi, Black, White

An option for A4 books and loose documents, provided they can rest safely on the glass.

Scanning size: A4.

Scanning resolution according to the product name: 1200 × 1200 dpi.

Colour options according to the product name: Black, White.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can the school scan a whole history book and put the scan online?

Don’t assume that it can. The Dutch government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing it; a private copy for personal use cannot be distributed. Kennisnet explains that conditions apply to sharing parts of a work for educational purposes. For a complete book, check who holds the rights and what permission or arrangement covers the intended use.

Is a searchable PDF the same as a good archival scan?

No. OCR makes text searchable, but it doesn’t replace checking the page images. The National Archives of the Netherlands describes quality control as part of digitisation; Metamorfoze distinguishes between preservation master files and derivative files for use. The standards of this professional programme don’t automatically apply to a school project.

How can you get started without forcing the binding or missing information?

First check the condition of the book and make test scans of a page with text near the spine, an image and the smallest print. The National Archives of the Netherlands takes the materials and their condition into account during preparation and checks scans; use this approach as practical inspiration, not as a mandatory school standard.

What costs and follow-up work should you compare alongside the scanner?

Check that the OCR software and computer support are suitable for the school, and allow time for checking and correcting scans. The National Archives of the Netherlands states that visitors may make their own scans of public archival materials in the reading room; this option isn’t available for materials with restricted public access. This doesn’t tell you anything about the charges or rules of other archives.

What if scanned books include identifiable photos of pupils?

Consider privacy separately from copyright. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that schools need the pupil’s consent to take and publish identifiable images of pupils aged 16 or over; for younger pupils, parental consent is required. Also check how you actually plan to use the scan.