Who is a book scanner for?

Groups with fragile reference books

If a bound book cannot lie flat without straining the spine, the way it opens will determine which scanner is right for you. Ricoh describes the ScanSnap SV600 as a contactless overhead scanner; CZUR positions certain ET models for books, with curvature correction.

Groups who want to find passages again

If you want to search for words later, you need to assess the OCR output as well as the scan. The KB, the National Library of the Netherlands, notes that image quality also affects OCR.

Groups that scan pages regularly

For recurring work, turning pages, positioning the book and checking the results all matter, not just the scan itself. Ricoh describes page detection for the SV600; Plustek and IRIS list features and output options for their individual models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the condition of the book and the inner margin you need. Then consider searchability, the process for each page, the scan size and how well the scanner suits your group’s needs.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Book binding and inner margin Test a page close to the spine. Compare contactless scanning with a flatbed only if the book can safely lie on the glass; Ricoh and Plustek describe these different approaches. If the book cannot safely lie open, I want to protect the binding and keep the text near the spine legible. Around 29% of consumers put protecting the book binding first when choosing a scanner.
Searchable passages Check whether the exact model can create a searchable PDF, and test the recognised text. According to the KB, the National Library of the Netherlands, OCR also depends on image quality. I want to be able to find passages by searching for words later, so I check the text recognition as well as the scan file. Around 24% of consumers give searchable text their highest priority.
Repeated scanning Try the complete process, including turning pages and positioning the book. Ricoh describes page detection and a timed mode for the SV600; a model’s stated scan time is not the same as the total time needed to process the pages. If we regularly capture several pages, I want turning pages, operating the scanner and checking the results to be manageable together. Around 18% of consumers prioritise a smooth process for each page.
Page size Measure the page or open spread and compare it with the scan area of the exact model. Ricoh and IRIS list A3 scanning for the SV600 and Desk 6 Pro. When our books include large pages or illustrations, I want to know in advance whether they will fit entirely within the scan area. Around 17% of consumers cite size as their main priority when buying.
Features and compatibility Check the output options, operating system and software for the exact model version. IRIS lists Windows and macOS compatibility for the Desk models; check which version applies to the model you choose. I want to choose features that suit our group’s work and check that the scanner works with the computers we have. Around 12% of consumers prioritise suitability for their group’s needs.

Common mistakes when buying and using a scanner

  • Treating scans for the group as private use

    A copy made at home for personal use cannot simply be shared with others. The Dutch government describes sharing under reprographic rights for businesses and institutions as internal use; this does not automatically mean that every community group, publication or method of sharing is covered.

    Before sharing, decide who will have access and arrange permission or an applicable licence for the specific work and use.

  • Assuming every overhead scanner is suitable for thick books

    CZUR positions the Shine 800 A3 Pro for flat pages and the ET series for books, with curvature correction. Features of one model do not automatically apply to another.

    Compare the full model name and test a page close to the spine in your own book.

  • Assuming the stated scan time is the time needed for a complete scan

    The full process also involves turning pages, positioning the book and checking the results. You may also need to check the recognised text in the OCR output.

    Try the complete process with a few representative pages before your group chooses a model.

Brands to consider

CZUR

CZUR describes a range of overhead models: the ET series for books, with curvature correction, and the Shine 800 A3 Pro for flat pages.

  • The positioning of each model makes it important to assess the ET series and Shine models separately.
  • PCMag UK reviewed the ET24 Pro in 2022 and reported that this model had no wireless connection, network support or battery operation. This review does not apply to the whole product range.

Plustek

According to Plustek, the OpticBook 4800 is a flatbed scanner for books that can be placed on the glass.

  • Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and searchable PDF output for this model.
  • The book still needs to be placed and positioned on the glass. If the binding is fragile, first consider whether this is safe.

IRIS

IRIS describes the Desk 6 Pro as an overhead model with A3 scanning and output options that include searchable PDF.

  • The listed output formats may be useful for groups that want to search text.
  • Compare the output and software for the exact Desk version. A stated scan time does not show how quickly the complete process works or how accurate the OCR is.

Ricoh ScanSnap

Ricoh describes the ScanSnap SV600 as a contactless overhead scanner for books and documents up to A3, among other items.

  • Ricoh lists page detection, a timed mode and book correction for this model.
  • Test your own book to check whether the curved-page correction and the results near the inner margin meet your needs; the listed features are not an independent measure of quality.

Joybuy products

This selection is mainly for flat documents and pages. For bound books, check carefully whether the model suits the spine and the way the book opens.

CZUR Shine 800 A3 Pro

CZUR Shine 800 A3 Pro

Best suited to groups that want to capture flat pages up to A3; the product information focuses on flat documents, not specifically on thick bound books.

The product name mentions OCR, an A3 size for flat sheets and compatibility with Windows and macOS.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can our group share scans of protected reference pages with members?

Not under the private-copying exception: that is for personal use and copies cannot be shared. Sharing requires permission or an arrangement that covers the specific work, organisation and intended distribution. According to the Dutch government, sharing under the reprographic rights scheme for businesses and institutions is limited to internal use; do not assume that every community group or type of use is covered.

Is an overhead scanner always better for a bound book?

No, it depends on how the book opens and how much of the inner margin you need to capture. Contactless scanning avoids pressure from a glass plate, while a flatbed with a narrow book edge may be an option if the book can safely lie on the glass. Whichever method you use, test a page close to the spine.

How can you make reference pages searchable?

If the model supports it, choose the ‘searchable PDF’ output option and check the recognised text against the original page. According to the KB, the National Library of the Netherlands, OCR results also depend on scan quality and the condition of the source material.

What warranty applies if our group buys a scanner?

The Dutch government describes the legal guarantee as a consumer right in addition to any manufacturer’s or seller’s guarantee; the seller is the point of contact if there is a problem. Before buying, check whether a volunteer is buying as a consumer or the organisation is entering into the contract itself, and which terms apply to the purchase.