Portrait editor assessing greyscale
You assess skin tones, shadows and highlights on the main screen and want to know whether the second screen can be used mainly for tools.
For black-and-white portraits, one carefully calibrated main screen may be enough alongside a simpler second screen, as long as you make your final decisions about tone on the main screen. If you assess the portrait on both screens, calibrate and profile them separately, and compare their uniformity too. Adobe describes calibration and profiling as separate steps for consistent display.
You assess skin tones, shadows and highlights on the main screen and want to know whether the second screen can be used mainly for tools.
You display portraits or edited versions on both screens, so separate profiling and consistent display are important to you.
You want to assess your on-screen decisions in print too, so alongside a calibrated monitor you need a suitable print profile and a soft proof.
First, decide whether you’ll use both screens to assess tones. This determines how much attention you’ll need to give to calibration and consistency between the screens.
| Consideration | What to look for | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Greyscale and uniformity | Compare the uniformity and calibration features of the exact model; after setting it up, check a greyscale gradient and solid-colour areas. | If I want to assess subtle tonal transitions across the whole portrait, I focus particularly on greyscale reproduction and uniformity. Around 36% of consumers put this need first. |
| Consistency between screens | Decide where you’ll make your final assessment; check whether each screen can be calibrated and profiled separately. | When I compare versions side by side, I don’t want to mistake differences between the screens for differences in the editing. Around 29% of consumers prioritise comparing images on both screens. |
| Print checking | Check whether your software can soft-proof using the profile for the intended print. | If I want to print black-and-white portraits, I want to be able to assess the output in advance using the appropriate profile. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this print workflow. |
| Workspace and connections | Check whether your computer supports two external monitors and whether the connections, cables and any charging requirements are suitable. | For my dual-monitor setup, I want enough space for images and tools, with connections that work with my computer. Around 14% of consumers prioritise this combination. |
A black-and-white mode is a monitor feature; calibration and profiling are separate steps in colour management.
Compare the model’s calibration and uniformity features, then assess the display after setting it up.
Allow time for separate calibration and, potentially, measuring equipment.
Different settings and monitor profiles can affect a comparison, even when the image file is the same.
Decide where you’ll make your final assessment and profile each screen separately if you use both to assess tones.
In its 2023 CS2740 review, Tweakers reported that a colourimeter and monitor hood were not included.
Check what’s included with the version you choose, and if you’re printing, allow for a suitable output profile too.
Depending on the monitor you choose and what’s in the box, you may need separate measuring equipment or a monitor hood.
A monitor’s connections and charging options don’t automatically tell you what a particular computer supports through its outputs.
Compare your computer’s video outputs and support for two external monitors with the connections on the monitors.
You may need a different cable, an adapter or a separate laptop power supply.
BenQ describes the PhotoVue SW272U as a 27-inch 4K monitor with a black-and-white mode, hardware calibration and uniformity technology.
The ColorEdge CS2740 is aimed at workflows where uniformity and repeatable calibration matter. EIZO lists a 16-bit LUT, Digital Uniformity Equalizer and hardware calibration.
According to the Dutch specifications, the ProArt PA279CRV is a 27-inch 4K IPS monitor with gamma modes and an adjustable stand.
The UltraSharp U2725QE is a 27-inch 4K option with hub features and an IPS Black panel, according to Dell.
LG describes the UltraFine 27UP850K-W as a 27-inch 4K IPS monitor with USB-C and a stand adjustable for height, tilt and pivot.
These Joybuy options are 27-inch 4K monitors to consider as a main or second screen in a dual-monitor setup. Check greyscale reproduction, uniformity and calibration options separately; the stated resolution alone tells you nothing about them.
Image unavailable
Could be considered as a 4K screen for a desktop setup; the product name specifies an IPS panel.
27 inches; 4K; IPS.
Image unavailable
Could be considered as a screen for a dedicated editing setup; for assessing tones, check its display and calibration options too.
27 inches; 4K UHD; IPS; 3840 × 2160; 60 Hz.
The name specifies HDMI, DisplayPort and a height-adjustable stand.
Image unavailable
Could be considered as a 4K screen for a setup with images and other windows; check greyscale reproduction and uniformity separately.
27 inches; 3840 × 2160; 4K Ultra HD.
Image unavailable
Could be considered as a main or second screen in a dedicated setup; make sure the connections are compatible with your computer.
27 inches; 3840 × 2160; 4K Ultra HD.
Image unavailable
Could be considered as a main screen for a detailed desktop setup; the stated resolution doesn’t prove uniform greyscale reproduction.
27 inches; 3840 × 2160; 4K Ultra HD.
Not if you always make your final assessment on one main screen. If you use both to make decisions about tone, calibrate and profile each screen separately; the same model number doesn’t guarantee that two units will look identical.
First, decide which screen you’ll use for your final assessment and set up both for the intended viewing conditions. Adobe describes calibration and profiling as separate steps; create a separate profile for each screen and update it if your setup or display changes.
No. A black-and-white mode is a monitor feature; for a specific print workflow, you also need a calibrated display and a suitable output profile for soft proofing.
Check whether measuring equipment and, if applicable, a monitor hood are included with the version you choose. In its 2023 review of the EIZO ColorEdge CS2740, Tweakers reported that a colourimeter and monitor hood were not included; for soft proofing, you’ll also need the appropriate profile for the intended print.
ACM ConsuWijzer states that the cooling-off period ends 14 days after delivery. The ACM also states that there is no fixed term for the statutory guarantee.