Who is this choice relevant to?

Users sharing a scanning workstation

They want several people to be able to use the same scanner and follow a straightforward file-handling workflow. The operating system, software licence and simultaneous use all matter; Plustek Europe, LaserSoft Imaging and reflecta describe these conditions for their respective products and software.

Scanners for 35mm black-and-white film

They want to assess greyscale and detail for themselves, and need to bear in mind that infrared correction is not suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. Plustek Europe and LaserSoft Imaging describe the relevant model specifications and correction limitations.

Collectors with mixed-format negatives

They may have 120, 110 or 126 film as well as 35mm. The formats in your collection determine which scanner and holders will work; reflecta and KODAK Photo Plus list different film types supported by their respective models.

What should you look for when choosing?

First check which film formats you have, then choose between a computer-based workflow and standalone scanning. With black-and-white film, also consider how dust correction works.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Shared scanning workflow Check the operating system, connection, required software and licence terms for simultaneous use. If you share one scanner and workstation with several users, you’ll want to know in advance whether the connection and software suit the way you work. A workable shared scanning process is a priority for around 31% of consumers.
Detail and greyscale Check support for 35mm and the greyscale output you need; compare sensor resolution and output resolution separately. If you want to edit your 35mm scans further, look for adjustable settings and output options. Don’t treat a single resolution figure as proof of the detail you’ll get in the finished scan. Around 25% of consumers prioritise detail and greyscale in 35mm negatives.
Film formats and holders Compare the film types you have with the format list and holders for the exact model. If you have other negative formats as well as 35mm, you’ll want to avoid choosing a scanner that can’t handle part of your collection. For around 19% of consumers, having suitable holders for their formats is the main consideration.
Dust correction Establish whether you have traditional silver-based black-and-white film, and assess software-based correction on a sample scan. If you want to deal with dust and scratches, don’t assume infrared correction will work on traditional black-and-white film. You may also need to allow time for inspection and editing. Around 25% of consumers prioritise correction work.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming infrared correction removes dust from every black-and-white negative

    LaserSoft Imaging warns that infrared correction can cause artefacts when used with silver-based black-and-white film.

    Check which type of film you’re scanning and assess a sample without infrared correction; consider any software-based correction separately.

    Allow time to check for dust and edit your scans.

  • Confusing 22 MP output with a 22 MP image sensor

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor and interpolated 22 MP output. These are different specifications.

    Compare sensor and output figures separately, and don’t assume the output figure guarantees more detail.

  • Choosing a 35mm scanner without checking the rest of your film collection

    The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is for 35mm; the reflecta x66-Scan also lists 120 film, while KODAK Photo Plus’s European product page lists 110 and 126 negatives.

    Before buying, check the format list and holders for the exact model.

    You may need a second scanning option for unsupported formats.

  • Assuming shared use means unlimited simultaneous software use

    According to LaserSoft Imaging, SilverFast 9 can be installed on several workstations, but the licence described allows use on one computer at a time.

    Check the software licence included with the scanner against the number of workstations that need to scan at the same time.

    You may need additional software licences for simultaneous use.

Brands to compare

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is a USB film scanner for 35mm negatives and slides, designed for a computer-based workflow. Plustek lists QuickScan Plus and SilverFast SE Plus 9 for this model.

  • For the OpticFilm 8300i SE, Plustek specifies a hardware resolution of 7,200 dpi and 8- or 16-bit greyscale output.
  • This model is designed for 35mm and is not suitable for 120 film. According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared correction is not suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

reflecta describes both the standalone x66-Scan and the USB-connected RPS 10S, which has automatic film transport.

  • The x66-Scan lists JPEG storage on an SD card and support for 120, 135 and 127 black-and-white film. The RPS 10S lists automatic transport for 3 to 40 frames.
  • The x66-Scan’s stated 22 MP output is interpolated from a 14 MP sensor. The RPS 10S’s stated scan time applies to a specific colour scan and does not automatically indicate how quickly it handles black-and-white film.

KODAK Photo Plus

KODAK Photo Plus’s European product page describes the SLIDE N SCAN Max as a standalone SD option for 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives.

  • The product page lists adapters for the stated film formats and operation without a computer-based workflow.
  • An SD card is required; according to the product page, it is not included. Check the exact model and the items supplied.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can one SilverFast licence be used on different workstations?

According to LaserSoft Imaging, SilverFast 9 can be installed on several workstations, but the licence described allows use on just one computer at a time. If several workstations need to scan simultaneously, check which licence comes with the exact scanner model.

Which film formats should I check before choosing a scanner?

Check the format list and holders for the exact model. The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is for 35mm; reflecta lists 120 and 135 among the formats supported by the x66-Scan, while KODAK Photo Plus’s European page lists 135, 110 and 126 for the SLIDE N SCAN Max.

Should I switch on infrared dust removal for black-and-white negatives?

Not with traditional silver-based black-and-white film: LaserSoft Imaging warns that infrared correction can cause artefacts. Assess any software-based correction on a sample scan.

What do I need to use a standalone scanner?

It depends on the model. The reflecta x66-Scan is listed as saving JPEG files to an SD card; the European KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Max page says an SD card is required and not included. Check the card requirements and items supplied with the model you choose.

What consumer rights apply when buying a scanner in the Netherlands?

The Dutch government states that there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands; the seller remains responsible for ensuring the product is of satisfactory quality. For online consumer purchases from a business, a 14-day cooling-off period applies in many cases. Whether it applies depends on the purchase and the seller.