Scanning without a computer
You want to save black-and-white negatives directly to an SD card at home, and JPEG is an acceptable output format.
Want to scan without a computer, and happy with JPEG files? Choose a scanner that saves directly to an SD card. For greater control over scans of 35mm negatives, a film scanner with software for use on your computer is a better fit, provided it’s compatible with your computer. Whichever route you choose, check the film format and don’t expect infrared dust correction to work with traditional black-and-white film.
You want to save black-and-white negatives directly to an SD card at home, and JPEG is an acceptable output format.
You mainly have 35mm negatives and want to adjust and edit your scans on your own computer.
You have film formats other than 35mm too. Whether a scanner is suitable will depend in part on which film holders are available and compatible.
Choose this option: if you want to scan without a computer or cloud service and JPEG files are sufficient.
Bear in mind: you’ll have fewer options for fine-tuning scan settings than with a film scanner that uses computer software.
Choose this option: if you want to adjust and edit scans of 35mm negatives on a computer.
Bear in mind: you’ll need a compatible computer and extra time for scanning and editing.
Choose this option: if you want to scan other supported formats or photo prints as well as film, and can find a suitable model.
Bear in mind: Epson lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued. If you find one, check the holders and software too.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Local storage | Check whether the exact scanner model saves directly to an SD card, which output format it uses and which cards it supports. | If I want to scan without a computer and keep files locally, a standalone SD card option is important. Around 36% of consumers prioritise local scanning without a computer. |
| 35mm detail and editing | Check that the film is compatible and that the software works with your computer. Plustek OpticFilm 8100’s 7200 dpi is a product specification, not an independent measurement of the detail achieved. | If I want to assess and edit 35mm scans myself, having more control matters more than a computer-free workflow. Around 29% of consumers prioritise detail and editing for 35mm. |
| Film format and holders | Find out whether your film is 135/35mm, 110, 126, 120 or 127, and check which holder is included. According to reflecta, the x66-Scan supports 120 and 127 film, among other formats; a separate holder may be needed for some formats. | If I have several film formats, I want to know in advance whether the right holder is included with the scanner. Around 21% of consumers prioritise support for several film formats. |
| Processing time | When choosing, also allow time for removing dust, editing and organising files locally. The time taken to capture an image alone doesn’t tell you how long the whole archiving process will take. | If I want to process a large number of negatives, the work involved after scanning matters too. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a manageable processing time. |
According to SilverFast, infrared light cannot pass through the silver-based emulsion of traditional black-and-white film. So a scanner with an infrared channel won’t necessarily offer infrared dust correction for this type of film.
Don’t choose a scanner based solely on a mention of infrared correction. Keep the film and holder carefully free of dust, and check whether suitable software correction fits your workflow.
Removing dust and checking scans can take extra time.
The KODAK Slide N Scan lists a 14MP sensor and 22MP interpolation; these are not the same resolution figures. The Consumentenbond notes that basic converters and good film scanners can produce different scan results.
Compare the scanning method and editing options with what you need, rather than simply choosing the highest resolution figure.
A scanner designed for documents or books won’t necessarily have a transparency unit or suitable negative holders.
Check explicitly whether the exact model can scan transparent film and whether the right holders are available. A product listing that mentions black and white doesn’t prove that it supports black-and-white negatives.
The OpticFilm 8100 is a dedicated option for scanning 35mm negatives, with scanning software for use on a computer.
According to reflecta, the x44-Scan and x66-Scan are standalone scanners that save JPEG files directly to an SD card.
The specified Slide N Scan with a 5-inch screen is a standalone SD card option for supported 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives.
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are flatbed models with a transparency unit and film holders.
No, not with the workflows described here: standalone models can save scans to an SD card, while a film scanner connected to a computer can be used in a local workflow. Do check where your computer saves files and whether syncing is enabled.
Not with the usual silver-based black-and-white emulsion: according to SilverFast, infrared light cannot pass through it. Software correction, such as SRDx, is a different method. Carefully remove dust from the film and holder, then check the scan.
With a standalone scanner, check that you have the holder for your film format and an SD card supported by the exact model. For the OpticFilm 8100, check that the available drivers and scanning software work with your computer.
You’re entitled to a product that meets the terms of the agreement. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory two-year guarantee period for every product in the Netherlands; if a product is faulty, the seller must provide an appropriate solution.