Who are these scanning options suitable for?

Photographers who want to finish quickly after editing

Want to digitise black-and-white negatives with as little extra loading and computer work as possible, and are weighing up standalone storage against automatic strip feeding. Consumentenbond, reflecta and Kodak Photo Plus describe these workflow choices.

Photographers who want to edit their scans further

Scan selected 35mm images and prioritise scanning options and editing capabilities over a short, standalone workflow. Consumentenbond and Plustek describe this trade-off.

Photographers with several film formats

Want to check first whether their collection includes, for example, 120 film as well as 35mm, because the scanner and film holder must suit the format they use. Epson Nederland describes support for 35mm and 120/220 with the Perfection V600 Photo.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the film format and how you want to work after editing. Then compare the feeding, storage and scanning options that matter for your collection.

What to consider What to check before buying Who should prioritise this?
Fewer extra steps Check whether you can save files without a computer, which memory card is needed and whether you have to move the film holder by hand. After a long editing session, I want to digitise my negatives without lots more loading and computer work. Around 36% of consumers mainly prioritise having fewer extra steps.
Scan detail and editing Compare the scanning method, sensor or optical specifications, and the software for your computer; an interpolated output resolution is not the same as sensor detail. If I want to edit selected black-and-white images further, scanning options and a usable file matter more than a high output resolution alone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise scan detail and editing.
Lots of 35mm images Check how many frames per strip the feeding system can handle, and factor loading, checking and saving into your workflow. When I have lots of compatible 35mm images, I want to load strips less often, without expecting automatic feeding to eliminate the need to check them. Around 21% of consumers prioritise processing lots of 35mm images.
Film format and holder Check whether you have 135/35mm, 110, 126 or 120/220 film, then make sure the exact model supports that format and includes the right holders. If my collection includes another format, the scanner must support it with the right holder. Around 14% of consumers make format compatibility their first consideration.

Which scanner choices might disappoint?

  • Assuming infrared correction works for all black-and-white film

    The usual infrared method cannot be used with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that silver in the emulsion reflects infrared light.

    So don’t let an infrared feature be the deciding factor. Check how you can clean the film and what software correction is available.

  • Assuming an interpolated megapixel figure equals sensor detail

    KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP output through interpolation for the SLIDE N SCAN. Consumentenbond warns that simple sensor-based scanners generally deliver less detail than a good film scanner.

    Compare the sensor specifications and scanning method with how you plan to use the scanner; don’t judge an output figure in isolation.

  • Looking only at the scanning time per image

    Digitising your own film also takes time for loading, checking and saving. Automatic feeding can reduce the need to load each strip separately, but it doesn’t tell you how long the whole project will take.

    Assess the entire workflow based on the number of images and the condition of your film.

  • Assuming a discontinued model or an incomplete set is ready to use

    Epson Nederland states that the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued. Kodak Photo Plus says that the SLIDE N SCAN requires an SD card, which is not included.

    Check what film holders, software and storage media are included with the exact model, and make sure they’re compatible with your computer and film.

Which brands are worth considering?

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a computer-connected option for 35mm film, suited to anyone who wants to automatically feed compatible strips containing several frames.

  • reflecta specifies automatic feeding for strips containing 3 to 40 frames.
  • Automatic feeding doesn’t necessarily reduce the total scanning time; don’t expect infrared correction to work with conventional silver-based black-and-white film.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8100 is a specialist 35mm scanner for selected black-and-white negatives and a computer-based workflow.

  • Plustek specifies compatibility with silver-based black-and-white film and lists SilverFast SE Plus as included software.
  • Check that the software and scanner are compatible with your computer; software-based SRDx correction is not the same as infrared correction.

KODAK Photo Plus

The European SLIDE N SCAN, with its 5-inch screen, is a standalone option for anyone who wants to save black-and-white negatives to an SD card.

  • The product specifications list support for 135, 110 and 126 negatives, a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP output through interpolation.
  • An SD card is required but not included. Consumentenbond warns that simple sensor-based scanners generally deliver less detail than a good film scanner.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option with holders for 35mm and 120/220 film.

  • The supplied holders are designed for the film formats listed.
  • Epson Nederland states that the V600 Photo has been discontinued and is no longer available through the product page; don’t assume it’s currently available as a new product.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust correction work with my black-and-white negatives?

Not as a reliable solution for conventional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that silver in the emulsion reflects infrared light; so carefully compare cleaning the film with the software correction available, and check the features of the exact software version.

Can I start scanning without a computer?

Yes, with a standalone scanner such as the European KODAK SLIDE N SCAN with its 5-inch screen. This model requires an SD card, which isn’t included; also check that the adapter is suitable for your film format.

What should I check when buying a second-hand flatbed scanner?

Check that it includes the transparency unit, suitable film holders and usable software, and that it works with your computer. This is important for the Epson Perfection V600 Photo, which Epson Nederland lists as discontinued.

What are my rights if a scanner I bought online doesn’t work properly?

If a product you bought from a business is faulty, contact the seller. The Dutch government describes free repair or replacement as possible solutions; for distance purchases, you also have a 14-day cooling-off period in many cases. According to the Dutch government, the rules for distance purchases don’t apply when you buy online from a private individual.

Can I put an old electric scanner in my general rubbish?

Take an old electric scanner to a separate collection point. The Dutch government lists the local recycling centre and the retailer’s take-back scheme when a consumer buys a new, similar appliance; this scheme also applies to online purchases.