Which scanner setup is right for you?

Computer-connected black-and-white scanner

You want to adjust your black-and-white negatives and manage scans directly on your computer. Control over the output and your approach to dust removal are important to you.

Frequent file transfer user

You scan regularly and want to know whether files go straight to a computer or are saved to an SD card first, so the transfer process fits the way you work.

Mixed film archive manager

As well as 35mm film, you may have other negative formats. Check which formats and holders are supported by the scanner and the specific version on offer.

What should you look for when choosing?

What matters when buying What should you look for? Who is this important for?
Handling black-and-white negatives Check that the scanner supports your film format and find out how it handles dust. Infrared correction isn’t a guaranteed solution for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. If accurate processing of black-and-white film is your priority, you’ll want to know which correction methods work with your film. Around 31% of consumers put the handling of black-and-white negatives first.
Frequent file transfers Check whether scans go straight to a computer or are saved to an SD card first. Also check the file format and which card you’ll need. If you transfer scans regularly, you’ll want the storage route to suit your computer or card-based workflow. Around 31% of consumers give file transfer top priority.
Speed when scanning repeatedly Find out whether the film is fed through manually or transported automatically. A stated scan time isn’t the same as the total time needed for preparation and file transfer. For recurring batches of scans, remember to factor in the time needed to load and save them. Around 23% of consumers prioritise speed when scanning repeatedly.
Film formats and holders Compare the formats in your archive with the specifications, and check which holders come with the version on offer. If you have different negative formats, you’ll want the scanner and available holders to support them. Around 15% of consumers give format support top priority.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Assuming infrared means guaranteed dust correction

    Infrared correction isn’t necessarily suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that silver-based black-and-white emulsion reflects infrared light, making the iSRD method unsuitable.

    Consider the dust-removal process for the type of film you actually scan, rather than focusing only on whether the scanner has an infrared function.

    Allow extra time for careful cleaning and retouching.

  • Mistaking an interpolated figure for sensor resolution

    The reflecta x66-Scan and KODAK SLIDE N SCAN are both listed with 22 MP interpolation alongside a 14MP sensor. These figures therefore describe different things.

    Compare the sensor and output specifications separately, and don’t base your choice on the highest MP figure alone.

  • Confusing a short scan time with a fast end-to-end workflow

    Manual loading, adjusting settings, cleaning and saving files all take time too. reflecta lists automatic film transport for the RPS 10S, but that alone doesn’t tell you how long your complete scanning and transfer process will take.

    For your own use, factor in preparation, feeding, transfer and file management.

  • Treating a discontinued flatbed model as a standard new product

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you’re buying a clearance or second-hand unit, its condition and completeness matter.

    Before deciding, check which film holders are included, software compatibility and the details of the specific unit.

Relevant brands for black-and-white negative scanners

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE offers a computer-connected option for 35mm film, with greyscale output.

  • According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8200i SE has USB 2.0 Type B, a hardware resolution of 7200 dpi and 8- or 16-bit greyscale output. The listed SilverFast bundle and computer requirements apply to this model.
  • The infrared function isn’t a guaranteed dust-correction solution for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The standalone x66-Scan and computer-connected RPS 10S cater for different 35mm scanning workflows.

  • According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card and supports 35mm film and the specified medium formats. The RPS 10S has automatic film transport for strips of 3 to 40 frames.
  • For the x66-Scan, 22 MP is interpolated alongside a 14MP sensor. Infrared retouching isn’t a guaranteed solution for traditional black-and-white film.

KODAK Photo Plus

The specified SLIDE N SCAN is a standalone option for black-and-white negatives in the listed formats, among others.

  • The product information lists black-and-white negatives in 135, 110 and 126 formats, SD storage up to 32 GB and USB 2.0.
  • The listed 22 MP is interpolated from a 14MP sensor. Check that the version on offer and the included adapters match the specifications.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner with film holders for several formats, but Epson Netherlands lists the model as discontinued.

  • Epson Netherlands lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF output.
  • According to Epson Netherlands, the model is no longer available from Epson. If you’re considering a clearance or second-hand unit, check the holders and software compatibility.

Products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust correction work with traditional black-and-white film?

Don’t assume that it does. LaserSoft Imaging explains that silver-based black-and-white emulsion reflects infrared light, which means the iSRD infrared method isn’t suitable. For your workflow, consider careful cleaning and suitable software-based or manual retouching.

Does the computer need to be connected while scanning?

That depends on the type of scanner. According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card without a computer; the Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE is specified with a USB computer interface and computer requirements.

Which film formats and holders should I check?

First, compare your film formats with the specifications, then check which holders come with the version on offer. The models listed vary: the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN specifies 135, 110 and 126 formats, while other models listed also specify support for 35mm and certain medium formats or 120/220 film.

Is a short scan time enough to choose a fast workflow?

No. The scan time per frame doesn’t tell you how long your whole workflow will take. Also allow for preparation, any manual feeding, cleaning, file transfer and organisation. Automatic transport is only relevant for the film formats and strips supported by the scanner.