Image archive managers
They want to preserve black-and-white negatives as files that can still be edited later. The National Archives lists TIFF/TIF among its preferred formats.
Start by taking stock of the film formats you have, then decide whether the group needs editable archival scans or images that are quick to share. A dedicated 35mm film scanner is a good fit for individual 35mm frames. If you have several formats, a suitable film flatbed or multi-format scanner makes more sense, while automatic feeding can help with large numbers of compatible film strips. According to SilverFast, infrared correction is not a solution for dust on conventional silver-based black-and-white film.
They want to preserve black-and-white negatives as files that can still be edited later. The National Archives lists TIFF/TIF among its preferred formats.
They need to check that both the scanner and the supplied holders are suitable for all the negative formats the group wants to scan.
They want to spend less time feeding film in by hand. reflecta specifies automatic transport for strips of 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Archival file and detail | Check the actual output format and distinguish sensor resolution from interpolated megapixels. reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor, 22 MP interpolated resolution and direct JPEG saving for the x66-Scan. | If the group wants to edit scans again later, a useful output format matters more than simply creating a quick selection of JPEGs. Around 26% of consumers prioritise editable archival scans. |
| Film formats and holders | List the formats in your collection and check that the scanner and supplied holders support them. Epson lists 35mm and 120/220 film for the V600; reflecta lists 120, 135 and 127 for the x66-Scan. | If the collection includes different formats, you don’t want to find out that some of them won’t fit in the holder. Around 21% of consumers prioritise support for multiple formats. |
| Feed mechanism and volunteer time | Check whether the scanner transports film automatically and which strips it can handle. reflecta specifies transport for 3 to 40 35mm frames on the RPS 10S. | When there are lots of strips and limited time, you’ll want to reduce the amount of manual feeding without skipping checks for missing or incorrectly processed frames. Around 21% of consumers prioritise automatic feeding. |
| Dust and scratch correction | Find out what type of black-and-white film the group has and check separately which software correction features are included. SilverFast describes SRDx as software-based correction that can also be used on black-and-white images. | If the negatives are dusty, you’ll want to know in advance how much cleaning or post-processing will still be needed. Around 16% of consumers prioritise reducing the amount of correction work. |
| Shared use | Check whether the workflow requires a computer and compatible software, or whether the scanner works independently. Also check whether the necessary storage media are included. | When volunteers take turns, you’ll want a workflow that everyone can follow and clear information about what’s needed. Around 16% of consumers prioritise ease of shared use. |
With conventional silver-based black-and-white film, the usual infrared correction does not work as it does with standard colour negatives; according to SilverFast, the silver-based emulsion reflects infrared light.
Check what type of film the group has, and separately review the software correction features and cleaning steps involved with the scanner.
Scanning film requires a suitable film holder and a transparency unit. A flatbed document scanner is therefore not automatically suitable for transparent film.
Look for explicit mention of film scanning support, compatible formats and the required holder or transparency unit in the product specifications.
For the reflecta x66-Scan, the stated 14 MP sensor resolution and 22 MP interpolated resolution are different specifications. According to reflecta, the scanner saves directly to JPEG.
First decide which files the group wants to keep, then check the sensor specification and output formats separately. If the available format turns out not to be suitable later, you may need to scan again.
Epson UK states that the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued. For a specific second-hand unit or remaining stock, the supplied holders, software and computer compatibility could be decisive.
Check everything included and test that the software works with the computer the group plans to use.
Plustek specifically recommends the OpticFilm 8100, a 35mm model, for silver-based black-and-white negatives.
The x66-Scan and RPS 10S offer different approaches: standalone scanning across several film formats, or automatic transport for compatible 35mm strips.
The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a film flatbed scanner with holders for 35mm and 120/220 film.
The European product page for the Slide N SCAN Max lists black-and-white negatives on 135, 110 and 126 film for a standalone scanning workflow.
Not for that feature alone if you’re scanning conventional silver-based black-and-white film. According to SilverFast, the emulsion reflects infrared light, so the usual infrared method does not work in the same way. Check which software correction features are included with the specific product.
Choose a dedicated 35mm scanner if the collection is mainly made up of 35mm film; choose a multi-format or film flatbed scanner if the group also wants to scan other formats. Always check both the stated scanning formats and the holders supplied with the specific unit.
Agree in advance how to load the film, name the files and check for missing or incorrectly processed frames. The National Archives describes quality control as part of a digitisation process; this is a practical example, not a legal requirement for a group.
Check the film holders, storage media, software and compatibility with the group’s computer. The European product page for the KODAK Slide N SCAN Max states that an SD card is required but not included; Epson UK states that the V600 Photo has been discontinued.
Scanning does not, in itself, give you permission to publish copyright-protected work. The Dutch Government explains that protected photos belonging to others cannot simply be shared or made public. If people are recognisable in the images, the Dutch Data Protection Authority also points out that images may contain personal data and that an organisation needs a lawful basis under the GDPR for processing them. Consider both issues in relation to the specific collection.