First, check the size of your negatives and the file format or image quality your school project requires. If you’re mainly scanning 35mm film and want to adjust your scans on a computer, a dedicated scanner may be a good fit. A standalone scanner is more convenient if you want to save JPEG files straight to an SD card. For traditional silver-based black-and-white film, infrared dust correction isn’t a deciding factor when choosing a scanner.
Which approach is right for you?
Student with 35mm black-and-white film
You want to digitise negatives for a presentation or print, and need to choose between scans you can adjust on a computer and a standalone JPEG workflow. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8100 as suitable for 35mm black-and-white film, while reflecta says the x33-Scan saves scans to an SD card.
Student with different film formats
You may also have 120, 110 or 126 film, so check that the scanner supports the format and comes with the right holder. Epson says the V600 supports 120/220 film, while reflecta offers a separate adapter set for 110/126 for the x33-Scan.
Student with a one-off scanning assignment
You want to decide whether borrowing, hiring or paying for a scanning service is more practical than setting up your own scanning workflow. The Consumers’ Association discusses the choice in relation to the number of images, the quality you want and the time available.
What should you look for when choosing?
For a school project, your choice mainly depends on the image quality you need, the film format, how much time you have to scan and the size of the assignment.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who should consider this? |
| Detail and tone |
Compare the optical or sensor specifications with the result you need, and check the tone settings. An interpolated output figure doesn’t mean the sensor captures more detail. |
If you’re preparing a presentation or print and want to assess detail in the shadows, make tone and detail your priorities; these account for about 33% of consumers with this project need. |
| Film format and holder |
Check the format on the film or packaging, and make sure the right holder for the exact model is included. |
If you have different formats, you’ll want to avoid finding that a negative won’t fit in the scanner or holder; consumers who prioritise format compatibility account for about 27% of consumers with this project need. |
| Time and workflow |
Check whether the scanner saves directly to an SD card or needs a computer, and which file type your assignment requires. |
If you have little time to set up a scanning workflow, a straightforward option may suit you best; consumers who prioritise convenience and speed account for about 20% of consumers with this project need. |
| One-off assignment |
Count how many images you need and consider whether borrowing, hiring or paying for a scanning service is practical. If you use a scanning service, agree in advance which file you’ll receive. |
If you only need a limited number of images for one assignment, you may not want to set up your own scanning workflow unnecessarily; consumers who see this as their main consideration account for about 20% of consumers with this project need. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming an interpolated megapixel figure means more detail
KODAK lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP output through interpolation for the KODAK Slide N SCAN. That output figure alone doesn’t mean the scanner has captured extra detail from the sensor.
Compare the sensor or optical specifications with the output your school needs and, if possible, look at a sample scan.
-
Choosing infrared dust correction for traditional black-and-white film
According to LaserSoft Imaging, the iSRD infrared method doesn’t work with conventional silver-based black-and-white emulsion. An infrared channel is therefore not a decisive advantage if you’re scanning only this film type.
Carefully remove dust from the film and assess any software or manual correction separately. Look for infrared features if you also plan to scan other types of film.
-
Assuming every holder or power adapter is included in the box
The holders supplied vary by model and version. The adapter set for 110/126 film is sold separately for the reflecta x33-Scan; the power adapter isn’t listed in the box contents for the KODAK Slide N SCAN version reviewed.
Before buying, check the exact model version, the film formats it supports and the full contents of the box.
-
Assuming a discontinued flatbed model is available to buy new
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you borrow or buy one second-hand, check the film holders, transparency unit and software carefully.
Check that all the parts you need are included and test that the scanner works with your computer and scanning software before use.
Brands to consider
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8100 is a dedicated option for 35mm film, with scans adjusted on a computer.
- Plustek specifies support for 35mm black-and-white film, 7200 dpi and included SilverFast software.
- Plustek doesn’t list a built-in infrared channel. Also check that the software is compatible with your computer; infrared dust correction isn’t a decisive feature for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.
reflecta
The x22-Scan and x33-Scan offer a standalone way to scan 35mm film and save JPEG files to an SD card.
- reflecta says 35mm holders are included with the x33-Scan.
- The adapter set for 110/126 film is sold separately. Check that the holders you need are included with the exact version you’re considering.
KODAK Photo Plus
The Slide N SCAN is a standalone option for the film formats listed for the relevant version.
- KODAK lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film, as well as a 14MP sensor.
- The stated 22 MP output is interpolated. This specification isn’t an independent quality test; also check what’s included in the box, including the power adapter.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo shows when a flatbed scanner could be useful for both film and prints.
- Epson Netherlands lists support for 35mm and 120/220 film.
- Epson Netherlands marks the V600 as discontinued. It isn’t a confirmed new purchase option; if you borrow or buy one second-hand, check the holders and software.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
How do I scan a black-and-white negative on a flatbed scanner?
Use a suitable film holder and the scanner’s transparency unit. A scanning guide from the University of Illinois School of Art & Design recommends 8- or 16-bit greyscale for black-and-white film. Also follow the instructions for your specific model and remove dust from the film first.
Does infrared correction remove dust from traditional black-and-white film?
Not with the usual silver-based black-and-white emulsion: software maker LaserSoft Imaging says this emulsion reflects infrared light, which means the iSRD method doesn’t work. Clean the film carefully and assess other correction methods separately.
What can I do if my scanner turns out to be faulty?
In the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that meets reasonable expectations; the Dutch government says there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period that applies to every product. Contact the seller if there’s a fault. For online purchases from a business, you’re also usually entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period; this is separate from your rights if the product is faulty.
Can I publish scans of other people’s photos in my school project?
Scanning a photo for your own use isn’t the same as making it publicly available. The Dutch government makes this distinction for copyright-protected photos, so check what rights or permissions apply before sharing images. If the school publishes an identifiable photo of a pupil aged 16 or over, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says the pupil must give permission themselves.