Which scanner option is right for you?

Collectors with lots of 35mm strips

If your collection is growing, strip transport and batch feeding can reduce the number of steps involved. Plustek and reflecta describe automatic feeding for their respective 35mm models.

Photographers who want to assess detail carefully

If you mainly want to adjust and edit selected black-and-white images, give scan settings and output more weight than speed alone. The Dutch Consumers’ Association identifies image quality and the time you want to spend digitising as factors to consider.

Collectors with different film formats

If you have 120 film as well as 35mm, for example, check the support and compatible holders for each format. Epson lists several formats for the Perfection V850 Pro; reflecta specifies multi-format support for the x66-Scan.

What should you look for in a negative scanner?

First, work out how much film you want to process, how much control you need over individual scans and whether your collection includes more than one format.

35mm scanner with automatic strip feeding

Best for: you have lots of compatible 35mm strips and want to spend less time feeding them by hand. Plustek specifies six frames per strip for the OpticFilm 135i; reflecta describes transport of three to forty frames for the RPS 10S.

Bear in mind: these figures come from the manufacturers and aren’t a measure of total processing time. Check that your strips are in a suitable condition and the right length for the transport system.

Film scanner for selected images

Best for: you want to adjust and edit a selection carefully, rather than simply feed through lots of strips. The Dutch Consumers’ Association describes film scanning as a quality-focused option.

Bear in mind: feeding, cleaning, correcting and organising your files all take time. Check which settings and software come with the model you choose.

Flatbed scanner with a transparency unit

Best for: you also want to scan 120 film or larger originals, and the right holders are available. Epson lists formats including 35mm, 120/220 and 5 × 4 inch for the Perfection V850 Pro.

Bear in mind: Epson Netherlands lists the V850 Pro as discontinued. Epson also says that Digital ICE cannot be used with black-and-white film on this model.

Standalone scanner with SD storage

Best for: you want to view or save images quickly without a computer. reflecta describes JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan.

Bear in mind: reflecta specifies a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP output through interpolation. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that basic sensor-led scanners generally capture less detail than good film scanners.

Have your scans done for you

Best for: you have a large backlog or would rather not spend time cleaning, correcting and managing files yourself.

Bear in mind: you’ll have less direct control over each scan. Ask in advance about resolution, file format and which corrections are included. The Dutch Consumers’ Association lists outsourcing as an option for large collections.

What to consider What to look for Who will care most?
Processing lots of film Check the number of frames per strip, the supported strip length and whether your film is suitable for the transport system. If I have long 35mm strips, I want to feed them by hand less often. Around 33% of consumers prioritise throughput over other purchasing needs.
Detail and editing flexibility Compare scan settings, output format and included software. Check whether a resolution figure refers to sensor resolution or interpolation. I want to adjust and edit important images carefully, even if it takes more time. Around 27% of consumers prioritise control over detail.
More film formats List your formats, such as 135 and 120, and check that the right holder and supported image area are available for each one. With a collection in several formats, I don’t want to discover that my scanner can only handle some of them. Around 20% of consumers choose mainly on the range of supported formats.
Dust and scratches Check which film process you have and what non-infrared cleaning or software options are available. If dust correction is my main concern, I want to know in advance how to clean or restore conventional black-and-white film. Around 13% of consumers prioritise dust removal.
Quick image review Check whether an SD card is required and included, which file format is saved and how the megapixel figures are specified. I want to view images easily without using a computer to scan them. Around 7% of consumers prioritise simple previews.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming infrared will automatically repair black-and-white film

    With conventional silver-based black-and-white film, infrared dust detection doesn’t work as it does with films that are compatible with this type of correction. Epson also excludes black-and-white film from Digital ICE on the V850 Pro.

    Consider dust removal separately from scanner resolution, and check which software-based approach is suitable for your film process.

    Allow for extra manual cleaning and restoration if infrared correction isn’t suitable.

  • Mistaking interpolated megapixels for sensor detail

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, reflecta specifies a 14 MP sensor and native output, with interpolated output of 22 MP. The higher figure doesn’t mean the sensor captures that extra detail.

    Compare the stated sensor resolution with the output and settings you need for your scans.

  • Assuming a discontinued flatbed model is readily available new

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V850 Pro as discontinued, although product information is still available.

    If you’re considering remaining stock or a second-hand model, check the exact version, included film holders, condition and software compatibility.

  • Focusing only on the device and forgetting the work involved with each image

    Scanning your own film also involves feeding, cleaning, correcting and organising files. The Dutch Consumers’ Association includes the time required as part of the decision.

    Test the process with representative strips and assess the entire workflow and the final file you want before choosing an option.

Brands worth comparing

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is a 35mm option for anyone who values batch strip feeding.

  • Plustek specifies a batch capacity of six frames per strip for the OpticFilm 135i.
  • This is a manufacturer specification, not an independent measure of total processing time. Don’t expect correction via the infrared channel with conventional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is designed to transport 35mm strips, while the x66-Scan offers a standalone option for several film formats.

  • reflecta specifies automatic transport of three to forty frames for the RPS 10S. For the x66-Scan, reflecta lists features including JPEG storage on an SD card and support for different film formats.
  • According to reflecta, the x66-Scan has a 14 MP sensor; its specified 22 MP output is interpolated. These are model specifications, not an independent comparison of image quality.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro is an example of a flatbed scanner for various film formats and larger originals.

  • Epson lists support for formats including 35mm, 120/220 and 5 × 4 inch.
  • Epson Netherlands lists this model as discontinued. Epson says that Digital ICE cannot be used with black-and-white film on the V850 Pro.

KODAK Photo Plus

The EU version of the SLIDE N SCAN Max RODFS70 is a standalone option for formats including 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives.

  • The European product page describes direct storage on an SD card and simple film feeding.
  • The manufacturer says an SD card is required but not included. Also check the exact model version: other SLIDE N SCAN models aren’t automatically the same product.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust removal work on black-and-white negatives?

Not with conventional silver-based black-and-white film: the emulsion prevents the infrared detection on which this method relies. LaserSoft Imaging describes SRDx as a software-based alternative. Check which film process you have and what software is available for your scanner.

How many frames can automatic film scanners feed at a time?

It varies by model and strip. Plustek specifies six frames per strip for the OpticFilm 135i; reflecta lists automatic transport of three to forty frames for the RPS 10S. Check that your strips are suitable in terms of length and condition.

Can one scanner handle both 35mm and 120 film?

Some models are designed for multiple formats, but check the support and compatible holder for each one. reflecta describes the x66-Scan as supporting formats including 35mm and 120; Epson lists 120/220 support for the Perfection V850 Pro, which Epson Netherlands lists as discontinued.

What do I need for a standalone scanner?

Check which film holders and storage media you’ll need. For the European KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Max RODFS70, the manufacturer states that an SD card is required and isn’t included.

What should I check when buying a second-hand Epson Perfection V850 Pro?

Check the exact version, condition, film holders and software compatibility; Epson Netherlands lists the V850 Pro as discontinued. Also bear in mind that Epson says Digital ICE isn’t suitable for black-and-white film on this model.