Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a mixed film collection

First, work out which film formats and holders you need. A scanner that supports 35mm only is not suitable for 120 film. Plustek and reflecta list format support for each model.

Volunteer responsible for archive files

Decide in advance which scan files will be kept, how they will be checked and how they will be linked to the originals. The National Archives describes organisation and accessibility as part of digital archiving.

Coordinator of lots of 35mm film strips

Compare the steps involved in feeding, checking and cleaning, not just the stated scan time. reflecta specifies that the RPS 10S can automatically feed strips with up to 40 frames.

What should you look for?

First, decide which originals the scanner needs to handle and which files the archive wants to keep. Then compare the available feeding options and the amount of manual work involved in your chosen workflow.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Film format and holder Check which formats are supported and which holders are supplied with the exact model. If you manage a mixed collection, you’ll want to know which originals will actually fit in the scanner. Around 36% of consumers give format compatibility top priority.
Files for preservation Check whether the scanner supports your preferred file output and how files can be checked and organised. For archive work, you’ll want to be able to manage files later and link them to the originals, rather than simply save a viewing copy quickly. Around 29% of consumers prioritise archive-ready output.
Processing film strips See how many manual steps are involved for each strip and whether automatic feeding is suitable for your film format. If you have lots of compatible 35mm strips, you’ll want a workflow that volunteers can keep up with, including checking the scans afterwards. Around 21% of consumers care most about feeding.
Dust correction and editing Test correction on your own film and check that fine detail is preserved. If you want to deal with dust and visible defects, the correction method needs to work with traditional black-and-white film and allow you to check the results. Around 14% of consumers prioritise black-and-white editing.

Common pitfalls

  • Choosing a 35mm scanner before taking stock of the collection

    Support for 35mm does not mean a scanner can also handle 120 film. As a result, some of your collection may not fit into the workflow you choose.

    Take stock of the film formats and check the holders for the exact model before making your choice.

  • Assuming infrared correction will remove all dust from black-and-white film

    LaserSoft Imaging explains that infrared light cannot pass through the silver-based emulsion of traditional black-and-white film. So this feature is not necessarily the answer to dust correction for this material.

    Make a test scan and check that software correction does not remove detail.

  • Treating a JPEG viewing copy as a complete archiving workflow

    According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. Without agreed rules for file names, checking and linking files to originals, you may have extra organising to do later.

    Decide in advance which files will be kept and how volunteers will link scans to the originals. The National Archives describes organisation as part of digital archiving.

  • Assessing a discontinued model as if it were readily available new

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V850 Pro as discontinued. A product page with specifications does not, on its own, tell you whether a specific unit is available.

    If you’re considering a particular unit, check which holders and software are included and whether the software works with the computer you use.

Relevant brands to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8100 is a computer-connected option for supported 35mm film.

  • Plustek lists support for 35mm black-and-white negatives, film holders and SilverFast SE Plus.
  • This model does not support larger film formats. The manufacturer’s specifications are not an independent measure of the detail achieved.

reflecta

The RPS 10S and x66-Scan offer different workflows for 35mm strips and supported film formats.

  • reflecta specifies that the RPS 10S can automatically process strips with up to 40 frames and output DNG files.
  • According to reflecta, the x66-Scan also supports certain 120 and 127 formats.
  • The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. Its stated 22 MP output is interpolated; reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro is an example of a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for various transparency formats.

  • Epson lists film holders for 35mm, 120 film and larger transparencies, as well as TIFF output.
  • Epson Netherlands marks this model as discontinued. If you’re considering a specific unit, check which holders and software are included and what support is available.

Kodak Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan is a standalone option for the film formats listed on its EU product page.

  • The EU product page lists support for black-and-white film in 135, 110 and 126 formats, with an SD card-based workflow.
  • 120 film is not among the listed formats. The product page says an SD card is required but not included.

Products at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Should I take the stated dpi as a guarantee of scan quality?

No. A stated or interpolated output resolution is not the same as independently measured detail. For the x66-Scan, reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated output of 22 MP. So start with the film format and the files you need, then assess a test run of the complete workflow.

Can infrared correction automatically remove dust from traditional black-and-white negatives?

Don’t rely on it for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that infrared light cannot pass through this emulsion; the manufacturer describes SRDx as a separate software-based method for black-and-white film. Check any corrections visually.

What should we agree on for volunteers’ use and care of the scanner?

Start with a small inventory and a test batch. Set out how scans will be linked to originals, how settings and files will be checked, and how scans will be organised. Handle dusty or damaged originals with care before placing them in a holder.

What tasks should the archive compare in addition to choosing a scanner?

Compare the time needed for feeding, cleaning, checking and editing, as well as the holders, storage and software required. The Consumers’ Association points out that digitising material yourself takes time. For a discontinued or second-hand model, also check computer compatibility and support.

Can we publish scans featuring identifiable people online without further checks?

No. Publication requires an appropriate assessment of privacy and rights. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in photographs to be personal data; according to the DPA, consent is required in many cases for online publication. Also check the copyright and any image rights for each photograph: owning a negative does not prove that you have the right to publish it.