Which scanner suits which user?

Scanning at different workspaces

You want to digitise black-and-white negatives without having to launch scanner software on a laptop every time. The power supply and SD card storage both affect how easy the setup is to move. KODAK Photo Plus and reflecta describe these features for their respective models.

Fine-tuning 35mm scans

You work with 35mm film and want to control the scan and greyscale output using computer software, and are happy to use a separate power adapter. Plustek specifies these output options for the OpticFilm 8200i SE.

A collection with several film formats

You have other negative formats as well as 35mm film, and want to check which holders are compatible with your chosen model before buying. KODAK Photo Plus, reflecta and Epson Netherlands describe the format support available for their individual models.

What to look for when choosing

What to consider What to check Best for
Scanning on the move Check the power source, included adapter, required memory card and how to transfer files. If I scan in different places, I don’t want to depend on a connected laptop. Around 36% of consumers say standalone scanning and file storage are their main requirements.
Scan settings Check the greyscale output and whether the software works with your operating system. Don’t expect infrared dust correction to work with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. If you want to adjust scans of 35mm film using computer software, you may prefer greater control over standalone JPEG capture. Around 29% of consumers prioritise this level of control.
Film formats List the formats you have, such as 135, 110, 126, 120 or 127, and check which holders are included with the model. If I have other negative formats as well as 35mm, I don’t want to find out later that the holder is missing or won’t fit. Around 21% of consumers say support for several film formats is their main requirement.
Printed photographs Check whether the model can scan printed photographs, which sizes it supports and whether it is still available. If I also want to digitise printed photographs, I’m looking for one device that can handle both types of media. Around 14% of consumers say this is their main buying requirement.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming infrared removes dust from all black-and-white film

    With conventional black-and-white film that has a silver-based emulsion, the usual infrared correction does not work as it does with film that supports this feature. According to LaserSoft Imaging, iSRD cannot be used with this emulsion.

    Don’t base your choice solely on terms such as Digital ICE or iSRD. Clean the film carefully and treat any software-based retouching as a separate feature.

    Allow extra time to clean the film and carry out any post-processing.

  • Comparing an interpolated megapixel figure with the sensor resolution

    For the KODAK Slide N Scan 5-inch and reflecta x66-Scan models examined, 22 MP is an interpolated output setting; both manufacturers specify a 14MP sensor.

    Compare sensor and output specifications separately, and consider the film format and file type too.

  • Assuming a small scanner is powered entirely through USB

    The Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE needs a separate 15 V power supply in addition to USB. Standalone models have their own power and storage requirements.

    Before buying, check everything you’ll need, including the power source, any adapter and a memory card.

  • Assuming a discontinued flatbed model is still generally available

    Epson Netherlands says that the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued and is no longer available from Epson.

    Use the V600 as an example of a flatbed scanning setup, but check the availability and condition of the device if you find a specific listing.

Brands to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm range is designed for scanning film with a computer; the 8200i SE is aimed at 35mm film.

  • For the 8200i SE, Plustek specifies 8- or 16-bit greyscale output, USB 2.0 and included SilverFast software.
  • The model also requires a separate 15V power supply. Its infrared channel does not remove dust from conventional silver-based black-and-white film.

KODAK

The standalone Slide N Scan 5-inch is designed to digitise negatives in formats including 135, 110 and 126.

  • According to KODAK Photo Plus, this model supports black-and-white film, SD storage and power from sources including a power bank.
  • The model creates JPEG files. Its stated 22 MP is interpolated from a 14MP sensor; check separately which accessories you’ll need.

reflecta

The standalone x66-Scan is designed for collections that include 35mm and medium-format film.

  • reflecta states that the scanner supports black-and-white film in formats 120, 135 and 127, with JPEG storage on SD.
  • The 22MP setting is interpolated from a 14MP sensor. Check which film holders fit the format you want to scan.

Rollei

The PDF-S 240 SE combines scanning negatives and printed photographs in one standalone device.

  • Rollei states that it supports SD, SDHC and MMC cards, as well as printed photographs up to 13 × 18 cm.
  • The manufacturer quotes 1800 dpi, interpolated to 2400 dpi. The different megapixel figures are not a reliable basis for comparing the sensor with other models.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner with holders for film and printed photographs.

  • Epson Netherlands lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, USB and mains power.
  • Epson Netherlands says that the V600 Photo has been discontinued and is no longer available from Epson; the device weighs 4 kg.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I automatically scan conventional black-and-white negatives free of dust using infrared?

Not with the usual iSRD infrared feature: according to software maker LaserSoft Imaging, the silver-based black-and-white emulsion prevents it from being used. Clean the film carefully and assess software correction separately; SRDx is different from infrared scanning.

Does my laptop need to stay connected while I’m scanning?

It depends on the model. The Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE works with computer software and also has a separate power supply; the KODAK Slide N Scan 5-inch and reflecta x66-Scan models examined can save scans to an SD card without a computer.

What should I have ready before my first scan?

Check the film holder and power supply for your model. For the KODAK Slide N Scan 5-inch, the manufacturer specifies an SD card of up to 32 GB, which is not included; reflecta lists SD storage and an included adapter for the x66-Scan. If you’re using a laptop scanner, also check that the software works with your computer.

What are my rights if an item bought online in the Netherlands isn’t suitable?

When you buy online from a business, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period, subject to applicable conditions and exceptions, as explained by the Rijksoverheid. You also have statutory rights if a product is faulty: in the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period, and the retailer is your point of contact. An additional guarantee does not replace those rights.