Photographers with clients’ 35mm negatives
You want to check tonal values, dust and files yourself before delivery. A computer-connected film scanner suits this workflow; Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a scanner for 35mm film.
If you only scan 35mm black-and-white film and want control over the final file, a computer-connected film scanner is a good fit; check that its software works with your system first. For 120 film, you’ll need a scanner and holder that support your format. A standalone scanner can quickly create JPEG files, but infrared correction won’t remove dust from conventional black-and-white film in the same way it can from some colour films. So allow time for checking and correction, as SilverFast also explains.
You want to check tonal values, dust and files yourself before delivery. A computer-connected film scanner suits this workflow; Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a scanner for 35mm film.
You want to avoid finding that a scanner or holder doesn’t fit the negatives you have. Compare the supported formats and image dimensions of models such as the Plustek OpticFilm 120 Pro and reflecta x66-Scan.
You’re weighing up the time needed for scanning and editing against a quick JPEG selection or outsourcing. The Consumentenbond lists the amount of material, the quality required and the time available as relevant factors.
Start with the film format and the final file you need. Then work out how much time you can spend on scanning, checking for dust and editing.
Choose this if: you only scan 35mm black-and-white film and want to review or edit the files on your computer afterwards.
Bear in mind: the OpticFilm 8200i SE isn’t suitable for 120 film. Also check that the software is currently compatible with your system.
Choose this if: you scan supported 120/220 negatives as well as 35mm and want greyscale output for further editing.
Bear in mind: Plustek lists 8- and 16-bit greyscale output for the OpticFilm 120 Pro. Check that the film holder supports your exact image format.
Choose this if: you don’t want to use a computer while scanning and JPEG files suit your workflow.
Bear in mind: format support varies by model. The reflecta x66-Scan and KODAK Slide N Scan don’t support the same film types, so check before buying.
Choose this if: you want to scan film and other originals, and already have a suitable model in working order.
Bear in mind: Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued. Don’t treat their old specifications as proof that they’re currently available new.
Choose this if: you have little time for scanning and correction, or the amount of material makes processing it yourself impractical.
Bear in mind: agree in advance on the resolution, file formats and corrections included in the service.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Image control and final file | Ask which file the client needs and compare the output options. Make a test scan and check for dust separately. | If I want to check tonal values and the final file myself, I choose an output that suits my editing workflow. Around 31% of consumers put this control first. |
| Film format support | Check the film type and image dimensions, and whether the right holder is included. | When a job involves different formats, I want to be sure that both the scanner and holder can handle them. Around 25% of consumers put format compatibility at the top of their list. |
| Time to delivery | Allow time for a test run that includes scanning, checking for dust and checking the files. A quick capture isn’t the same as a finished file. | If the deadline is close, I weigh up the full processing time against a JPEG workflow or outsourcing. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the delivery deadline. |
| Overall effort | Check the software, holders and storage you’ll need. Compare the hours you’ll spend doing it yourself with what a scanning service provides. | If I want to limit the time and equipment involved, I look beyond the scanner itself. Around 19% of consumers prioritise the overall effort and cost. |
The usual infrared method doesn’t work on conventional silver-based black-and-white film as it does on colour film. SilverFast explains that the emulsion makes this film unsuitable for infrared-channel correction.
Plan a test scan and assess how you’ll check for and correct dust and other visible defects.
Cleaning, checking and retouching may add to the processing time.
For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer lists a 14-megapixel sensor and, separately, an interpolated output of 22 megapixels. These are different specifications.
Compare sensor and output figures separately, and assess a test file for the client’s intended use.
Epson Netherlands lists both the Perfection V600 Photo and the V850 Pro as discontinued; their specifications don’t confirm that they’re currently available new.
If you’re considering a used or existing model, check the film holders, the condition of the scanner and whether the software works on your computer.
A quick JPEG capture doesn’t automatically mean the file is right for the client’s needs or show how much dust correction is still required.
Agree on the file you need, check which memory card is required and open a test scan before processing the whole job.
The EU retailer states that the KODAK Slide N Scan requires an SD card, which isn’t included.
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35mm film, while the OpticFilm 120 Pro also supports specified 120/220 formats.
The x66-Scan is a standalone JPEG digitiser for black-and-white film, including 120, 135 and 127 formats.
The described Slide N Scan, with its 5-inch screen, independently digitises 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives.
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are flatbed models with film holders, suited to anyone who also wants to scan other originals.
Not on conventional silver-based black-and-white film. According to SilverFast, the emulsion prevents the usual dust detection method from working via the infrared channel. Clean the negative carefully and check the scan for any remaining defects.
Check that the film holder, connection, software and file output are right for your film and computer. Make a test scan and open the file on the system you’ll use to deliver it to the client. If you’re using a discontinued Epson model, also check the condition and functionality of the holders and software.
Outsourcing may be a good option if you have a large number of images, valuable images or too little time for scanning and correction. The Consumentenbond lists the quantity, quality required and time available as factors to consider. Ask in advance which resolution, files and corrections are included in the service.
Not automatically: according to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, identifiable people in images are personal data. For the specific job, consider the applicable GDPR legal basis, the purpose of any disclosure and appropriate security measures. Handing images over to a client isn’t necessarily the same as publishing them publicly.