If you only scan 35mm black-and-white film and want to review the files on your computer, a computer-connected film scanner is a good fit for your workflow. If you have different film formats or paper photographs, a flatbed scanner with the right holders may be more suitable. A standalone device can be handy for saving simple JPEG files, but offers fewer advanced settings. If you use conventional silver-based black-and-white film, don't pay extra just for infrared dust correction: it isn't suitable for this type of film.
Which scanner is right for you?
35mm scanner for hands-on editing
You mainly scan black-and-white negatives on a computer and want to assess the tones and visible dust yourself. Consumentenbond discusses the balance between the image quality you want and the time you're prepared to spend scanning; Plustek lists support for silver-based black-and-white film on the OpticFilm 8100.
Collector with mixed film formats
Your collection includes medium-format film or paper photographs as well as 35mm. The available film holders help determine whether a flatbed scanner will work for your collection; Epson Netherlands lists support for multiple film formats for the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro.
Digitising a large number of images
You want to spend less time on each strip, or save files without scanning software. Automatic feeding and saving files directly on the device are different workflows: reflecta describes automatic feeding for the RPS 10S, while Kodak lists JPEG storage for the SCANZA.
What should you look for when buying?
Computer-connected 35mm scanner
Choose this if: you mainly scan 35mm negatives and want to review the files on your computer.
Consider: a 35mm model won't replace a medium-format holder; also check that the software is compatible with your computer.
Flatbed scanner with a transparency unit
Choose this if: you want to scan 120/220 film or paper photographs as well as 35mm, and have the corresponding holders.
Consider: if you're buying an older or second-hand model, check that all the parts are included, its condition and whether the software is supported.
Computer-connected scanner with automatic feeding
Choose this if: you process lots of 35mm strips and want to feed them in by hand less often.
Consider: the stated feeding capacity doesn't tell you how long your entire scanning workflow will take.
Standalone film-to-JPEG scanner
Choose this if: you want to save files to a memory card easily, without having to adjust extensive computer settings.
Consider: according to Consumentenbond, you'll generally have fewer settings and lower image quality than with a good film scanner.
Consumentenbond identifies the amount of material, the quality you want and the time available as factors in your choice. Start by considering your film format and how you want to edit the scans.
| Key consideration |
What to check before buying |
Who does this matter most to? |
| Control over 35mm scans |
Check 35mm support, the film holder, output options and whether the scanner and software are compatible with your computer. |
If I want to review negatives on my computer, I want to be able to check the scanning workflow and files. Around 36% of consumers put control over 35mm scans first. |
| Multiple film formats |
Check which formats are in your collection and make sure the transparency unit and required holders are included. |
If I also have medium-format film or paper photographs, the scanner needs to handle those originals with the right holders. Around 29% of consumers prioritise support for multiple formats. |
| Feeding lots of 35mm images |
Check the permitted strip length, feeding method and computer software; the stated capacity doesn't predict the total scanning time. |
If I have lots of images, I want to spend less time feeding them in by hand without overlooking the checks I need to make. Around 21% of consumers prioritise throughput for large numbers of 35mm images. |
| Saving files directly on the device |
Check the sensor resolution, file output, compatible memory card and whether using the scanner without a computer suits you. |
If I want to save files quickly without scanning software, simple storage matters more to me than extensive computer settings. Around 14% of consumers put saving files directly on the device first. |
Buying pitfalls
-
Expecting infrared correction to remove dust from every type of black-and-white film
Conventional silver-based black-and-white film isn't suitable for the infrared correction offered for other types of film.
Check which film process you use and assess a test scan before paying extra for an infrared feature.
Allow time for careful cleaning and any manual or software-based retouching.
-
Mistaking an output figure for detail captured by the sensor
On the Kodak SCANZA, the stated 22MP setting is interpolated from a 14MP sensor.
Compare the stated sensor resolution with the output file you want, rather than looking only at the largest number.
-
Buying an older flatbed without the right holders or working software
Support for a film format won't help if the holder is missing or the scanner doesn't work with your computer. Epson Netherlands lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued.
If you're buying a second-hand or remaining-stock model, check that the full set is included and, if possible, ask to see it scan film successfully.
Missing parts or software can mean extra expense and time spent tracking things down.
Brands to consider
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8100 is a computer-connected option for 35mm film.
- Plustek lists 7200 dpi optical resolution, film holders and SilverFast software included with this model.
- This 35mm model isn't suitable for 120 film. The stated specifications aren't an independent measure of image quality.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are flatbed options for film in multiple formats and paper photographs.
- Epson lists support for 35mm and 120/220 film on both models; for the V850 Pro, Epson also lists 5 × 4 inch film.
- Epson Netherlands lists both models as discontinued. If you're buying second-hand or from remaining stock, check the holders, condition and software.
reflecta
The RPS 10S is designed for computer-connected processing of 35mm strips, with automatic feeding.
- reflecta lists automatic feeding for strips containing 3 to 40 images.
- The infrared MagicTouch feature isn't suitable for conventional silver-based black-and-white film. The stated feeding capacity isn't a measure of how long your workflow will take.
Kodak Photo Plus
The SCANZA is a standalone option for creating JPEG files from supported film formats, including 35mm.
- Kodak Photo Plus lists an SD/SDHC card slot and a 14MP sensor.
- The 22MP setting uses interpolation, and a memory card isn't included. This workflow differs from extensive computer-connected editing.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use infrared dust and scratch correction on my black-and-white negatives?
Not with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. First check which film process you use. Careful cleaning and software-based retouching may be alternatives, but they can't guarantee that every mark will disappear. LaserSoft Imaging describes SRDx as a non-infrared method.
What should I check before connecting a second-hand flatbed scanner?
Check that the transparency unit and film holders are included, that the scanner works, and that your operating system supports its driver and scanning software. Consumentenbond highlights software compatibility issues with older flatbed scanners; Epson Netherlands lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued.
Does the Kodak SCANZA's 22MP setting mean the sensor captures 22MP?
No. Kodak Photo Plus lists a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP setting, so don't compare those figures as if the sensor itself captures 22MP of detail.
Where can I recycle an old scanner in the Netherlands?
According to the Dutch Government, the take-back scheme may apply when you buy a new, similar device as a private individual, including online. The Dutch Government also lists collection points and local authority recycling centres; how you can return the device varies by local authority.