Who is this guide for?

Players with one console and room for a second player

If you want to play with someone else on a PS5, Xbox or Nintendo console you already own, first check that the controller is compatible with your system. Sony, Xbox and Nintendo each set out which systems and models their controllers support.

PC players who want to play together locally

If you want to use two controllers on a PC, check whether the game recognises both separately and whether the connection you choose is suitable. Xbox warns that using multiple controllers over Bluetooth can work differently depending on the device.

Players with limited floor space

If you want to arrange seating flexibly in a small room, you may prefer to avoid cables. Remember to factor in pairing and charging or batteries too, so everything is ready when it’s time to play.

What should you look for in an extra controller?

First check your console or PC and your game’s local play mode. Then consider the connection, how many people are playing and how the controller is powered.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
System and game Check the exact controller model and whether your basketball game supports local play with extra controllers. If I’m buying a second controller, I want to be sure it works with my system and in the game’s local play mode. Around 36% of consumers say compatibility is their main reason for buying.
Cables and connection Check whether the model connects to your device using the wireless connection you want or USB. If you’re using a PC, check in advance that it recognises both controllers. In a small room, I want to position players without a cable crossing the walkway. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a cable-free set-up.
Controls for each player Check how many players the game supports locally and whether it supports one Joy-Con or a full controller per player. If two people want to play, I want to know whether each person can use their own suitable controller. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on the number of individual player positions.
Power Check whether the controller uses a rechargeable battery or AA batteries, and what’s included with the version you choose. When playing a match at home, I don’t want to stop halfway through to charge the controller or look for batteries. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on power and running costs.
Extra features Check whether the game supports extra buttons, haptics or trigger effects. These features won’t necessarily work in every game. Once I’ve sorted out the basic controls, I can see whether extra buttons or feedback would add anything to my game. Around 7% of consumers put additional features first.

How to avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a model name refers to just one version

    The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for Windows and Android, while the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth supports different platforms, including Switch. The versions are not interchangeable.

    Before buying, check the full model name and the platform list for that specific version.

  • Assuming that a controller you can pair will always add another player slot

    A console may support multiple controllers, but not every game or play mode will support the same number of local players. Nintendo also notes that a single Joy-Con can be used as a controller only if the software supports that play style.

    Check your basketball game’s local play mode, player count and required controls.

  • Leaving power requirements until after you’ve bought it

    Xbox lists AA batteries and a compatible rechargeable battery pack as power options for its wireless controller. The option you choose determines what you’ll need to have ready.

    Check what’s in the box and make sure you have suitable batteries or a compatible battery pack before you play.

Brands to consider

PlayStation

DualSense is an option if you play on PS5 and want a full-size second controller.

  • Sony lists Bluetooth and USB as connection options.
  • Haptics and trigger effects depend on the game, so don’t assume every basketball game uses them.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Xbox lists Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth as connection options.
  • When connecting multiple controllers to a PC via Bluetooth, performance can vary by device. Power comes from AA batteries or a compatible battery pack.

Nintendo

A Joy-Con can be used as a separate controller with compatible Switch software. There’s also a full-size Pro Controller for Switch 2.

  • Nintendo explains that a single Joy-Con can be used as a controller if the software supports that play style.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed exclusively for Switch 2, not the original Switch.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C is available in versions with different platform support.

  • 8BitDo lists Windows and Android support for the Wireless version and Switch support for the Bluetooth version.
  • Check the full model name and system requirements: the two versions are not interchangeable.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wireless Controller Rechargeable is a full-size controller for a Switch set-up.

  • PowerA lists a rechargeable battery and Switch 2 support for this model.
  • PowerA does not list a C button, HD rumble, IR or amiibo NFC for this version. These features are not automatically available on other models from the brand.

Controller options on Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for Xbox and Windows set-ups, PS5 and Nintendo Switch or Switch 2 set-ups, as well as a controller whose product name says it supports multiple platforms. Before buying, check that the exact version is compatible with your system and game.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

An option for an Xbox or Windows set-up; the product name mentions Xbox Series and PC.

View on Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

An option for a PS5 set-up; the product name also mentions PC, Mac and mobile devices.

According to the product information, the haptic feedback and adaptive triggers mentioned are only available in compatible games.

View on Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, Black-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller (Black-Bundle Edition)

Worth considering for a PC or Switch set-up; the product name also mentions iOS and Android. Check that your game and device support this version.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

An option for an original Nintendo Switch set-up; also check that your basketball game supports local multiplayer with this controller.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

An option for Nintendo Switch 2; according to Nintendo, this Pro Controller is designed exclusively for that system.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need an online subscription to play NBA 2K26 locally on PS5?

The Dutch PlayStation Store lists one to four players for NBA 2K26 and lists PS Plus separately as a requirement for online play. Check how many players your chosen local play mode supports in the game.

Can each player hold one Joy-Con on Switch?

Not in every game. Nintendo says a Joy-Con held horizontally can be used as a separate controller if the software supports that play style. So check the controls for your basketball game.

How do you get a second DualSense ready to use?

According to Sony, first connect the second DualSense to your PS5 while it’s switched on using a USB cable, then press the PS button. Once the controller has charged sufficiently, you can unplug it. You can use up to four controllers at the same time on PS5.

What can you do if a controller you bought online is faulty?

According to the Dutch government, if a product is faulty you may be entitled to a free repair, replacement or refund. There is no fixed statutory guarantee period for all products in the Netherlands; the assessment depends on factors including the product and the circumstances.

What is the cooling-off period for online purchases in the Netherlands?

The Dutch government states that sellers must tell you about the cooling-off period when you buy online. It is usually 14 days. Check the information provided with your order, and remember that the cooling-off period is separate from your statutory rights if a product is faulty.