Who is this advice for?

Basketball player with a dedicated console

You want to make sure a replacement or second controller works with your PS5, Xbox or Switch 2. Check the exact version against your system: similar model names don’t necessarily mean the same compatibility. Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo specify compatibility for each product range.

Player sharing a room

You play while someone else is in the bedroom and want to choose how you hear game audio and adjust the controller’s sound. Sony describes a volume control for the DualSense speaker on PS5, but this won’t control every sound in the room.

PC player with limited space to play

You’re choosing between the freedom to move without a cable and a fixed wired setup. Check that the exact controller version is designed for your Windows system, and consider where you can safely run a cable.

What should you consider when choosing?

First check compatibility with your gaming platform and game. Then consider the audio and the practical layout of your playing space.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the exact console or PC version and the game version. If you play on your existing console or PC, you’ll want to know whether the controller works with that specific setup. Compatibility is the top priority for around 36% of consumers.
Sound in the room Check headset use and any controller audio settings. When you share a bedroom, you’ll want to hear game audio without assuming that a headset also mutes button sounds or your voice. Around 29% of consumers put their room-mate’s needs first.
Connection and playing space Compare wired and wireless play, and check the connection for your system. If space is limited, you’ll want a connection that suits the distance to your screen and the layout of the room. Connection and playing space are the biggest considerations for around 21% of consumers.
Cost and length of use Check which accessories you’ll need and what any additional cover includes. Before you buy, find out whether you’ll also need a cable, power supply or compatible headset, and whether extra cover offers any added value. Total cost and length of use are top priorities for around 14% of consumers.

What to watch out for when buying

  • Assuming every Switch controller works with every Switch

    Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller can only be used with the Switch 2.

    Check your console’s full name and the compatibility of the exact controller version before ordering.

  • Assuming a headset socket means a quiet gaming setup

    A headset can keep game audio in your ears, but it won’t mute button sounds or your voice. The DualSense also has its own speaker, whose volume can be adjusted on PS5, according to PlayStation Support.

    Check where your headset connects to your system and see which controller sounds you can adjust separately.

  • Buying an extended warranty without considering your existing rights

    Additional cover may overlap with your statutory rights. The Dutch government states that the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period.

    Compare the terms of any additional cover with your statutory rights, and keep your proof of purchase. If a product is faulty, contact the seller.

Brands to compare

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is an option for PS5 players who want to adjust the controller speaker on their console.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers; how they work depends on the game.
  • The DualSense Midnight Black version reviewed isn’t described as PS4-compatible. PlayStation Support explains how to adjust the DualSense volume on PS5.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for players looking for a controller for Xbox and PC.

  • For the wireless product range reviewed, Microsoft lists Windows PC and Xbox Series X|S compatibility.
  • Check the power supply, headset socket and exact version before choosing accessories.

Nintendo

The Switch 2 Pro Controller suits a Switch 2 setup where an audio socket is useful.

  • Nintendo lists an audio socket and assignable GL and GR buttons.
  • According to Nintendo, this model doesn’t work with the original Switch.

PowerA

The wired Xbox version reviewed is an option if you want a fixed cable setup and a headset socket.

  • For SKU 1519365-01, PowerA lists a detachable 10 ft cable and support for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and PC.
  • These features apply to that version and don’t necessarily apply to other PowerA models.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows PC, while the separate Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is designed for Switch.

  • For the Wireless version, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz and USB on Windows, and Bluetooth on Android.
  • Don’t buy based on the shared Ultimate 2C name alone: the two versions are designed for different platforms.

Joybuy products for this gaming setup

This selection focuses on Xbox and PC setups, with additional controllers for Switch and mobile use.

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

A wireless option for playing on Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One or a Windows 10 PC. If you’re using a headset, check that the connections are suitable for your headset and system.

The product information lists AA batteries for wireless use and USB-C for wired use.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G8 Galileo Plus Bluetooth

GameSir G8 Galileo Plus Bluetooth

The product name positions this mobile controller for Switch, iOS, Android, tablets and PC. Check compatibility with your exact device before choosing.

The product information lists an adjustable magnetic phone holder. Check that it fits the device you want to use.

View at Joybuy
Hyperkin Duchess wired Xbox controller, black

Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller for Xbox, Black

A wired version for anyone looking for an Xbox controller with a fixed connection. The product name lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10|11.

Allow for the cable between your playing space and system, and check that it can be routed safely and conveniently.

View at Joybuy
Hyperkin Xenon wired Xbox controller, red

Hyperkin Xenon Wired Controller for Xbox, Red

A wired Xbox controller for a fixed gaming setup. The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10|11. Check that your game and system are compatible with this version.

This wired controller uses a Type-C cable to connect your playing space to your system.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, White Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, White Bundle Edition

An option to compare if you play on PC or Switch; the product information also lists iOS and Android. Check which connection and compatibility apply to your specific device.

The product name specifies the White Bundle Edition. Check which items are included with this version before choosing accessories.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a Switch 2 Pro Controller with the original Switch?

No. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller can only be used with the Switch 2. Check your console model before choosing a controller.

How can I make my DualSense quieter while playing?

On PS5, you can adjust the DualSense controller speaker volume via Settings > Accessories > Controller (General), according to PlayStation Support. This won’t change the sound of the buttons, your TV or your voice.

Do I only need a controller with a headset socket for GameChat on Switch 2?

No. Nintendo also lists a paid Nintendo Switch Online membership and phone verification when setting up GameChat. Check the current requirements for your account and how you plan to use it.

What if I don’t like a controller I bought online, or it’s faulty?

For online purchases from a business, the Dutch government says you generally have 14 days to change your mind; this is separate from your statutory warranty rights. If a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for resolving the issue. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period.

Are there European rules for wireless controllers?

The European Commission’s Radio Equipment Directive sets out a framework for radio equipment placed on the EU market. The Dutch government points to CE marking for electronic products. This does not, by itself, confirm that a specific controller version has been checked for compliance.