Who is this buying guide for?

Host with extra players

You want to have a suitable controller ready for everyone. Start by checking the platform, game version and how many people can play locally. PlayStation documents the controller limit for PS5; the game determines separately how many players it supports.

Sofa player who wants to go wireless

You want to play wirelessly during a night on the sofa. Check how each model connects and what powers it, as options vary by model and platform.

PC player with multiple gamepads

You want to play with others on one Windows PC. Check both that the game supports local multiplayer and that your PC recognises each controller using your chosen connection.

What should you look for when buying?

Start with the exact game version and system. Then work out how many players need their own controller, and only then choose between a wired or wireless setup.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Platform and game Compare the full controller model name and game version with your console or PC. Also check which connection that combination supports. If I’m playing on my existing system, I want to know in advance whether both the controller and game version are suitable. Platform and game compatibility is the main buying concern for around 36% of consumers.
Number of players Check the local player limit and game mode for the specific game; the number of connected controllers isn’t necessarily the same. If everyone wants to play during the match, I want to know how many separate player controls the game supports. For around 29% of consumers, the number of usable player controls comes first.
Connection and power Check whether the model is wireless or wired, what power source it needs and whether a cable can safely reach the seating area. If I want to arrange the seating freely, I consider cables, connections and power before the evening begins. For around 21% of consumers, this practical setup is the main buying concern.
Buttons and controls Compare the shape and button layout, and check whether extra features can be used in your chosen game. If I’m playing several matches, I want a button layout that suits the way I play. Controls and comfort are the main consideration for around 14% of consumers.

Common pitfalls

  • Choosing a controller without checking the game and platform

    Compatibility with another console or PC doesn’t automatically mean a controller will work with your setup. For example, Nintendo says the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

    Before buying, compare the full model name with your system and check that the controller is supported in the local game mode you want to play.

  • Assuming four connected controllers mean four local players

    Being able to connect several controllers and a game’s player limit are two different things. PlayStation lists NBA 2K26 on PS5 as supporting one to four players, and separately documents support for up to four DualSense controllers in use at the same time on PS5.

    Check the information for the right game version and mode alongside your system’s capabilities.

  • Assuming ‘wireless’ always means the same type of connection

    According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless uses a 2.4GHz receiver or a cable on Windows; Bluetooth is listed for Android.

    Check the connection options for your operating system and make sure the required port is available.

  • Leaving power and cables until game night

    A battery-powered controller and a wired controller need different preparation. With a cable, you’ll also need to consider how it will reach the USB port.

    Check the power source and connection in advance, and don’t leave a cable loose across a walkway.

Brands to consider

PlayStation

A DualSense is a good option if you need an extra controller for a PS5 setup.

  • PlayStation documents that up to four DualSense controllers can be used at the same time on PS5.
  • That console limit doesn’t tell you how many local players an individual game supports.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows PC.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox Wireless for consoles, and Bluetooth or a cable for supported PC setups.
  • Check the power and connection options for each model, as well as the game’s local multiplayer support.

Nintendo

Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller offer different controller setups for Nintendo Switch 2.

  • Nintendo explains that a single Joy-Con 2 can be used as a controller, depending on the software and play style.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired Controller is a wired, officially licensed option for Xbox Series X|S.

  • PowerA lists two mappable buttons and a 10 ft USB-C cable.
  • The cable affects where players can sit; PowerA says features may vary by game.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows using a 2.4GHz receiver or cable.

  • According to 8BitDo, this model supports Windows and Android.
  • The manufacturer lists Bluetooth for Android. Don’t assume this means it supports Bluetooth on Windows or is compatible with consoles.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection at Joybuy is aimed at local matches on Nintendo Switch 2, PS5 and Xbox or Windows setups.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller for Nintendo Switch 2

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller (Bluetooth) for Nintendo Switch 2

An option to consider if you’re looking for a wireless controller for Nintendo Switch 2.

The product name lists Bluetooth, RGB lighting, TMR sticks, 40-hour battery life, four RGB modes and two programmable buttons.

The product name also lists compatibility with Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED; check that your game supports the controller setup you want.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

An option for a PS5 setup if you’re looking for an extra DualSense controller for a local match.

The product name lists PS5, PC, Mac and mobile devices; check compatibility and connection type for the system you’ll be playing on.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

An option for local play on a compatible Xbox or Windows PC.

The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows PCs, as well as Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth and USB-C. Check which connection works with your system and model.

View at Joybuy
GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller with Hall Effect sticks and triggers, blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller, blue

A wired option for a compatible Xbox or Windows PC setup with an accessible USB port.

The product name lists Hall Effect sticks and triggers, and compatibility with Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11.

The wired connection limits your playing distance to the setup and cable length.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

A separate gamepad to consider if you play on Nintendo Switch 2 and want a traditional controller for one player.

The model name lists Nintendo Switch 2. Nintendo says this controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How many controllers should I have ready for a basketball game on PS5?

Check the player limit for the exact game version. PlayStation lists NBA 2K26 on PS5 as supporting one to four players and documents support for up to four DualSense controllers in use at the same time on PS5. Connect any extra controllers in advance.

Can each Joy-Con 2 be assigned to a separate basketball player?

Not without checking the game’s play style. Nintendo says a single Joy-Con 2 held horizontally can work as a separate controller, depending on the software and supported play style. Also check how many players the game version you’ve chosen supports.

Does ‘four controllers connected’ mean four players can play locally?

No. The number of controllers a system can use and a game’s local player limit are separate requirements. Check both for the game version and mode you want to use.

Which connection does the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless use on Windows?

According to 8BitDo, this model uses a 2.4GHz receiver or a cable on Windows. The manufacturer lists Bluetooth for Android, so check the connection for the operating system you’ll be playing on.

Do I need to play online or take out a subscription to use an extra PS5 controller?

No, not just to connect an extra controller. The PlayStation page for NBA 2K26 on PS5 lists online play as optional and PS Plus as required for online play. Check the requirements for the game mode you want to use.