Who is this buying guide for?

Console owner with a second player

You want to play together on the console you already own. So check that both the controller and the local game mode are compatible with your console and game version. The PlayStation Store Netherlands and Nintendo provide compatibility and gameplay information for their own platforms.

PC player who wants to play together locally

You want to use multiple controllers on one PC, so you’ll need to check the connection, whether the game recognises them and whether it has a local mode. Steam describes the modes and controller support for NBA 2K27; Xbox Support notes that using multiple controllers via PC Bluetooth can affect performance.

Sofa player in a bright living room

You want to sit comfortably while taking cables, charging and screen reflections into account. Manufacturer information from PlayStation, Xbox and PowerA can help you compare connections and power options, while LG offers advice on positioning your screen to reduce distracting light.

What should you look for?

Start by checking compatibility with your console or PC and your game. Then check the local mode, connection and power options. Finally, compare the controls and what’s included in the box.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Compatibility Check the exact console model, the controller’s full model name and the supported connection. If I’m looking for an extra controller for the console or PC I already own, I want to be sure the combination will work. Around 31% of consumers put compatibility first.
Local game mode Check the edition, local mode and player count; online player numbers don’t tell you this automatically. If an extra controller is for a match on one screen, I want to know whether my edition of the game supports local multiplayer. Around 25% of consumers say a working local match is their top priority.
Cable and power Compare wireless use, battery type or batteries, included cables and the cable route to the sofa. If I’m playing from the sofa, I want room to move without batteries running out unexpectedly or an awkward cable route. Around 19% of consumers prioritise freedom of movement, cables and power.
Controls and grip Compare the button layout and grip; check separately whether the game supports any extra features. If I play often, I want controls that feel familiar and suit my preferences. Around 13% of consumers prioritise grip and controls.
Accessories and aftercare Check what’s included in the box and who to contact if something goes wrong. If I want to factor in extra accessories or help with a fault, I want to know what comes with this model and what rights I have in relation to the seller. Around 12% of consumers prioritise accessories and aftercare.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming Bluetooth means universal compatibility

    A wireless connection doesn’t automatically mean a controller will work with every console. Manufacturers list compatible systems for each model.

    Before buying, check the exact console model, the controller’s full model name and the supported connection.

  • Confusing online player numbers with local multiplayer

    A listing that mentions online multiplayer doesn’t tell you how many people can play on the same console or PC.

    Check the local mode in your edition of the game and whether each player can use a compatible controller.

  • Assuming a wireless controller is always rechargeable or comes with a cable

    Power options and included accessories vary by model and version. The Xbox model mentioned uses AA batteries; PlayStation says its separately sold white DualSense doesn’t include a cable.

    Compare the power options and box contents for the exact version you’re considering.

  • Confusing an additional commercial warranty with your statutory rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between your statutory rights in relation to the seller and any extra commercial cover.

    Read exactly what an additional service covers, and remember that your statutory rights still apply if something goes wrong.

Relevant brands

PlayStation

The DualSense is designed for PS5 and is also listed by PlayStation for PC, Mac and mobile.

  • PlayStation lists a built-in rechargeable battery and USB-C. Haptic feedback and adaptive trigger support depend on the game.
  • PlayStation says the separately sold white version doesn’t include a cable.

Xbox

The wireless controller is designed for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a hybrid D-pad and grip features for the controller.
  • The official model reviewed uses AA batteries. Xbox Support warns that using multiple controllers via PC Bluetooth can affect performance.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is a traditional controller for Switch users and, according to Nintendo, can also connect wirelessly to Switch 2.

  • Nintendo estimates battery life at around 40 hours, depending on the software and features used.
  • On Switch 2, the HOME button on this older controller can’t wake the system from sleep mode.

PowerA

According to PowerA, the Enhanced Wired Controller is licensed for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows.

  • PowerA lists two mappable buttons and a detachable 3 m cable.
  • Check whether a 3 m cable will reach conveniently and safely across your living room.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth Controller is designed for supported Switch and Windows setups.

  • 8BitDo lists a charging dock and Switch 2 support following a firmware update.
  • Check the full model name: other Ultimate versions may have different connections or compatibility.

Controller options at Joybuy

This selection at Joybuy includes controllers for Xbox and Windows, PS5 and Switch 2, as well as a PC and Switch controller. Check the local mode for each game and the exact version of each controller.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Ideal if you play on Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One or Windows 10/11 and want to play wirelessly from the sofa.

Supports Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth, and uses two included AA batteries.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

An option for an extra local player on PS5; check that your edition of the game supports the local mode you want.

The product description lists a built-in rechargeable battery and Bluetooth. No cable is included.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 White-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 (White-Bundle Edition)

Ideal if you’re looking for a controller for PC or Switch and want to choose between different connection options.

The product description lists wired, Bluetooth and wireless dongle connections, as well as TMR sticks and programmable rear buttons.

View at Joybuy
Sony PS5 DualSense Edge Controller Black

Sony PS5 DualSense Edge Controller Black

A PS5 controller for anyone who values customisable controls; check that the game supports the features you want.

The product description lists adjustable stick sensitivity and rear buttons. Replacement joystick modules are sold separately.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

Ideal if you’re looking for a controller specifically labelled as a Switch 2 Pro Controller.

The product description lists Bluetooth and HD Rumble. Also check whether your game version supports local matches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need an online subscription for two players on one screen?

Not necessarily: local and online play are different modes. The Dutch PS5 listing for NBA 2K27 states that it supports 1–4 players and requires PS Plus for online play. Check the mode and edition you want to use.

What should I check when connecting two controllers to a PC?

First, check that the game supports local multiplayer and your type of controller. Xbox Support says performance may be reduced when more than one controller is connected via PC Bluetooth; if necessary, check for another supported connection.

Can an older Nintendo Switch Pro Controller work with Switch 2?

Yes, Nintendo confirms that it can connect wirelessly to Switch 2. The HOME button on this older controller can’t wake Switch 2 from sleep mode; you can charge it using a USB cable connected to the Switch 2 dock.

Will a different controller make the TV picture easier to see in bright daylight?

No, reflections are down to the screen and its position, not your choice of controller. For distracting light, LG recommends, among other things, positioning the TV so it faces away from a window.

Who should I contact if a controller develops a fault too soon under normal use?

Contact the seller: according to ACM ConsuWijzer, they’re responsible if the product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed general two-year period for this. Online purchases often also come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions.