Joybuy Insights

Choosing a baby dummy: consider age, shape and material

A baby dummy may seem like a simple product, but small differences can affect how easy it is to use. One baby may accept a round teat, while another prefers an anatomical shape. A teat that is too small or too large can also be awkward. If you focus only on colour, discounts or a familiar brand name, you may end up buying a dummy that your baby quickly rejects or that isn’t suitable for their age.

As a Joybuy Product Recommendation Officer, I filter the most important product specifications to help you compare options with confidence. Read on to find out what to look for in a Difrax dummy, a BIBS dummy and other age-specific models.

Three common buying pitfalls

1. Ignoring the age recommendation

A dummy for 0-6 months is designed for a different mouth size from a dummy for 6+ months or 6-12 months. Even so, parents sometimes use different sizes interchangeably when they focus mainly on the design.

Always check:

  • The recommended age on the product page.
  • Whether the size refers to the shield, the teat or both.
  • Whether your baby is now ready for a larger size.

The product name for the Difrax Uni Teether Round says 6+ months, while the description provided also mentions 0-6 months. This is exactly the kind of inconsistency where you should check the latest product information and packaging before buying.

2. Treating “natural” or “orthodontic” as a guarantee

A round dummy and an anatomical dummy feel different. An anatomical teat often has a flattened or asymmetrical shape. A round dummy has a symmetrical, rounded sucking shape. No shape is automatically accepted by every baby.

Brands can describe the features of their designs, but that doesn’t mean a particular dummy is suitable for every child. According to BIBS’ product description, the anatomical shape is intended to support tongue movement and sucking technique. This is a product claim made by the brand, not a guarantee for every child.

3. Prioritising extra features over care

A glow-in-the-dark dummy may be easier to find at night. That’s handy, but the essentials matter more: a suitable size, an undamaged teat and a shield with enough ventilation holes.

Check the teat every day. Replace the dummy if you notice cracks, damage, discolouration or changes in shape. Difrax advises in its product information that a dummy should be replaced approximately every six weeks with daily use. Always follow the instructions for the specific model.

Important features to consider when choosing a baby dummy

Age and size

Choose a dummy for 0-6 months for newborns and young babies when the manufacturer recommends it for this age group. There are models for older babies aged 6+ months, 6-12 months and sometimes 6-18 months.

A larger size isn’t automatically more comfortable. Check the recommended age, the shape of the shield and the length of the teat. If you’re unsure, for example when your baby is moving between age groups, check the product packaging or the manufacturer’s instructions.

Shape: round or anatomical

A round dummy has a symmetrical sucking shape. This can be handy if the dummy is regularly turned around. According to its product description, the Difrax LOVI Prime has a symmetrical shape and is available as a duo pack.

An anatomical dummy has a specific top and bottom. According to the product description, the BIBS Colour Anatomical Size 1 has an orthodontically shaped teat. BIBS says the design is intended to follow natural tongue movement. With this type, make sure the teat is positioned correctly.

Material and product information

Look for clear information about the material. The selected products include silicone and natural rubber latex.

  • The Difrax LOVI Prime is described as being made from 100% medical-grade silicone, BPA-free and odourless.
  • The BIBS Colour Size 1 is described as being made from natural rubber latex.
  • BIBS states that several of its models are free from BPA, PVC and phthalates.
  • EN 1400+A2 is listed as a certification reference in the product information for the BIBS models.

Choosing a BPA-free dummy is understandable, but also check whether you need to consider a latex allergy. Material information doesn’t replace daily checks for wear and tear.

Our recommendations for different uses

Suitable for: Budget-conscious first-time buyers
Difrax Natural Soother, 0-6 Months, Silicone, White/Pink, 2 Pieces

Difrax Soother Natural 0-6 Months Silicone White/Pink - 2 Pieces

Why it suits this profile: A set of 2 is handy at home, when you’re out and about or as a spare. This model is intended for babies aged 0-6 months.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The age is clearly stated in the product name. According to the description, the shield has a nose cut-out and ventilation holes.

Key benefit & highlights

Duo pack; silicone design; glow-in-the-dark button according to the product description.

Suitable for: Buyers looking for premium quality
BIBS Colour Dummy, 2 Pieces, Size 1, Woodchuck Blush

BIBS Colour Teat 2 Pieces Size 1 Woodchuck Blush

Why it suits this profile: This anatomical BIBS dummy is an option for parents looking to combine clear material information, a duo pack and a specific teat shape.

How this product avoids the pitfall

Size 1 is for 0-6 months. The product description states that the material is free from BPA, PVC and phthalates and refers to EN 1400+A2.

Key benefit & highlights

Two pieces; anatomical teat; natural rubber latex according to the product information.

Suitable for: Specific needs & frequent use
BIBS Colour Glow Dummy, 2 Pieces, Size 2, Sage Cloud

BIBS Colour Glow Teat 2 Pieces Size 2 Sage Cloud

Why it suits this profile: Handy for night-time use if you’re looking for a dummy with a visible handle. Size 2 is intended for the next age group; check the packaging for the exact age recommendation.

How this product avoids the pitfall

According to the product description, the glow-in-the-dark handle makes the dummy easier to find in the dark, but this doesn’t replace checking the age recommendation.

Key benefit & highlights

Duo pack; round teat; free from BPA, PVC and phthalates according to the product information.

Looking for more options?

We’ve put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about baby dummies

Which dummy is suitable for breastfeeding?

There’s no one-size-fits-all shape for a dummy used alongside breastfeeding. Some parents choose a round or symmetrical teat because, according to brand product descriptions, it mimics a natural sucking shape. The manufacturers position the BIBS Colour and Difrax LOVI Prime as options for this. Pay close attention to how your baby responds and, if you have questions about feeding or sucking, follow the advice of your midwife, health visitor or doctor.

How often should you replace a dummy?

Check the teat every day and replace the dummy immediately if it’s damaged. Difrax states that several of its models should be replaced approximately every six weeks with daily use. Even if a dummy still looks in good condition, it’s a good idea to follow the specific instructions on the packaging.

Is a pack of 2 dummies better value?

A pack of 2 dummies can be handy because you’ll have a spare for a walk, night-time feeds or cleaning. Don’t compare only the price per pack; also consider the age recommendation, material and care instructions. A duo pack is useful only if both dummies are suitable for your baby’s age and preferences.