In an untreated, reverberant space, start with a set-up that keeps the microphone close to the speaker; a higher recording resolution won’t remove recorded reverberation. Choose a recorder with a lapel microphone if the speaker moves, a handheld recorder if they can stand nearby, or a model with separate inputs if you want to record multiple sources. Make a test recording in the intended location and listen back to it; Shure explains that a microphone cannot effectively separate direct sound from reflections.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Speaker in a reverberant room
You want to record a single museum script clearly and can place the microphone close to your mouth or wear a lapel microphone. Shure’s guidance on microphone distance makes this positioning especially relevant when reflections are audible.
Mobile commentary creator
You record short pieces with a single voice in different locations and want a portable set-up that’s quick to check. Sprekende Geschiedenis recommends listening back to a short test recording through headphones.
Creator recording multiple sound sources
You want to connect or record voices or commentary separately from ambient sound. The number and type of inputs help determine which set-up is right; Zoom, for example, lists two XLR/TRS inputs for the H4essential.
What should you look for when buying?
Handheld recorder with built-in microphones
Suitable when: you can record one speaker in a fixed position and place the recorder close to their mouth.
Trade-off: you need very little extra equipment, but microphones placed further away will also pick up more reflections. Check that the input is suitable for any external microphone you may want to use.
Recorder with a lapel microphone
Suitable when: the speaker moves or you can’t position the recorder close enough to their mouth. The Tascam DR-10L Pro comes with a lapel microphone.
Trade-off: check the microphone’s position and listen for clothing noise; this is a different set-up from a recorder with multiple external microphones.
Recorder with separate microphone inputs
Suitable when: you want to record two voices separately, for example, or combine an external microphone with ambient recording. The Zoom H4essential has two XLR/TRS inputs and built-in X/Y microphones.
Trade-off: allow for a suitable microphone, cable and any necessary power supply; extra inputs won’t reduce reverberation without suitable microphone positioning.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Clear speech despite reverberation |
Can you position the built-in microphone nearby, or do you need a suitable external microphone? Listen to a test recording in the room. |
If I want to record one voice clearly in a reverberant space, I start by considering the distance between the speaker’s mouth and the microphone. Around 36% of consumers give clear speech in this situation top priority. |
| Quick, mobile recording |
Check the microphone position and controls, and whether you can listen back to a short recording through headphones. |
When I record short commentary pieces in different locations, I want a simple set-up that I can check straight away. Around 29% of consumers prioritise mobile recording with a single voice. |
| Recording multiple sources separately |
Count the sources you need to record separately at the same time, and check the input type and power requirements of the microphones. |
If I want to record voices or ambient sound separately, I look at the number of suitable inputs and tracks. Around 21% of consumers prioritise recording multiple sources separately. |
| Checking long takes |
Check supported storage, power options, remaining recording time and whether you can listen back to a test recording. |
For a longer session, I want to avoid the recording being interrupted by a lack of storage or power, or an audible fault. Around 14% of consumers give recording capacity and monitoring top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing 32-bit float with acoustic treatment
A recording format won’t stop reflections from the room reaching the microphone. Shure explains that a microphone cannot effectively separate direct sound from unwanted reflections.
First, assess a test recording made with the microphone close to the speaker; then choose the recording format that suits your work.
-
Comparing only the number of inputs
Two XLR/TRS inputs give you connection options, but they don’t provide a close-miking solution on their own or remove reverberation.
Decide in advance which sources you want to record at the same time, and check the connection and any power requirements for each microphone.
-
Starting a long recording without listening back first
A quick check can reveal audible recording issues before you record a longer script.
Check storage and power, make a short test recording and listen back to it through headphones.
Brands to compare
Zoom
The H1essential is a compact handheld recorder with built-in X/Y microphones and a 3.5mm input. The H4essential also has two XLR/TRS inputs for a set-up with external microphones.
- Zoom lists 32-bit float recording for both of these models.
- This recording format doesn’t prove that reverberation will disappear in an untreated room; choose based on microphone distance and the inputs you need.
Tascam
The DR-05XP has built-in stereo microphones and an external mini-jack input. The DR-10L Pro pairs a compact recorder with an included lapel microphone for recording a single voice up close.
- Tascam lists a 32-bit float mode for both models.
- The built-in microphones and lapel microphone need to be positioned differently; product specifications aren’t an independent listening comparison.
OM SYSTEM
According to OM SYSTEM, the LS-P5 has three built-in microphones, adjustable directionality and internal memory. It may be worth considering if you want flexibility from built-in microphones.
- OM SYSTEM lists 16 GB of internal memory and PCM recording up to 96 kHz/24 bit.
- A narrower recording angle doesn’t prove that commentary will be free of reverberation; assess how clear the speech is in the room where you’ll be recording.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is 32-bit float enough to keep reverberation out of my museum commentary?
No. Zoom and Tascam list 32-bit float recording for the models mentioned, but Shure explains that a microphone cannot effectively separate direct speech from recorded reflections. So focus on testing the microphone distance and the room.
What should I check just before recording?
Check the microphone, available storage and power. Make a short test recording and listen back to it through headphones; this lets you hear whether the recording sounds usable before you record the final take.
What if the recorder breaks down too soon after I buy it?
When you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands, the product must meet the expectations you were entitled to have of it. If it breaks down too soon during normal use, the seller must provide a free solution, according to ACM ConsuWijzer; a manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace this statutory right. The assessment depends on the circumstances.
Can I record other people or copyrighted music in published museum commentary?
A recording in which someone can be identified may contain personal data. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an organisation needs a valid GDPR legal basis to collect and use personal data; consent is one possible basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one. Copyright may also apply to protected music or other people’s texts. Check the rules of the museum where you’re recording, too: this information doesn’t establish general permission or a ban for every museum location.